Neural heterogeneity promotes robust learning

Nicolas Perez-Nieves, Vincent C. H. Leung, Pier Luigi Dragotti, Dan F. M. Goodman

TL;DR

This paper demonstrates that introducing variability in neural parameters (specifically, time constants) in spiking neural networks significantly improves their performance, robustness, and ability to learn complex temporal tasks. This finding suggests that neural heterogeneity, often overlooked in favor of homogeneous models, plays a crucial functional role in biological learning and adaptation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The brain is remarkably diverse, with neurons exhibiting a wide range of properties. However, many computational models of neural systems, particularly spiking neural networks (SNNs), tend to be highly homogeneous, assuming uniform parameters across neurons. This simplification makes them easier to analyze and implement but may not fully capture the functional advantages of biological neural diversity. The central question this paper addresses is whether this neural heterogeneity is merely a byproduct of biological noise or if it serves a critical functional purpose, especially in learning complex, real-world tasks with rich temporal dynamics. Previous studies often used simplified tasks, leaving the role of heterogeneity in more challenging scenarios unexplored.

Methods

The researchers trained recurrent spiking neural networks (RSNNs) to perform classification tasks. They systematically varied the degree of heterogeneity in the neuronal parameters, focusing primarily on the membrane and synaptic time constants.

  • Network Architecture: A standard three-layer architecture was used: an input layer, a recurrently connected layer, and a readout layer for predictions.
  • Heterogeneity Implementation: Heterogeneity was introduced in two main ways:
  • Initialisation: Neuronal time constants were either initialized to a single value (homogeneous) or sampled from a gamma distribution (heterogeneous).
  • Training: During training, synaptic weights were always learned. In "standard" training, time constants were fixed at their initial values. In "heterogeneous" training, both synaptic weights and time constants could be learned and adapted.
  • Learning Algorithm: Surrogate gradient descent was employed, a common technique for training SNNs by approximating the non-differentiable spiking mechanism with a differentiable function.
  • Parameter Tuning: To ensure results were due to heterogeneity and not just better parameter tuning, they performed grid searches for homogeneous time constants and observed that learned distributions converged to a similar heterogeneous form regardless of initialisation.

Datasets

The study utilized five datasets with varying degrees of temporal complexity:

  • Low Temporal Structure:
    • Neuromorphic MNIST (N-MNIST): Generated from static images using a neuromorphic sensor.
  • Fashion-MNIST (F-MNIST): Static images converted to spike times based on intensity.
  • Intermediate Temporal Structure:
    • DVS128 Gesture: Recorded motion from a neuromorphic vision sensor.
  • High Temporal Structure:
    • Spiking Heidelberg Digits (SHD): Auditory dataset based on a detailed model of cochlear nucleus activity for spoken digits.
  • Spiking Speech Commands (SSC): Similar auditory dataset for spoken commands.

The paper also referenced publicly available neural data from mouse cochlear nucleus and visual cortex, as well as human middle temporal gyrus, to compare learned parameter distributions with experimental observations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Heterogeneity is Not Just Noise: The findings strongly suggest that neural heterogeneity is not merely a byproduct of biological processes but actively contributes to improved learning capabilities.
  • Temporal Complexity Matters: The benefits of heterogeneity are most pronounced on tasks requiring the processing of rich temporal information, aligning with the complexity of real-world sensory inputs.
  • Robustness and Generalization: Heterogeneous networks demonstrate greater robustness to variations in environmental conditions (e.g., different speech speeds) and are less sensitive to hyperparameter mistuning during training.
  • Biological Plausibility: The distributions of neuronal parameters learned by the heterogeneous models closely resemble those observed experimentally in biological brains, lending strong support to the functional role of heterogeneity.
  • Metabolic Efficiency: Heterogeneity offers a significant computational advantage without increasing the number of neurons or synapses, making it a metabolically efficient strategy for the brain.

Key Results

  • Performance Improvement: Heterogeneity substantially improved task performance, particularly on temporally complex auditory tasks (SHD, SSC), where accuracy increased by 15-20%. For simpler tasks (N-MNIST), the improvement was negligible.
  • Stable and Robust Learning: Heterogeneous configurations led to more stable training trajectories and better generalization, especially for datasets with rich temporal structure.
  • Parameter Distribution Match: The learned distributions of neuronal time constants in the trained networks closely matched experimentally observed distributions, even across different animal species and brain regions.
  • Generalization Across Time Scales: Heterogeneous networks showed superior performance when tested on stimuli presented at different speeds than those used during training, demonstrating enhanced generalization.
  • Robustness to Mistuning: In experiments where learning hyperparameters were deliberately mistuned, heterogeneous networks maintained good performance across a wider range of conditions compared to homogeneous networks.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Demands: The methods used are computationally intensive, limiting the scale of networks investigated (hundreds of neurons for surrogate gradient descent, thousands for FORCE training). Developing more efficient algorithms for scaling up these methods is a critical future direction.
  • Cell Type Diversity: While the models achieved heterogeneity in time constants, they did not incorporate diversity in cell types, which is present in biological brains. The authors suggest that incorporating different cell types could lead to even better performance.
  • Theoretical Explanation: The paper highlights the need for a rigorous theoretical framework to explain why heterogeneity provides such an advantage, beyond empirical observation.
  • Broader Heterogeneity: The study focused primarily on time constants. Future work could explore the impact of heterogeneity in other neuronal parameters (though initial tests showed less impact) and investigate spatial heterogeneity.

Summary updated

Abstract

The brain is a hugely diverse, heterogeneous structure. Whether or not heterogeneity at the neural level plays a functional role remains unclear, and has been relatively little explored in models which are often highly homogeneous. We compared the performance of spiking neural networks trained to carry out tasks of real-world difficulty, with varying degrees of heterogeneity, and found that heterogeneity substantially improved task performance. Learning with heterogeneity was more stable and robust, particularly for tasks with a rich temporal structure. In addition, the distribution of neuronal parameters in the trained networks is similar to those observed experimentally. We suggest that the heterogeneity observed in the brain may be more than just the byproduct of noisy processes, but rather may serve an active and important role in allowing animals to learn in changing environments.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{pereznieves2021neural,
  author = {Nicolas Perez-Nieves and Vincent C. H. Leung and Pier Luigi Dragotti and Dan F. M. Goodman},
  title = {{Neural heterogeneity promotes robust learning}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-021-26022-3},
}
Figure