Network Architecture Underlying Basal Autonomic Outflow: Evidence from Frontotemporal Dementia

Virginia E. Sturm, Jesse A. Brown, Alice Y. Hua, Sandy J. Lwi, Juan Zhou, Florian Kurth, Simon B. Eickhoff, Howard J. Rosen, Joel H. Kramer, Bruce L. Miller, Robert W. Levenson, William W. SeeleyJournal of Neuroscience 2018 · DOI

Abstract

The salience network is a distributed neural system that maintains homeostasis by regulating autonomic nervous system activity and social-emotional function. Here we examined how within-network connectivity relates to individual differences in human baseline parasympathetic and sympathetic nervous activity. We measured resting autonomic nervous system physiology in 24 healthy controls and 23 patients with behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia (bvFTD), a neurodegenerative disease characterized by baseline autonomic deficits. Participants also underwent structural and task-free fMRI. First, we used voxel-based morphometry to determine whether salience network atrophy was associated with lower baseline respiratory sinus arrhythmia (a parasympathetic measure) and skin conductance level (a sympathetic measure) in bvFTD. Next, we examined whether functional connectivity deficits in 21 autonomic-relevant, salience network node-pairs related to baseline autonomic dysfunction. Lower baseline respiratory sinus arrhythmia was associated with smaller volume in left ventral anterior insula (vAI), weaker connectivity between bilateral vAI and bilateral anterior cingulate cortex (ACC), and stronger connectivity between bilateral ACC and bilateral hypothalamus/amygdala. Lower baseline skin conductance level, in contrast, was associated with smaller volume in inferior temporal gyrus, dorsal mid-insula, and hypothalamus; weaker connectivity between bilateral ACC and right hypothalamus/amygdala; and stronger connectivity between bilateral dorsal anterior insula and periaqueductal gray. Our results suggest that baseline parasympathetic and sympathetic tone depends on the integrity of lateralized salience network hubs (left vAI for parasympathetic and right hypothalamus/amygdala for sympathetic) and highly calibrated ipsilateral and contralateral network connections. In bvFTD, deficits in this system may underlie resting parasympathetic and sympathetic disruption.

Introduction

This study, published in The Journal of Neuroscience, maps the neural "wiring diagram" that controls our body's unconscious physiological state. By studying patients with behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia (bvFTD)—a disease that specifically targets the brain's "salience network"—researchers identified lateralized hubs and competing connections that maintain the delicate balance between our "rest-and-digest" and "fight-or-flight" systems.

The autonomic nervous system (ANS) is the body’s control center for homeostasis, divided into the parasympathetic (PANS) and sympathetic (SANS) branches. While the salience network (SN)—anchored in the insula and anterior cingulate cortex—is known as a primary driver of these systems, the exact architecture of this control has remained poorly defined. By studying bvFTD, a neurodegenerative disease that systematically breaks down the SN, the authors could observe how specific "wiring" failures lead to specific autonomic deficits, providing a unique window into the healthy brain's design.

Methods

The researchers compared 24 healthy controls with 23 patients with bvFTD. The study integrated three data streams: physiology (baseline Respiratory Sinus Arrhythmia [RSA] for PANS and Skin Conductance Level [SCL] for SANS), structural imaging (voxel-based morphometry [VBM]), and functional imaging (task-free fMRI). Functional connectivity was measured between 21 key nodes in the salience network, defined using an independent cohort of 40 healthy older controls.

Schematic of the salience network architecture and anatomical locations of the 21 nodes used in the functional connectivity analysis.

Key Insights: The Lateralization Rule

The study confirmed a striking hemispheric split. The left ventral anterior insula (vAI) emerged as the primary hub for parasympathetic (PANS) tone, while the right hypothalamus/amygdala acted as the hub for sympathetic (SANS) tone. Interestingly, more connectivity isn't always "better." The researchers found that stronger connectivity in certain edges (like between the ACC and the hypothalamus) was associated with lower parasympathetic activity. This suggests the SN uses some pathways to actively inhibit autonomic outflow, acting as a physiological "brake."

Results

Parasympathetic Activity (RSA)

Lower RSA was linked to atrophy in the left vAI and weaker functional connectivity between the vAI and the anterior cingulate cortex (ACC). Conversely, stronger connectivity between the ACC and subcortical nodes (hypothalamus/amygdala) predicted lower RSA, highlighting the inhibitory role of these connections.

