Neural Manipulation Planning on Constraint Manifolds

Ahmed Hussain Qureshi, Jiangeng Dong, Austin Choe, Michael C. YipIEEE RA-L 2020 · DOI · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces CoMPNet, a novel neural network-based planner that tackles complex robot manipulation tasks with multiple kinematic constraints. CoMPNet significantly speeds up motion planning by learning to generate feasible robot configurations on constraint manifolds, achieving an order of magnitude improvement in computational speed compared to existing methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Robots performing real-world tasks, like picking and placing objects or performing surgery, often face "manifold constraints." These constraints limit the robot's possible configurations to a low-dimensional subset within its overall configuration space. Traditional motion planning algorithms struggle with these constraints because randomly sampling configurations rarely lands on the desired manifold, making planning computationally expensive and slow. Existing methods, while improving, remain impractical for many real-time applications. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a computationally efficient and scalable neural planner for these challenging constrained manipulation problems.

Methods

CoMPNet is a full-stack neural planning framework with three key components:

  • Task Encoder: This component takes a natural language description of the task (e.g., "carefully move mug to the tray") and encodes it into a latent representation. This allows the planner to understand the task's nuances and associated constraints.
  • Observation Encoder: This component processes sensor data (like 3D point clouds) from the robot's environment and embeds it into a latent representation. This allows the planner to perceive the current state of the world.
  • Planning Network (PNet): This is a stochastic, feed-forward neural network that acts as the core planner. It takes the task and observation encodings, along with the current and goal robot configurations, and incrementally generates the next configuration that moves the robot closer to the goal on the constraint manifold.

The planning process itself is bidirectional. It uses a learned neural configuration generator to propose steps from both the start and goal configurations. These proposed steps are then extended along the constraint manifold using a "Transverse Manifold" function, which employs a projection operator to ensure configurations remain on or near the manifold. The algorithm terminates when paths from both directions meet, and the resulting path is then extracted and smoothed.

Datasets

The paper describes data generation for two main scenarios:

  • Bartender Setup: Involves manipulating objects like soda cans, juice cans, mugs, and kettles, requiring tasks like moving items to a trash bin or a tray.
  • Kitchen Setup: Includes objects like cans, bottles, mugs, pitchers, and a cabinet door, with tasks such as moving items, opening cabinets, and placing objects.

For training, demonstration trajectories were generated using the CBiRRT algorithm. The paper states that over 10% of randomly generated scenarios were set aside for testing, and these test environments were novel (not seen during training).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Natural Language for Constraints: Using natural language descriptions for tasks is a powerful way to encode complex, multimodal constraints, allowing for greater scalability than traditional one-hot encodings.
  • Neural Generation on Manifolds: The core innovation is the neural network's ability to directly generate robot configurations that lie on or near the constraint manifold, bypassing the low sampling probability issue of traditional methods.
  • Bidirectional Planning with Neural Guidance: Combining a learned neural generator with a bidirectional planning approach significantly accelerates the search process by exploring from both ends simultaneously.
  • Generalization to Unseen Scenarios: CoMPNet demonstrates impressive generalization capabilities, successfully planning for tasks in environments and object configurations it did not encounter during training.

Key Results

  • Computational Speed: CoMPNet achieves an order of magnitude improvement in computational speed compared to state-of-the-art constrained motion planning algorithms like Atlas-RRT, TB-RRT, and CBiRRT. Mean computation times are consistently in the low seconds range, whereas others take minutes.
  • Consistency: CoMPNet exhibits significantly lower variance in computation times, making its performance more predictable.
  • High Success Rates: The planner achieves high success rates (around 90%) across various challenging manipulation tasks in both simulated and real-world settings.
  • Generalization: CoMPNet successfully plans for tasks in unseen environments and object configurations, demonstrating its robustness.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: While CoMPNet shows impressive results, the paper acknowledges that it is a learning-based approach, and its performance is dependent on the quality and diversity of training data. The paper also mentions that the projection operator is sensitive to its parameters.
  • Future Work: The authors plan to extend CoMPNet to integrated task and motion planning, leveraging its speed for real-time motion reasoning. They also aim to incorporate dynamic constraints for kinodynamic path planning in high-dimensional observation spaces. The paper also suggests that CoMPNet can be combined with uniform C-space sampling techniques to achieve probabilistic completeness guarantees.

Summary updated

Abstract

The presence of task constraints imposes a significant challenge to motion planning. Despite all recent advancements, existing algorithms are still computationally expensive for most planning problems. In this letter, we present Constrained Motion Planning Networks (CoMPNet), the first neural planner for multimodal kinematic constraints. Our approach comprises the following components: i) constraint and environment perception encoders; ii) neural robot configuration generator that outputs configurations on/near the constraint manifold(s), and iii) a bidirectional planning algorithm that takes the generated configurations to create a feasible robot motion trajectory. We show that CoMPNet solves practical motion planning tasks involving both unconstrained and constrained problems. Furthermore, it generalizes to new unseen locations of the objects, i.e., not seen during training, in the given environments with high success rates. When compared to the state-of-the-art constrained motion planning algorithms, CoMPNet outperforms by order of magnitude improvement in computational speed with a significantly lower variance.
BibTeX
@article{qureshi2020neural,
  author = {Ahmed Hussain Qureshi and Jiangeng Dong and Austin Choe and Michael C. Yip},
  title = {{Neural Manipulation Planning on Constraint Manifolds}},
  journal = {IEEE Robotics Autom. Lett.},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1109/lra.2020.3010220},
}
Figure