Neurodevelopmental milestones and associated behaviours are similar among healthy children across diverse geographical locations

José Villar, Michelle Fernandes, Manorama Purwar, Eleonora Staines-Urias, Paola Di Nicola, Leila Cheikh Ismail, Roseline Ochieng, Fernando C. Barros, Elaine Albernaz, César G. Victora, N. Kunnawar, Sophie Temple, Francesca Giuliani, Tamsin Sandells, Maria Carvalho, Eric O. Ohuma, Yasmin A. Jaffer, J. Alison Noble, Michael G. Gravett, Ruyan Pang, Ann Lambert, Enrico Bertino, Aris T. Papageorghiou, Cutberto Garza, Alan Stein, Zulfiqar A Bhutta, Stephen KennedyNature Communications 2019 · DOI

Abstract

It is unclear whether early child development is, like skeletal growth, similar across diverse regions with adequate health and nutrition. We prospectively assessed 1307 healthy, well-nourished 2-year-old children of educated mothers, enrolled in early pregnancy from urban areas without major socioeconomic or environmental constraints, in Brazil, India, Italy, Kenya and UK. We used a specially developed psychometric tool, WHO motor milestones and visual tests. Similarities across sites were measured using variance components analysis and standardised site differences (SSD). In 14 of the 16 domains, the percentage of total variance explained by between-site differences ranged from 1.3% (cognitive score) to 9.2% (behaviour score). Of the 80 SSD comparisons, only six were >±0.50 units of the pooled SD for the corresponding item. The sequence and timing of attainment of neurodevelopmental milestones and associated behaviours in early childhood are, therefore, likely innate and universal, as long as nutritional and health needs are met.

Introduction

For decades, the scientific community has debated whether "normal" child development is a product of cultural and geographical context or a universal biological blueprint. Historically, neurodevelopmental standards have been derived from populations in high-income, Western countries. This reliance on skewed data makes it difficult to determine if developmental lags in low-income regions are due to biological potential or cultural bias in the assessment tools. This study aims to determine if neurodevelopmental milestones—such as walking, talking, and cognitive problem-solving—are as universal as physical growth (height and weight) when environmental constraints are removed.

Methods

The study utilized data from the INTERGROWTH-21st Project, focusing on a "prescriptive" population of 1,307 healthy, well-nourished children at age 2. These children were recruited from five geographically diverse urban centers: Pelotas (Brazil), Nagpur (India), Turin (Italy), Nairobi (Kenya), and Oxford (UK).

Key methodological features included:

  • The INTER-NDA: A "culturally neutral" psychometric tool designed for administration by non-specialists, measuring 16 domains including cognition, language, and motor skills.
  • Standardized Testing: Supplemented by WHO motor milestone assessments and Cardiff visual tests.
  • Statistical Analysis: Variance components analysis was used to determine the proportion of variation attributable to the study site versus individual differences. Standardized Site Differences (SSD) measured deviations from the global average, with a threshold of ±0.5 Standard Deviations (SD) defining similarity.

Results

The analysis revealed overwhelming evidence for developmental similarity across the diverse geographical locations. In 14 of the 16 developmental domains, the percentage of variance explained by differences between countries was less than 9.2%. Notably, the cognitive score showed the least variation, with only 1.3% of total variance attributed to the child's location.

Variance components analysis showing the percentage of total variance explained by site differences across developmental and growth domains.

Out of 80 total comparisons (16 domains across 5 sites), only six showed a difference greater than 0.5 SD from the global mean. While cognitive and motor skills were nearly identical, "secondary" domains like negative behavior and emotional reactivity showed slightly higher variation (up to 14%), potentially reflecting cultural differences in parental perception or reporting.

Standardised site differences (SSD) for neurodevelopmental domains across five study sites.

Furthermore, 99% of children across all sites reached motor milestones like "standing alone" and "walking alone" within the same age windows established by the WHO, and 99% exhibited normal visual acuity.

Discussion

These findings suggest that observed global differences in child development are primarily driven by socioeconomic and educational disparities—the "postal code"—rather than innate biological or ethnic differences—the "genetic code." When health and nutritional needs are met, the sequence and timing of neurodevelopment appear to be innate and universal human traits.

While the study provides a powerful argument for developmental equity, it is limited by the absence of data from three original INTERGROWTH-21st sites (China, Oman, and the USA) and its cross-sectional nature at age 2. Future research should apply these universal standards to high-risk populations to quantify the impact of poverty and malnutrition on developmental trajectories. In conclusion, providing children with adequate health and nutrition allows their minds and bodies to follow a universal path of growth, regardless of their place of birth.

Summary updated

Abstract

It is unclear whether early child development is, like skeletal growth, similar across diverse regions with adequate health and nutrition. We prospectively assessed 1307 healthy, well-nourished 2-year-old children of educated mothers, enrolled in early pregnancy from urban areas without major socioeconomic or environmental constraints, in Brazil, India, Italy, Kenya and UK. We used a specially developed psychometric tool, WHO motor milestones and visual tests. Similarities across sites were measured using variance components analysis and standardised site differences (SSD). In 14 of the 16 domains, the percentage of total variance explained by between-site differences ranged from 1.3% (cognitive score) to 9.2% (behaviour score). Of the 80 SSD comparisons, only six were >±0.50 units of the pooled SD for the corresponding item. The sequence and timing of attainment of neurodevelopmental milestones and associated behaviours in early childhood are, therefore, likely innate and universal, as long as nutritional and health needs are met.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{villar2019neurodevelopmental,
  author = {José Villar and Michelle Fernandes and Manorama Purwar and Eleonora Staines-Urias and Paola Di Nicola and Leila Cheikh Ismail and Roseline Ochieng and Fernando C. Barros and Elaine Albernaz and César G. Victora and N. Kunnawar and Sophie Temple and Francesca Giuliani and Tamsin Sandells and Maria Carvalho and Eric O. Ohuma and Yasmin A. Jaffer and J. Alison Noble and Michael G. Gravett and Ruyan Pang and Ann Lambert and Enrico Bertino and Aris T. Papageorghiou and Cutberto Garza and Alan Stein and Zulfiqar A Bhutta and Stephen Kennedy},
  title = {{Neurodevelopmental milestones and associated behaviours are similar among healthy children across diverse geographical locations}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-018-07983-4},
}
Figure