Neurocomputational mechanisms of confidence in self and others

Dan Bang, Rani Moran, Nathaniel D. Daw, Stephen M. Fleming

TL;DR

This paper investigates how humans estimate confidence in others' decisions, a crucial skill for social interaction. They found that people combine information about the decision's difficulty with their knowledge of the other person's ability, and this process involves a fascinating interplay between brain regions associated with decision-making and "theory of mind."

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

We're pretty good at knowing how confident we are in our own decisions, and neuroscience has made strides in understanding the brain mechanisms behind this. However, when it comes to estimating confidence in other people's decisions, our understanding is much more limited. This is a critical gap because social success often hinges on accurately predicting whether someone else will succeed or fail, especially when their abilities might differ from our own. For instance, a brilliant doctor might struggle with a rare diagnosis, while a novice might easily solve a basic math problem. This paper aims to bridge this gap by exploring the computational and neural underpinnings of social confidence estimation.

Methods

The researchers employed a clever experimental design using a random dot motion task. Participants had to decide the direction of moving dots and then place a "bet" (a post-decision wager) on whether their own decision or another player's decision was correct. This bet involved choosing between a safe, small reward and a risky, larger reward (with a corresponding loss if incorrect). The size of the bet served as an implicit measure of their confidence.

Crucially, participants were exposed to three other players with varying levels of accuracy (low, medium, high). This allowed the researchers to see if participants adjusted their confidence estimates based on the other player's known ability.

To understand the underlying computations, they developed and compared several computational models:

  • Self-projection (S-model): Assumes participants simply project their own confidence onto the other player.
  • Quality-tracking (Q-model): Assumes participants learn about an other player's ability through past performance.
  • Theory of Mind (ToM-model): The most sophisticated model, proposing that participants integrate their own assessment of decision difficulty with a learned representation of the other player's ability.

The researchers used fMRI to observe brain activity while participants performed the task. They focused on specific brain regions known to be involved in decision-making (like LIP) and "theory of mind" (like TPJ and dmPFC).

Datasets

The study used data from 21 participants. The "other players" were not real-time participants but were simulated using data from a pilot study where participants performed the same random dot motion task. This allowed for controlled manipulation of player ability.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Self-Projection: Participants don't just assume others are like them. They actively learn and incorporate information about an individual's specific abilities.
  • The "Theory of Mind" Connection: The brain regions associated with understanding others' mental states (TPJ and dmPFC) are crucial for estimating confidence in their decisions.
  • An Interplay of Systems: Confidence in others' decisions isn't solely a "social" process. It involves a dynamic interaction between brain areas responsible for perceptual decision-making (like LIP, which tracks difficulty) and those involved in social cognition.
  • Learning Others' Abilities: Participants update their beliefs about others' abilities based on observed outcomes, using a learning mechanism similar to how we learn from our own experiences.

Key Results

  • Behavioral: Participants were more likely to bet on the risky option (indicating higher confidence) when the decision was easier and when the other player was more skilled. This effect was specific to "other-trials" – the other player's ability didn't influence their confidence in their own decisions. They also showed a learning effect, adjusting their bets based on the other player's previous accuracy.
  • Computational Modeling: The "Theory of Mind" (ToM) model, which integrates decision difficulty and player ability, provided the best fit to the behavioral data, outperforming simpler models.
  • Neuroimaging:
    • During the decision phase, "self-trials" activated regions associated with perceptual decision-making (e.g., extrastriate cortex, parietal cortex), while "other-trials" preferentially activated "theory of mind" regions (TPJ, dmPFC).
  • Brain regions like MT+ and LIP tracked decision difficulty (motion coherence) on both self- and other-trials.
  • TPJ and dmPFC showed increased activity on other-trials and specifically encoded model-based confidence estimates for the other player, with TPJ showing selectivity for other-trials.
  • Functional connectivity between LIP (decision-making) and TPJ/dmPFC (social cognition) was stronger during other-trials, suggesting a collaborative process.
  • TPJ and dmPFC also encoded "social prediction errors", reflecting the difference between expected and actual outcomes of the other player's choices, indicating their role in updating beliefs about others' abilities.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Ambiguity: While the ToM model was the best fit, the authors acknowledge that other, more heuristic models (like combining self-projection and quality tracking) might also explain some of the behavioral data. Future work could explore these models further.
  • Artificial vs. Human: The study used simulated "other players." While this allowed for controlled manipulation, future research could investigate how these mechanisms play out with real human interactions.
  • One-Sided Confidence: This study focused on estimating confidence in others' decisions. The authors suggest that future work should explore how our confidence estimates interact with our inferences about how confident others are in their own decisions, which is crucial for complex social interactions.
  • Generalizability: The study used a specific perceptual task. Exploring these mechanisms in more complex, real-world social scenarios would be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

Computing confidence in one's own and others' decisions is critical for social success. While there has been substantial progress in our understanding of confidence estimates about oneself, little is known about how people form confidence estimates about others. Here, we address this question by asking participants undergoing fMRI to place bets on perceptual decisions made by themselves or one of three other players of varying ability. We show that participants compute confidence in another player's decisions by combining distinct estimates of player ability and decision difficulty - allowing them to predict that a good player may get a difficult decision wrong and that a bad player may get an easy decision right. We find that this computation is associated with an interaction between brain systems implicated in decision-making (LIP) and theory of mind (TPJ and dmPFC). These results reveal an interplay between self- and other-related processes during a social confidence computation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bang2022neurocomputational,
  author = {Dan Bang and Rani Moran and Nathaniel D. Daw and Stephen M. Fleming},
  title = {{Neurocomputational mechanisms of confidence in self and others}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-022-31674-w},
}
Figure