Neural Interaction Energy for Multi-Agent Trajectory Prediction

Kaixin Shen, Ruijie Quan, Linchao Zhu, Jun Xiao, Yi Yang

Abstract

Predicting the future paths of multiple interacting agents—be they vehicles, pedestrians, or athletes—is a foundational challenge in robotics and artificial intelligence. Current deep learning approaches often prioritize data distribution fitting over physical consistency, leading to temporal instability and unrealistic trajectories. We present MATE (Multi-Agent Trajectory prediction via neural interaction Energy), a framework that treats agent interactions as neural energy. By applying physics-inspired constraints at both the system and agent levels, MATE reduces kinematic fluctuations and enhances zero-shot performance in complex, unseen environments. Our evaluation across four diverse datasets demonstrates that MATE significantly outperforms state-of-the-art baselines in both accuracy and robustness.

Introduction

Predicting how multiple agents move simultaneously is challenging because their behaviors are deeply interdependent. A major hurdle in current deep learning models is temporal instability: small errors in predicting an agent's velocity or position at one time step can lead to wild fluctuations or "jitter" in subsequent steps.

Most existing models focus on fitting data distributions but lack proper regularization to ensure that the predicted movement is physically or behaviorally coherent over time. Without this, errors amplify quickly, leading to unrealistic trajectories that fail in safety-critical real-world applications like autonomous driving or collaborative robotics. The MATE framework addresses this by introducing a "neural interaction energy" concept that acts as a physics-inspired regularizer during the prediction process.

Methodology

The MATE framework is built on two core components designed to capture the complexity of agent relationships and enforce physical plausibility.

1. MATE-Encoder: Multi-Edge GNN

Unlike standard models that use a single edge to represent an interaction between two agents, MATE utilizes a Multi-Edge Graph Neural Network (GNN). This allows the model to capture diverse, coexisting relationship types simultaneously. For example, in a social setting, two agents might be "friends" and "following" one another at the same time. By modeling these multi-faceted interactions, the encoder provides a richer representation of the social and physical context.

2. Neural Interaction Energy Module (NIEM)

The NIEM serves as the heart of the decoder, treating the "interactiveness" of agents as a form of energy. It enforces stability through two primary constraints:

  • Inter-agent Interaction Constraint: This enforces stability at the system level. It assumes that over a short time interval, the total interaction energy of the entire system should change minimally. By utilizing a partial differential equation (PDE) approach to minimize the gradient of this energy, the model ensures the collective behavior of the group remains stable.
  • Intra-agent Motion Constraint: This enforces stability at the individual level. It calculates a "motion variance" term based on an agent's past states and current interactions. By minimizing this variance, the model ensures that an agent’s predicted kinematic state (position and velocity) stays within a plausible, coherent range, effectively smoothing out potential jitter.

Experimental Setup

The model was evaluated on four distinct datasets to test its performance across simulated physics and real-world human behavior:

  • PHASE: Physically grounded abstract social events, such as agents collaborating to move an object.
  • Socialnav: A social navigation environment where agents are controlled by the Optimal Reciprocal Collision Avoidance (ORCA) policy.
  • Charged: A simulated dynamic system of particles with positive and negative charges governed by electromagnetic physical laws.
  • NBA: Real-world player-tracking data from the National Basketball Association, featuring high-intensity, multi-agent interactions and strategic movement.

Key Results and Insights

Superior Accuracy and Graph Understanding

MATE achieved the best performance across all four datasets. On the PHASE dataset, it showed a relative improvement of 17.6% in Average Displacement Error (ADE) and 13.7% in Final Displacement Error (FDE) over the previous strongest baseline, IMMA. Furthermore, the model reached over 91% accuracy in predicting the underlying interaction graphs in PHASE and Socialnav, indicating that it successfully identifies which agents are interacting.

Zero-Shot Robustness

Because the model learns the underlying "energy" of interactions rather than just memorizing trajectory patterns, it generalizes remarkably well to unseen scenarios. In zero-shot tests on the Socialnav dataset—where the number of agents or their speeds were doubled compared to training—MATE maintained much lower error rates than competitors like NRI or GAT-LSTM. While baseline models saw their error rates spike when the environment changed, MATE's physics-inspired constraints provided a buffer against out-of-distribution fluctuations.

Energy as a Proxy for Dynamics

A key insight of this work is the use of Neural Interaction Energy (NIE) as a proxy for system dynamics. Agents with low NIE are predicted to move slower or be less active, while high NIE suggests dynamic, high-velocity changes. By regularizing this energy, the authors effectively penalize "unstable" physics, forcing the neural network to act more like a consistent physics engine.

Limitations and Future Work

While MATE demonstrates strong results, several areas remain for future exploration:

  • Hyperparameter Sensitivity: The model relies on scaling factors (λ1, λ2) to balance the stability constraints with the primary loss function. Finding the optimal balance for these factors may vary significantly across different domains.
  • Computational Overhead: The use of multi-edge GNNs and PDE-based constraints in the decoder increases the computational cost compared to simpler MLP-based models. Future work could focus on optimizing these calculations for real-time deployment.
  • Complex Static Environments: While tested on high-intensity NBA data, the model's performance in environments with complex static obstacles (such as urban driving with intricate road geometry) was not the primary focus of this study and warrants further investigation.

Conclusion

The MATE framework represents a significant step toward integrating physical principles into deep learning for trajectory prediction. By modeling interactions through neural energy and enforcing system-wide stability, MATE provides a robust solution for predicting multi-agent dynamics in complex, ever-changing environments.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{shen2024neural,
  author = {Kaixin Shen and Ruijie Quan and Linchao Zhu and Jun Xiao and Yi Yang},
  title = {{Neural Interaction Energy for Multi-Agent Trajectory Prediction}},
  booktitle = {ACM Multimedia},
  year = {2024},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=igTm7pX1Fh},
}
Figure