Neural effects of propofol-induced unconsciousness and its reversal using thalamic stimulation

André M. Bastos, Jacob Donoghue, Scott L. Brincat, Meredith Mahnke, Jorge Yanar, Josefina Correa, Ayan S. Waite, Mikael Lundqvist, Jefferson E. Roy, Emery N. Brown, Earl K. Miller

TL;DR

This study investigates the neural mechanisms underlying propofol-induced unconsciousness in non-human primates, revealing that loss of consciousness is characterized by increased slow-frequency brain oscillations and reduced higher-frequency activity, disrupting cortical communication. Crucially, stimulating the thalamus can reverse these effects, partially restoring an awake-like brain state.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Despite propofol being a widely used anesthetic, the precise neural circuits and mechanisms responsible for inducing and maintaining unconsciousness remain incompletely understood. Previous research has relied heavily on less spatially precise methods like EEG or fMRI, often neglecting the thalamus, a critical brain region for regulating cortical activity and consciousness. This paper aims to bridge this gap by using high-resolution neural recordings from multiple cortical areas and the thalamus to characterize the dynamic neural changes associated with propofol-induced unconsciousness and its reversal via thalamic stimulation.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach using non-human primates (macaques). They recorded neural activity (local field potentials and spiking) from various cortical regions (prefrontal, parietal, temporal) and the thalamus. Propofol was administered to induce unconsciousness, and its effects were monitored throughout the transition from awake to unconscious states and during recovery.

Key techniques included:

  • Chronic and Acute Electrophysiology: Using chronically implanted Utah arrays and acutely inserted laminar probes to capture neural activity with high spatial and temporal resolution.
  • Thalamic Stimulation: Applying electrical stimulation to specific thalamic nuclei (intralaminar and mediodorsal) to investigate its effect on arousal and brain activity.
  • Physiological Monitoring: Tracking muscle tone (EMG), eyeblink reflexes, blood oxygenation, and heart rate to correlate with behavioral and neural states.
  • Advanced Signal Processing: Employing techniques like zero-phase component analysis (ZCA) for artifact removal, time-frequency analysis for LFP power, and pairwise phase consistency (PPC) for phase synchronization analysis.
  • Statistical Analysis: Utilizing non-parametric cluster-based randomization tests for robust statistical comparisons of neural data.
  • Point Process Generalized Linear Models (PPGLMs): To model spike trains and assess the coupling of neuronal spiking to LFP phases.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from four rhesus macaques. No external datasets were used for training or evaluation. The data collected from these animals, encompassing neural recordings and physiological measures during propofol anesthesia and thalamic stimulation, represent the primary dataset for this research.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Slow-Frequency Dominance: Unconsciousness is strongly associated with a dramatic increase in slow-frequency (~1 Hz) oscillations in both cortical and thalamic activity. This suggests a fundamental shift in brain dynamics towards slower, more synchronized patterns.
  • Spiking Decoupling: Neuronal spiking becomes tightly coupled to these slow oscillations, leading to periods of high activity ("Up states") followed by prolonged periods of silence ("Down states"). This "fragmentation" of spiking activity likely impairs information processing.
  • Loss of High-Frequency Dynamics: Simultaneously, higher-frequency brain activity (e.g., gamma band) associated with active cognition and communication is significantly suppressed. This loss of dynamic, higher-frequency coherence is a hallmark of unconsciousness.
  • Thalamus as a Key Regulator: Electrical stimulation of the thalamus, particularly with higher currents, can partially reverse the neurophysiological signs of unconsciousness, including increasing spiking rates and reducing slow-frequency power. This highlights the thalamus's crucial role in maintaining arousal and cortical integration.
  • Layer-Specific Effects: The impact of propofol and thalamic stimulation varies across cortical layers, with superficial layers showing greater suppression of gamma and spiking, while deep layers exhibit a stronger increase in slow-frequency power. This suggests that different cortical circuits are differentially affected.

Key Results

  • Propofol-induced unconsciousness was characterized by increased slow-frequency LFP power across all recorded cortical areas and the thalamus.
  • Spike rates across all cortical areas decreased significantly during unconsciousness, falling to 0.2-0.5 spikes/s from awake rates of 6-8 spikes/s.
  • Neuronal spiking became phase-locked to slow-frequency oscillations, with spikes preferentially occurring during the depolarized phases.
  • Cortico-cortical and thalamo-cortical phase synchronization increased in the slow-frequency band during unconsciousness.
  • Thalamic stimulation (180 Hz, bipolar) in unconscious monkeys led to increased muscle tone, eyeblinks, blood oxygenation, and heart rate, alongside a significant increase in cortical spiking rates (up to ~2.5 spikes/s) and a decrease in slow-frequency power.
  • High-current thalamic stimulation also reduced slow-frequency power and synchronization, while increasing higher-frequency power, partially restoring an awake-like cortical state.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Animal Model: While macaques are excellent models for human brain function, direct translation of findings to humans requires caution.
  • Propofol Specificity: The study focused on propofol. Future work could explore whether these mechanisms are conserved across different anesthetic agents, particularly those acting on different neurotransmitter systems (e.g., NMDA antagonists like ketamine).
  • Brainstem Contribution: The study primarily focused on cortex and thalamus. The authors acknowledge that propofol's actions on GABAergic targets in the brainstem likely contribute to unconsciousness and warrant further investigation.
  • Separating Factors: The authors note that factors like oxygen saturation, blood pressure, and ventilation also changed during the experiment, and it was challenging to completely isolate their contribution from the observed neurophysiological changes.
  • Thalamic Stimulation Parameters: While effective, the specific parameters for thalamic stimulation were optimized for arousal. Further research could explore the precise parameters and targets for more complete restoration of consciousness.
  • Layer-Specific Mechanisms: The observed layer-specific effects suggest distinct roles for different cortical layers in consciousness, which could be further explored to refine theories of consciousness.

Summary updated

Abstract

The specific circuit mechanisms through which anesthetics induce unconsciousness have not been completely characterized. We recorded neural activity from the frontal, parietal, and temporal cortices and thalamus while maintaining unconsciousness in non-human primates (NHPs) with the anesthetic propofol. Unconsciousness was marked by slow frequency (~1 Hz) oscillations in local field potentials, entrainment of local spiking to Up states alternating with Down states of little or no spiking activity, and decreased coherence in frequencies above 4 Hz. Thalamic stimulation 'awakened' anesthetized NHPs and reversed the electrophysiologic features of unconsciousness. Unconsciousness is linked to cortical and thalamic slow frequency synchrony coupled with decreased spiking, and loss of higher-frequency dynamics. This may disrupt cortical communication/integration.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bastos2021neural,
  author = {André M. Bastos and Jacob Donoghue and Scott L. Brincat and Meredith Mahnke and Jorge Yanar and Josefina Correa and Ayan S. Waite and Mikael Lundqvist and Jefferson E. Roy and Emery N. Brown and Earl K. Miller},
  title = {{Neural effects of propofol-induced unconsciousness and its reversal using thalamic stimulation}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.60824},
}
Figure