Neural circuits in the mouse retina support color vision in the upper visual field

Klaudia P. Szatko, Maria M. Korympidou, Yanli Ran, Philipp Berens, Deniz Dalkara, Timm Schubert, Thomas Euler, Katrin Franke

TL;DR

Mice, despite being dichromatic, can discriminate colors in their upper visual field. This study reveals that the neural circuits responsible for this color vision are surprisingly concentrated in the ventral retina, utilizing a rod-cone interaction mechanism. This processing pipeline, from cones to bipolar cells to ganglion cells, generates specific color-opponent signals crucial for survival.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Color vision is vital for animal survival, enabling tasks like foraging, communication, and predator detection. In primates, this process is well-understood, involving distinct red-green and blue-yellow opponent pathways. However, the neural basis of color vision in dichromatic mammals like mice has remained largely elusive. While behavioral studies suggest mice can discriminate colors, particularly in their upper visual field, the underlying retinal circuitry is poorly characterized. A key puzzle is that the ventral retina, where this upper visual field information is processed, has cones with similar spectral preferences, seemingly hindering color comparisons. This paper aims to systematically map the chromatic processing pathways from photoreceptors to retinal output neurons in the mouse retina to understand how color information is extracted.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-stage approach using in vivo two-photon imaging techniques to record neural activity.

  • Cone responses: They used a viral approach to express a glutamate biosensor (iGluSnFR) in photoreceptor axon terminals. This allowed them to measure light-evoked glutamate release, serving as a proxy for cone activity.
  • Bipolar cell (BC) responses: Similar to cone recordings, iGluSnFR was used to monitor glutamate release from BCs. Crucially, they used axial scanning with an electrically tunable lens to capture responses across the entire inner plexiform layer (IPL), where BCs stratify.
  • Ganglion cell (GC) responses: For GC recordings, they used a synthetic calcium indicator (OGB-1) delivered via bulk electroporation to label the ganglion cell layer.

Chromatic stimuli (UV and green light) were presented in various configurations (full-field, center, and surround) to probe spectral preferences and color opponency. Data analysis involved quantifying spectral contrast (SC) and correlation coefficients to characterize neuronal responses.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized ex vivo mouse retinas from wild-type and transgenic mouse lines.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ventral Retina Dominance: Contrary to expectations based on cone opsin distribution, the majority of color-opponent cells are found in the ventral retina, not the dorsal. This suggests a specialized circuit for color processing in this region.
  • Rod-Cone Interaction: Rod photoreceptors, typically associated with low-light vision, appear to play a crucial role in generating color-opponent signals in the ventral retina, likely through feedback mechanisms involving horizontal cells (HCs).
  • Early Onset of Color Opponency: Color-opponent responses are not just present at the ganglion cell level but are already established at the cone output stage, mediated by HCs and potentially rods.
  • Non-Linear Processing in GCs: While bipolar cells relay chromatic information, ganglion cells exhibit more complex, type-specific processing. Non-linear center-surround interactions in GCs create diverse color-opponent output channels, going beyond simple relaying of cone signals.
  • Upper Visual Field Specialization: The findings strongly support the hypothesis that mouse color vision is primarily localized to the upper visual field (processed by the ventral retina), aligning with behavioral observations.

Key Results

  • Cone Responses: Ventral cones showed UV-dominant responses to center/full-field stimuli, while dorsal cones were predominantly green-sensitive. However, ventral cones exhibited a significant green-shift in their surround responses, leading to color-opponent center-surround receptive fields. This surround opponency was significantly reduced when HC feedback was blocked with NBQX, confirming HC involvement.
  • Bipolar Cell Responses: BCs largely mirrored the chromatic preferences of cones, with ventral BCs showing UV-dominant centers and green-shifted surrounds, and dorsal BCs showing green-dominant centers. Approximately 75% of ventral BCs exhibited color-opponent full-field responses.
  • Ganglion Cell Responses: Color-opponency was preserved at the GC output layer. Ventral GCs showed a greater proportion of color-opponent responses compared to dorsal GCs. The complexity of chromatic signals increased from BCs to GCs, with evidence of non-linear integration in specific GC types.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Stimulus Alignment: The researchers acknowledge that for GCL recordings, the stimulus was aligned to the scan field center, not necessarily the precise RF center of each recorded cell. This could lead to an underestimation of center-opponent RGCs.
  • Cone-Type Specificity: While the study investigated chromatic processing, definitively identifying cone-type-selective circuits in mice proved challenging, unlike in primates. The authors suggest that while some candidate pathways might exist, the dominant mechanism appears to be cone-type-unselective.
  • Future Directions: The paper suggests that the rod-cone based mechanism for color extraction in the ventral retina might be advantageous for detecting predators from above and for processing visual scenes with inhomogeneous illumination. Further investigation into how this specialized color vision aids in specific behaviors like predator detection and social communication is warranted. The role of non-linear integration in RGCs for generating diverse color-opponent channels also presents an exciting avenue for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Color vision is essential for an animal's survival. It starts in the retina, where signals from different photoreceptor types are locally compared by neural circuits. Mice, like most mammals, are dichromatic with two cone types. They can discriminate colors only in their upper visual field. In the corresponding ventral retina, however, most cones display the same spectral preference, thereby presumably impairing spectral comparisons. In this study, we systematically investigated the retinal circuits underlying mouse color vision by recording light responses from cones, bipolar and ganglion cells. Surprisingly, most color-opponent cells are located in the ventral retina, with rod photoreceptors likely being involved. Here, the complexity of chromatic processing increases from cones towards the retinal output, where non-linear center-surround interactions create specific color-opponent output channels to the brain. This suggests that neural circuits in the mouse retina are tuned to extract color from the upper visual field, aiding robust detection of predators and ensuring the animal's survival.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{szatko2020neural,
  author = {Klaudia P. Szatko and Maria M. Korympidou and Yanli Ran and Philipp Berens and Deniz Dalkara and Timm Schubert and Thomas Euler and Katrin Franke},
  title = {{Neural circuits in the mouse retina support color vision in the upper visual field}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-020-17113-8},
}
Figure