Voxel-based morphometry and functional connectivity results for baseline respiratory sinus arrhythmia (RSA).

Sympathetic Activity (SCL)

Lower SCL was associated with smaller volumes in the right hypothalamus, dorsal mid-insula, and inferior temporal gyrus. It was also predicted by weaker connectivity between the ACC and the right hypothalamus, and stronger connectivity between the bilateral dorsal anterior insula and the periaqueductal gray (PAG). Patients with bvFTD showed significant deficits in both RSA and SCL, directly linked to the degradation of the SN's structural and functional integrity.

Discussion and Future Directions

While the study identifies correlations, it cannot definitively prove the direction of signaling (e.g., whether the ACC is driving the hypothalamus or vice versa). Standard 3T fMRI also has limitations in resolving tiny brainstem structures like the nucleus ambiguus. Future work using higher-resolution imaging could further refine this map by subdividing the hypothalamus and PAG into smaller functional zones.

Despite these limitations, the findings provide a robust framework for understanding how the salience network maintains autonomic homeostasis and how its breakdown in neurodegenerative disease leads to physiological dysfunction.

Summary updated

Abstract

The salience network is a distributed neural system that maintains homeostasis by regulating autonomic nervous system activity and social-emotional function. Here we examined how within-network connectivity relates to individual differences in human (including males and females) baseline parasympathetic and sympathetic nervous activity. We measured resting autonomic nervous system physiology in 24 healthy controls and 23 patients with behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia (bvFTD), a neurodegenerative disease characterized by baseline autonomic deficits. Participants also underwent structural and task-free fMRI. First, we used voxel-based morphometry to determine whether salience network atrophy was associated with lower baseline respiratory sinus arrhythmia (a parasympathetic measure) and skin conductance level (a sympathetic measure) in bvFTD. Next, we examined whether functional connectivity deficits in 21 autonomic-relevant, salience network node-pairs related to baseline autonomic dysfunction. Lower baseline respiratory sinus arrhythmia was associated with smaller volume in left ventral anterior insula (vAI), weaker connectivity between bilateral vAI and bilateral anterior cingulate cortex (ACC), and stronger connectivity between bilateral ACC and bilateral hypothalamus/amygdala. Lower baseline skin conductance level, in contrast, was associated with smaller volume in inferior temporal gyrus, dorsal mid-insula, and hypothalamus; weaker connectivity between bilateral ACC and right hypothalamus/amygdala; and stronger connectivity between bilateral dorsal anterior insula and periaqueductal gray. Our results suggest that baseline parasympathetic and sympathetic tone depends on the integrity of lateralized salience network hubs (left vAI for parasympathetic and right hypothalamus/amygdala for sympathetic) and highly calibrated ipsilateral and contralateral network connections. In bvFTD, deficits in this system may underlie resting parasympathetic and sympathetic disruption.<b>SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT</b> The salience network maintains homeostasis and regulates autonomic nervous system activity. Whether within-network connectivity patterns underlie individual differences in resting parasympathetic and sympathetic nervous system activity, however, is not well understood. We measured baseline autonomic nervous system activity in healthy controls and patients with behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia, a neurodegenerative disease characterized by resting autonomic deficits, and probed how salience network dysfunction relates to diminished parasympathetic and sympathetic outflow. Our results indicate that baseline parasympathetic and sympathetic tone are the product of complex, opposing intranetwork nodal interactions and depend on the integrity of highly tuned, lateralized salience network hubs (i.e., left ventral anterior insula for parasympathetic activity and right hypothalamus/amygdala for sympathetic activity).
BibTeX
@article{sturm2018network,
  author = {Virginia E. Sturm and Jesse A. Brown and Alice Y. Hua and Sandy J. Lwi and Juan Zhou and Florian Kurth and Simon B. Eickhoff and Howard J. Rosen and Joel H. Kramer and Bruce L. Miller and Robert W. Levenson and William W. Seeley},
  title = {{Network Architecture Underlying Basal Autonomic Outflow: Evidence from Frontotemporal Dementia}},
  journal = {Journal of Neuroscience},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1523/jneurosci.0347-18.2018},
}
Figure