Late weaning and maternal closeness, associated with advanced motor and visual maturation, reinforce autonomy in healthy, 2-year-old children

José Villar, Roseline Ochieng, Eleonora Staines-Urias, Michelle Fernandes, Marc J. Ratcliff, Manorama Purwar, Fernando C. Barros, Bernardo Lessa Horta, Leila Cheikh Ismail, Elaine Albernaz, N. Kunnawar, Sophie Temple, Francesca Giuliani, Tamsin Sandells, Maria Carvalho, Eric O. Ohuma, Yasmin A. Jaffer, J. Alison Noble, Michael G. Gravett, Ruyan Pang, Ann Lambert, Enrico Bertino, Paola Di Nicola, Aris T. Papageorghiou, Alan Stein, Zulfiqar A Bhutta, Stephen KennedyScientific 2020 · DOI

Abstract

We studied neurodevelopmental outcomes and behaviours in healthy 2-year old children (N = 1306) from Brazil, India, Italy, Kenya and the UK participating in the INTERGROWTH-21st Project. There was a positive independent relationship of duration of exclusive breastfeeding (EBF) and age at weaning with gross motor development, vision and autonomic physical activities, most evident if children were exclusively breastfed for ≥7 months or weaned at ≥7 months. There was no association with cognition, language or behaviour. Children exclusively breastfed from birth to <5 months or weaned at >6 months had, in a dose-effect pattern, adjusting for confounding factors, higher scores for "emotional reactivity". The positive effect of EBF and age at weaning on gross motor, running and climbing scores was strongest among children with the highest scores in maternal closeness proxy indicators. EBF, late weaning and maternal closeness, associated with advanced motor and vision maturation, independently influence autonomous behaviours in healthy children.

Introduction

While the nutritional benefits of breastfeeding are well-documented, the specific impact of breastfeeding duration and weaning timing on the sequence of neurodevelopmental milestones remains debated. Most studies focus on long-term IQ or health outcomes, often in populations facing socio-economic adversity.

This research shifts the lens to a healthy, well-nourished, multi-national cohort to ask: Does the timing of the "separation" from the mother (weaning) influence specific developmental domains like motor skills, vision, or behavior? The authors explore whether these practices reinforce a child’s transition from total dependency to "sensorimotor" autonomy—the ability to move, see, and interact with the world independently.

Methods and Study Population

The researchers utilized a prospective longitudinal design as part of the INTERGROWTH-21st Project. The study analyzed data from 1,306 healthy children across five diverse geographical sites: Pelotas (Brazil), Nagpur (India), Turin (Italy), Nairobi (Kenya), and Oxford (UK).

Study flow chart showing the selection of the final cohort of 1,306 healthy children from an initial 1,758 infants.

This cohort is unique because it consists of "low-risk" pregnancies and children living in stable environments, allowing the researchers to establish normative developmental patterns rather than studying the effects of malnutrition or poverty. Key methodological features included standardized assessments using the INTER-NDA tablet-based tool and rigorous adjustment for confounders like fetal head circumference and maternal education.

Key Insights: Sensorimotor Foundations of Autonomy

Motor Before Mind

The study found no significant link between breastfeeding/weaning and cognition or language at age 2. Instead, the effect was laser-focused on gross motor skills and vision. This supports Piaget’s theory that sensorimotor maturation is the essential foundation that must be laid before abstract intelligence can manifest.

The "Terrible Twos" as a Positive Sign

Interestingly, children with longer breastfeeding and later weaning showed higher scores for "emotional reactivity" and "attentional problems." While these sound negative, the scores remained within the normal range. The authors suggest this reflects increased autonomy and rebellion—the classic "terrible twos"—indicating a child who is active, independent, and confident enough to "refuse orders."

Closeness as a Catalyst

The positive effects on motor skills (running, climbing) were strongest in children whose mothers had a "low distraction" index. This suggests that the biological benefits of milk are amplified by the psychological security of maternal proximity.

Key Results

Significant positive independent relationships were found between EBF duration/weaning age and gross motor development, visual acuity, and contrast sensitivity. The most evident developmental gains appeared when exclusive breastfeeding or weaning was delayed until at least 7 months, aligning with WHO recommendations but providing specific neurodevelopmental evidence for them.

Forest plots showing the relationship (Beta coefficients and 95% CI) between feeding practices and various developmental domains including motor skills and vision.
  • Autonomy Markers: Children weaned later were significantly more likely to achieve higher scores in "autonomic" physical activities, such as running and climbing upstairs without assistance.
  • Behavioral Dose-Effect: A clear dose-effect pattern emerged where longer EBF led to higher "emotional reactivity" scores.
  • Formula Use: Conversely, longer duration of formula use was systematically associated with lower scores in five of the eight neurodevelopmental domains tested.

Limitations and Future Work

The study ends at age 2, and the authors acknowledge that effects on complex cognitive or language skills might only become evident during mid-childhood. Additionally, while the study tracked the amount of breastfeeding, it relied on proxy indicators for the quality of bonding.

Because the study population was so well-supported in breastfeeding, the "never breastfed" group was very small (N=23), limiting some statistical comparisons. Future research should continue to use domain-specific outcomes rather than "summary IQ quotients" to better capture the nuanced ways early nutrition shapes the developing brain.

Summary updated

Abstract

We studied neurodevelopmental outcomes and behaviours in healthy 2-year old children (N = 1306) from Brazil, India, Italy, Kenya and the UK participating in the INTERGROWTH-21<sup>st</sup> Project. There was a positive independent relationship of duration of exclusive breastfeeding (EBF) and age at weaning with gross motor development, vision and autonomic physical activities, most evident if children were exclusively breastfed for ≥7 months or weaned at ≥7 months. There was no association with cognition, language or behaviour. Children exclusively breastfed from birth to <5 months or weaned at >6 months had, in a dose-effect pattern, adjusting for confounding factors, higher scores for "emotional reactivity". The positive effect of EBF and age at weaning on gross motor, running and climbing scores was strongest among children with the highest scores in maternal closeness proxy indicators. EBF, late weaning and maternal closeness, associated with advanced motor and vision maturation, independently influence autonomous behaviours in healthy children.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{villar2020late,
  author = {José Villar and Roseline Ochieng and Eleonora Staines-Urias and Michelle Fernandes and Marc J. Ratcliff and Manorama Purwar and Fernando C. Barros and Bernardo Lessa Horta and Leila Cheikh Ismail and Elaine Albernaz and N. Kunnawar and Sophie Temple and Francesca Giuliani and Tamsin Sandells and Maria Carvalho and Eric O. Ohuma and Yasmin A. Jaffer and J. Alison Noble and Michael G. Gravett and Ruyan Pang and Ann Lambert and Enrico Bertino and Paola Di Nicola and Aris T. Papageorghiou and Alan Stein and Zulfiqar A Bhutta and Stephen Kennedy},
  title = {{Late weaning and maternal closeness, associated with advanced motor and visual maturation, reinforce autonomy in healthy, 2-year-old children}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-020-61917-z},
}
Figure