Nematicity and orbital depairing in superconducting Bernal bilayer graphene

Ludwig Holleis, Caitlin L. Patterson, Yiran Zhang, Yaar Vituri, Heun Mo Yoo, Haoxin Zhou, Takashi Taniguchi, Kenji Watanabe, Erez Berg, Stevan Nadj-Perge, Andrea F. YoungNature Physics 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have discovered two distinct superconducting states in Bernal bilayer graphene with strong spin-orbit coupling. One state emerges from a nematic normal phase, suggesting a new avenue for exploring unconventional superconductivity in layered materials.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Superconductivity in layered materials like graphene is a fascinating area of research, with its properties often influenced by the material's electronic structure and interactions. While superconductivity has been observed in various graphene allotropes, understanding the interplay between superconductivity, spin-orbit coupling (SOC), and other electronic orders like nematicity has been challenging. Specifically, the precise mechanisms limiting superconductivity, especially in the presence of magnetic fields, and the role of nematicity in its emergence remain open questions. This paper aims to shed light on these issues by investigating Bernal bilayer graphene (BBG) with induced Ising SOC, a system known for its reproducibility and tunable electronic properties.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of advanced experimental techniques and theoretical modeling:

  • Transport Measurements: Longitudinal resistance ($R_{xx}$) measurements were conducted using lock-in techniques at low temperatures and currents to probe the superconducting states.
  • Shubnikov-de-Haas (SdH) Oscillations: These measurements, performed in varying magnetic fields, were crucial for mapping the Fermi surface geometry and identifying different electronic phases. By analyzing the frequencies of these oscillations, the researchers could infer the electronic band structure and its modifications due to SOC.
  • Penetration Field Capacitance Measurements: This technique was used to measure the inverse electronic compressibility ($\kappa$), providing insights into phase transitions and the electronic response to external stimuli.
  • Theoretical Modeling: A tight-binding model was used to calculate the band structure of BBG, incorporating the effects of Ising SOC and interlayer potential. This model was then used to interpret the SdH oscillation data and to estimate critical fields.
  • In-plane Critical Field Measurements: The superconducting transition temperature ($T_c$) was measured as a function of in-plane magnetic fields to understand the limits of superconductivity and compare them with theoretical predictions like the Pauli and Ising limits.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Two Distinct Superconducting States: The study reveals two superconducting states, SC1 and SC2, in BBG with strong Ising SOC. This is a significant finding, suggesting a richer phase diagram than previously understood.
  • Nematicity Precedes Superconductivity: Crucially, SC2 emerges from a normal state that exhibits nematic order, characterized by broken rotational symmetry. This provides direct evidence for the role of nematicity in the emergence of superconductivity in this system.
  • Orbital Depairing as a Limiting Factor: For SC1, the researchers argue that superconductivity is limited by orbital depairing, arising from imperfect layer polarization of electron wavefunctions. This offers a specific mechanism for understanding the destruction of superconductivity by magnetic fields.
  • Robustness to Magnetic Fields: Both SC1 and SC2 show robustness against in-plane magnetic fields, exceeding the paramagnetic (Pauli) limit. This highlights the influence of SOC and potentially other pairing mechanisms.
  • Distinguishing from Isospin Transitions: The paper emphasizes that the proximity of SC2 to isospin phase boundaries, observed in other graphene allotropes, is likely coincidental. This helps to constrain theories of unconventional superconductivity by ruling out simple explanations based solely on isospin ordering.

Key Results

  • SC1: Exhibits a normal state consistent with the single-particle band structure. Its superconductivity is limited by orbital depairing, with critical fields falling between the Pauli and Ising limits.
  • SC2: Emerges from a nematic normal state. Its transition temperature is significantly higher than SC1, reaching up to ~255 mK.
  • Fermi Surface Analysis: SdH oscillations reveal detailed Fermi surface properties, allowing for the identification of different electronic phases and the characterization of the nematic state.
  • Critical Field Analysis: Theoretical modeling of orbital depairing successfully explains a significant portion of the discrepancy between experimental critical fields and theoretical limits.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Disentangling Contributions: While orbital effects are identified as dominant for depairing in in-plane magnetic fields, the paper acknowledges that Coulomb interactions might also play a role in Fermi surface reconstructions, which could influence the orbital moment.
  • Experimental Challenges: The low transition temperatures of SC1 make precise measurements challenging, and the saturation of resistance is attributed to disequilibration with the phonon bath.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that breaking other symmetries, such as through uniaxial strain, could further enhance superconductivity by stabilizing nematic orders. Further investigation into the interplay of nematicity, SOC, and superconductivity in other layered materials is also implied.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{holleis2025nematicity,
  author = {Ludwig Holleis and Caitlin L. Patterson and Yiran Zhang and Yaar Vituri and Heun Mo Yoo and Haoxin Zhou and Takashi Taniguchi and Kenji Watanabe and Erez Berg and Stevan Nadj-Perge and Andrea F. Young},
  title = {{Nematicity and orbital depairing in superconducting Bernal bilayer graphene}},
  booktitle = {Nature Physics},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1038/s41567-024-02776-7},
}
Figure