Negative affect impairs associative memory but not item memory

James A. Bisby, Neil BurgessLearning 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

Negative emotions and stress impair our ability to remember how things are connected (associative memory) but surprisingly enhance our memory for individual items. This suggests distinct brain systems for remembering "what" versus "what goes with what," with emotional arousal selectively disrupting the latter.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

We generally know that emotional experiences are remembered better than neutral ones. However, memory is complex; it's not just about recalling individual facts or objects (item memory), but also about remembering how these items relate to each other and their surroundings (associative memory). The authors wanted to understand how emotional states, specifically negative affect, impact these different types of memory. Previous research often focused on item memory, leaving the effects on associative memory less clear. This paper aims to disentangle these effects, proposing that emotional arousal might differentially impact the brain regions responsible for item versus associative memory.

Methods

The researchers conducted three experiments using human participants.

  • Experiment 1: Participants viewed neutral and negative images presented against different background scenes. They were asked to make a judgment about the plausibility of the item-scene combination. Later, they were tested on their memory for both the individual items and the associated background scenes.
  • Experiment 2: This experiment introduced a stress manipulation. Participants were exposed to background scenes that predicted either a threat of mild electric shock or safety. They then encoded neutral and negative images presented against these scenes. Memory for items and their associated scenes was tested later. This allowed them to see if stress, independent of the emotional content of the items themselves, affected memory.
  • Experiment 3: This experiment focused on paired associates. Participants were shown pairs of neutral and negative images and instructed to imagine a link between them. At test, they were cued with one image and asked to recall the associated image. This design allowed for all combinations of neutral and negative item pairs.

Across all experiments, memory performance was analyzed using repeated measures ANOVAs, comparing item and associative memory accuracy under different emotional conditions.

Datasets

The study used images from the International Affective Picture System (IAPS). These images are categorized by valence (pleasantness/unpleasantness) and arousal (intensity of emotion). The researchers selected neutral and negative images from this database. Background scenes for Experiments 1 and 2 were sourced from the internet. No new benchmarks were introduced; the study utilized existing, well-validated image sets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Emotional Salience vs. Associative Binding: The core idea is that negative emotions and stress might "hijack" attentional resources, enhancing the processing of salient emotional stimuli (item memory) at the expense of the more effortful process of binding these stimuli together into a coherent memory trace (associative memory).
  • Hippocampal vs. Extrahippocampal Systems: The findings support dual-processing models of memory. These models propose that item recognition relies more on perirhinal cortex, while associative memory is heavily dependent on the hippocampus. Negative affect seems to impair hippocampal function while sparing or even strengthening perirhinal cortex-based processing.
  • Threat of Shock as a Stressor: Demonstrating that stress, independent of the emotional content of the stimuli, can impair associative memory is crucial. It suggests that the physiological and psychological state of arousal itself is a key factor.
  • Response Bias in Item Memory: While item memory was generally enhanced or unaffected, the authors noted a potential response bias for negative items, indicated by increased false alarm rates in some recognition tasks. This suggests that participants might be more inclined to say "yes" to negative items, even if they aren't entirely sure.

Key Results

  • Associative Memory Impairment: In all three experiments, negative affect (from negative images or threat of shock) consistently impaired associative memory. For example, in Experiment 1, memory for contexts associated with negative items was significantly reduced compared to neutral items (t(17) = 4.00, P < 0.001).
  • Item Memory Enhancement/Neutrality: In contrast, item memory was either enhanced (Experiment 1: recognition memory was greater for negative items, t(17) = 2.15, P = 0.046) or unaffected (Experiment 2) by negative affect.
  • Stress vs. Negative Stimuli: Experiment 2 showed that the threat of shock impaired context memory similarly to negative items, highlighting the role of arousal.
  • Paired Associates: Experiment 3 confirmed that associative memory was reduced across all conditions involving a negative item, and retrieval of a negative target associate was boosted relative to a neutral target associate when cued by a negative item.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Response Bias: The authors acknowledge that increased false alarm rates for negative items in recognition tasks might suggest a response bias rather than a true memory enhancement. While they corrected for this in their primary analyses, they note that without correction, item memory for negative items appeared enhanced. Future work could further explore this bias.
  • Ecological Validity: While Experiment 3 used simultaneous presentation of images to mimic real-world experiences, the artificial nature of laboratory tasks always remains a limitation.
  • Generalizability: The study used young, healthy volunteers. Future research could investigate these effects in different age groups or clinical populations (e.g., individuals with anxiety disorders).
  • Mechanisms: While the study supports dual-processing models, further neuroimaging studies (e.g., fMRI) could directly investigate the differential activation of hippocampal and perirhinal cortices under emotional conditions. The authors suggest that future work could explore the role of the amygdala in modulating these memory systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

The formation of associations between items and their context has been proposed to rely on mechanisms distinct from those supporting memory for a single item. Although emotional experiences can profoundly affect memory, our understanding of how it interacts with different aspects of memory remains unclear. We performed three experiments to examine the effects of emotion on memory for items and their associations. By presenting neutral and negative items with background contexts, Experiment 1 demonstrated that item memory was facilitated by emotional affect, whereas memory for an associated context was reduced. In Experiment 2, arousal was manipulated independently of the memoranda, by a threat of shock, whereby encoding trials occurred under conditions of threat or safety. Memory for context was equally impaired by the presence of negative affect, whether induced by threat of shock or a negative item, relative to retrieval of the context of a neutral item in safety. In Experiment 3, participants were presented with neutral and negative items as paired associates, including all combinations of neutral and negative items. The results showed both above effects: compared to a neutral item, memory for the associate of a negative item (a second item here, context in Experiments 1 and 2) is impaired, whereas retrieval of the item itself is enhanced. Our findings suggest that negative affect impairs associative memory while recognition of a negative item is enhanced. They support dual-processing models in which negative affect or stress impairs hippocampal-dependent associative memory while the storage of negative sensory/perceptual representations is spared or even strengthened.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bisby2013negative,
  author = {James A. Bisby and Neil Burgess},
  title = {{Negative affect impairs associative memory but not item memory}},
  booktitle = {Learning},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1101/lm.032409.113},
}
Figure