Neutral-current background induced by atmospheric neutrinos at large liquid-scintillator detectors: III. Comprehensive prediction for low energy neutrinos

Jie Cheng, Min Li, Yufeng Li, Gao-Song Li, H. Q. Lu, Liangjian Wen

Abstract: Atmospheric neutrinos play a vital role in generating irreducible backgrounds in liquid-scintillator (LS) detectors via their neutral-current (NC) interactions with $^{12}$C nuclei. These interactions may affect a wide range of research areas from the MeV to GeV energy range, such as the reactor and geo neutrinos, diffuse supernova neutrino background (DSNB), dark matter, and nucleon decay searches. In this work, we extend our preceding paper, by conducting a first-time systematic exploration of NC backgrounds as low as the MeV region of reactor and geo neutrinos. We utilize up-to-date neutrino generator models from GENIE and NuWro, a TALYS-based nuclear deexcitation package and a GEANT4-based detector simulation toolkit for our complete calculation. Our primary focus is to predict the NC background for experimental searches of inverse-beta-decay signals below the 100 MeV visible energy. In order to have deeper understanding of the characteristics of atmospheric neutrino NC interactions in LS, we investigate the model dependence of NC background predictions by using various data-driven models, including the initial neutrino-nucleon interactions, nuclear ground-state structure, final-state interactions, nuclear deexcitation processes, and secondary interactions of final-state particles.

Introduction

Neutrino detectors like the Jiangmen Underground Neutrino Observatory (JUNO) are designed to capture incredibly rare events, such as Inverse Beta Decay (IBD) from reactor neutrinos or the Diffuse Supernova Neutrino Background (DSNB). However, atmospheric neutrinos—high-energy particles produced in Earth's atmosphere—can interact with the $^{12}$C nuclei in the detector's liquid scintillator through "neutral-current" (NC) interactions.

These interactions can knock out neutrons, protons, or gamma rays without changing the neutrino's identity. These secondary particles can mimic the "prompt + delayed" signal of an IBD event, creating an irreducible background. This paper addresses the challenge of predicting this background in the low-energy region (below 100 MeV), where previous models were less certain.

Methodology and Simulation Framework

The researchers employed a sophisticated "three-fold" simulation strategy to capture the complexity of these interactions, as illustrated in the schematic below.

Schematic of atmospheric neutrino neutral-current interactions with a $^{12}$C nucleus, showing primary interaction, final-state interactions (FSI), and nuclear deexcitation.
  1. Initial Interaction: Two primary neutrino event generators, GENIE and NuWro, were used to simulate the first hit of a neutrino on a nucleon inside a carbon nucleus. The study tested 11 different model configurations to evaluate how varying physics assumptions—such as the "axial mass" $M_A$ or nuclear ground-state models (e.g., Local Fermi Gas vs. Spectral Function)—impacted the results.
  2. Nuclear Deexcitation: Following the initial interaction, the remaining nucleus is often left in an excited state. The authors utilized the TALYS package to simulate the deexcitation process, which frequently involves the emission of additional particles that contribute to the background signal.
  3. Detector Simulation: Finally, GEANT4 was used to model the behavior of these particles within a JUNO-like detector, accounting for "quenching" effects and secondary interactions of fast neutrons.

To ensure a comprehensive exploration of model dependence, the study compared several preceding models with new configurations added specifically for this work.

Summary of the neutrino event generator models and nuclear physics parameters investigated in this study.

Key Insights

  • Model Sensitivity: The choice of nuclear model is the dominant source of uncertainty at low energies, with different models leading to a ~25% variation in predicted neutron production.
  • The Role of Deexcitation: Including nuclear deexcitation is essential; it increases the overall NC background rate by 6% to 9% and shifts the visible energy spectrum toward higher energies, potentially increasing overlap with supernova signals.
  • Secondary Neutron Interactions: Fast neutrons from the primary interaction often strike other carbon nuclei. This secondary process actually helps in background rejection, as it often creates multiple neutrons (multiplicity) that can be used to "tag" and reject the event.
  • The "Zero Kinetic Energy" Bug: The authors identified that certain GENIE versions produce nucleons with zero kinetic energy due to binding energy handling. They introduced "modified" models (Model-Gi') to correct this, which significantly impacted predicted neutron rates.

Results and Implications

The study provided specific background rate predictions for key energy windows:

  • Reactor Neutrino Window (0.7–12 MeV): The predicted NC background rate is $2.1 \pm 0.7 \text{ kt}^{-1} \text{ yr}^{-1}$. While this is only about 0.2% of the expected reactor signal at JUNO, it is critical for sub-percent precision measurements of neutrino mass ordering.
  • DSNB Window (12–30 MeV): The predicted rate is $2.9 \pm 0.4 \text{ kt}^{-1} \text{ yr}^{-1}$, which is roughly an order of magnitude higher than the expected DSNB signal. This underscores the necessity of advanced Pulse Shape Discrimination (PSD) techniques.
  • Uncertainty: The systematic uncertainty due to model choice is estimated at approximately 14% to 16%.

Conclusion

While the low-energy region still lacks sufficient experimental constraints, this work provides a vital roadmap for upcoming experiments. Future refinements will involve incorporating more sophisticated nuclear shell models and utilizing in-situ detector measurements—such as tracking specific isotopes like $^{11}$C—to further reduce background uncertainties in the search for the universe's most elusive particles.

Summary updated

Abstract

Atmospheric neutrinos play a vital role in generating irreducible backgrounds in liquid-scintillator (LS) detectors via their neutral-current (NC) interactions with $^{12}$C nuclei. These interactions may affect a wide range of research areas from the MeV to GeV energy range, such as the reactor and geo neutrinos, diffuse supernova neutrino background (DSNB), dark matter, and nucleon decay searches. In this work, we extend our preceding paper, by conducting a first-time systematic exploration of NC backgrounds as low as the MeV region of reactor and geo neutrinos. We utilize up-to-date neutrino generator models from GENIE and NuWro, a TALYS-based nuclear deexcitation package and a GEANT4-based detector simulation toolkit for our complete calculation. Our primary focus is to predict the NC background for experimental searches of inverse-beta-decay signals below the 100 MeV visible energy. In order to have deeper understanding of the characteristics of atmospheric neutrino NC interactions in LS, we investigate the model dependence of NC background predictions by using various data-driven models, including the initial neutrino-nucleon interactions, nuclear ground-state structure, final-state interactions, nuclear deexcitation processes, and secondary interactions of final-state particles.
BibTeX
@article{cheng2025neutral,
  author = {Jie Cheng and Min Li and Yufeng Li and Gao-Song Li and H. Q. Lu and Liangjian Wen},
  title = {{Neutral-current background induced by atmospheric neutrinos at large liquid-scintillator detectors: III. Comprehensive prediction for low energy neutrinos}},
  journal = {The European Physical Journal C},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1140/epjc/s10052-025-14009-z},
}
Figure