Neutrino masses in the mirror twin Higgs with spontaneous ℤ2 breaking

Pedro Bittar, Davi B. Costa, Gustavo Burdman

TL;DR

This paper proposes a new extension to the Mirror Twin Higgs (MTH) model that elegantly solves two major puzzles in particle physics: the origin of neutrino masses and the hierarchy problem. By introducing new scalar particles (triplets) and a specific way of breaking a key symmetry, the model generates light Standard Model neutrino masses while simultaneously making their "mirror" counterparts very heavy, thus resolving cosmological tensions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Standard Model (SM) of particle physics, while incredibly successful, leaves several fundamental questions unanswered. Two of these are:

  1. The Hierarchy Problem: Why is the Higgs boson so much lighter than the Planck scale (the scale at which gravity becomes strong)? Quantum corrections tend to push the Higgs mass up to this high scale, requiring an unnatural fine-tuning of parameters to keep it at its observed value.
  2. Neutrino Masses: The SM, in its simplest form, predicts massless neutrinos. However, neutrino oscillation experiments have definitively shown that neutrinos do have mass, albeit very small.

The Mirror Twin Higgs (MTH) model offers a potential solution to the hierarchy problem by introducing a "mirror" sector with identical particles and symmetries, related by a $\mathbb{Z}_2$ symmetry. This setup can naturally explain the Higgs mass without fine-tuning. However, the original MTH model faces challenges, particularly with cosmological constraints related to "dark radiation" (extra relativistic particles in the early universe) and the generation of SM neutrino masses. This paper aims to address these shortcomings by modifying the MTH model.

Methods

The core of the proposed solution lies in introducing new particles and a specific symmetry-breaking mechanism:

  • Introducing SU(2) Triplets: The model adds two $SU(2)$ triplets of scalar fields, one for the Standard Model (SM) sector and one for the mirror sector. These triplets carry a hypercharge of 1.
  • Type-II Seesaw Mechanism: These triplets are crucial for generating neutrino masses. In the SM sector, the triplet, through a mechanism called "type-II seesaw," allows for the generation of small, but non-zero, masses for the SM neutrinos.
  • Spontaneous $\mathbb{Z}_2$ Symmetry Breaking: The model engineers a scenario where the $\mathbb{Z}_2$ symmetry (which relates the SM and mirror sectors) is spontaneously broken. This breaking is achieved through the vacuum expectation values (VEVs) of the scalar sector, particularly the VEV of the mirror triplet.
  • Hierarchy of VEVs: A key aspect is establishing a hierarchy of VEVs: $V \ll v < f < F$. Here, $v$ and $f$ are the VEVs of the SM and mirror Higgs doublets, respectively, while $V$ and $F$ are the VEVs of the SM and mirror triplets. This hierarchy is essential for the model's success.
  • Addressing Dark Radiation: The spontaneous $\mathbb{Z}_2$ breaking, coupled with the large VEV of the mirror triplet ($F$), results in very large masses for the "twin neutrinos" (the mirror counterparts of SM neutrinos). These heavy twin neutrinos are non-relativistic by the time of Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) and Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) formation, thus significantly reducing their contribution to dark radiation and alleviating cosmological constraints.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical model building and phenomenological predictions, not on fitting specific experimental datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unified Solution for Neutrino Masses and Hierarchy Problem: The model provides a single framework that addresses both the origin of neutrino masses and the hierarchy problem, a significant advantage over models that tackle these issues separately.
  • Heavy Twin Neutrinos as a Cosmological Solution: Making twin neutrinos heavy is a clever way to resolve the "dark radiation" problem in MTH scenarios, which has been a major hurdle for previous MTH models.
  • Type-II Seesaw as a Natural Fit: The type-II seesaw mechanism, implemented via the scalar triplets, naturally generates small SM neutrino masses and large twin neutrino masses due to the engineered VEV hierarchy.
  • Spontaneous $\mathbb{Z}_2$ Breaking as a Key Ingredient: The spontaneous breaking of the $\mathbb{Z}_2$ symmetry is not just a mechanism to generate VEVs but is crucial for differentiating the SM and mirror sectors in a way that leads to the desired mass spectrum for neutrinos.
  • Twin Majoron as a New Phenomenological Probe: The model predicts a "twin Majoron," a light pseudoscalar particle associated with the breaking of lepton number in the mirror sector. This particle could have observable cosmological and potentially other phenomenological consequences.

Key Results

  • Small SM Neutrino Masses: The model successfully generates small, realistic masses for SM neutrinos, consistent with experimental observations.
  • Large Twin Neutrino Masses: The twin neutrinos acquire masses of the order of the TeV scale, rendering them non-relativistic during early cosmological epochs.
  • Alleviated Cosmological Constraints: The heavy twin neutrinos significantly reduce the contribution to the effective number of relativistic degrees of freedom ($N_{\rm eff}$), bringing the model into agreement with current BBN and CMB data (within $1\sigma$). The predicted $\Delta N_{\rm eff} \approx 0.18$ is primarily due to the twin photon.
  • Collider Phenomenology: The model predicts new scalar particles (triplets) that could be searched for at colliders like the LHC. Constraints from direct searches for these triplets and from electroweak precision measurements are discussed.
  • Twin Majoron Constraints: The presence of a light twin Majoron is explored, with its potential impact on $N_{\rm eff}$ calculated. For a Majoron lighter than ~100 MeV, $\Delta N_{\rm eff} \approx 0.21$, which is still within current experimental limits.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Parameter Tuning: While the model is designed to be natural, some parameters, particularly those related to the mixing of visible and twin states, need to be tuned to avoid large invisible Higgs decay widths and to ensure a realistic scalar spectrum. The authors note that this tuning is of a similar nature to that found in other MTH models.
  • Domain Wall Problem: The exact $\mathbb{Z}_2$ symmetry of the model, if unbroken, could lead to the formation of domain walls in the early universe, which would be cosmologically problematic. The paper suggests that a very small explicit breaking of the $\mathbb{Z}_2$ symmetry, orders of magnitude smaller than other scales in the theory, can resolve this issue without significantly altering the model's predictions.
  • Future Experimental Tests: The paper highlights that future experiments, particularly CMB experiments with greater sensitivity to $N_{\rm eff}$, will be crucial in testing this model. Collider searches for the predicted scalar triplets and lepton flavor violation tests will also provide important constraints.
  • Further Exploration of Twin Majoron and Dark Matter: While the twin Majoron's cosmological impact is discussed, its full phenomenological implications and the potential for dark matter in this MTH framework are areas for future investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

A bstract We introduce a mirror twin Higgs model with spontaneous ℤ 2 symmetry breaking that ameliorates the constraints in twin Higgs cosmology and, at the same time, generates the Standard Model neutrino masses. The model features an SU(2) triplet with hypercharge 1 alongside its twin counterpart. Spontaneous breaking of both ℤ 2 and electroweak symmetry occurs in the scalar sector. The Standard Model neutrinos acquire small masses through the type-II seesaw mechanism. In contrast, their twin counterparts acquire large masses, effectively addressing the dark radiation problem in mirror twin Higgs scenarios. We study the impact of the model on the N eff. constraints, as well as on collider phenomenology.
BibTeX
@article{bittar2024neutrino,
  author = {Pedro Bittar and Davi B. Costa and Gustavo Burdman},
  title = {{Neutrino masses in the mirror twin Higgs with spontaneous ℤ2 breaking}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1007/jhep09(2024)106},
}

Loading related content...

Figure