Naturalness and light Higgsinos: why ILC is the right machine for SUSY discovery

Suvi-Leena Lehtinen, Howard Baer, M. Berggren, Jenny List, H. Fujii, Jacqueline Yan, T. Tanabe

This paper explores a critical "blind spot" in our current search for New Physics: the elusive Higgsino. While the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) has yet to find evidence of Supersymmetry (SUSY), the authors argue that we might simply be using the wrong tool for the job. By simulating the capabilities of the proposed International Linear Collider (ILC), they demonstrate how an electron-positron machine could turn a "hidden" sector of SUSY into a precision laboratory.

TL;DR

Natural Supersymmetry predicts the existence of light Higgsinos that are nearly impossible to detect at the LHC due to their compressed mass spectra. This paper shows that the International Linear Collider (ILC) can measure these particles with 1% precision, allowing physicists to "see" the rest of the unobserved SUSY spectrum and test the grand unification of fundamental forces.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In particle physics, "naturalness" is the idea that the universe shouldn't require extreme fine-tuning to function. For the Higgs boson mass to remain stable, many theorists believe Supersymmetry (SUSY) must exist. However, the LHC has not found any SUSY particles yet, leading to a "Little Hierarchy" problem.

The authors point out that "Natural SUSY" specifically requires the $\mu$ parameter (which governs Higgsino masses) to be near the weak scale (100–300 GeV). The catch? These Higgsinos are predicted to be nearly mass-degenerate. When a heavier Higgsino decays into a lighter one, it releases very little visible energy. At a "noisy" hadron collider like the LHC, these tiny signals are buried under a mountain of background data. The paper addresses whether a "cleaner" lepton collider like the ILC can solve this detection crisis.

Methods

The researchers performed a detailed simulation study of the International Large Detector (ILD) concept at the ILC.

  • Simulation Suite: They used Geant4 for detector simulation, Whizard for event generation (including beam effects), and Pythia for hadronization.
  • Benchmark Scenarios: They tested three specific models (ILC1, ILC2, and nGMM1) with varying mass gaps between Higgsinos (ranging from 20 GeV down to 5 GeV).
  • Analysis Technique: They focused on neutralino and chargino pair production. By measuring the maximum energy and invariant mass of decay products (like muon pairs), they could algebraically solve for the absolute masses of the parent SUSY particles.
  • Parameter Fitting: They used the Fittino algorithm (based on Markov Chain Monte Carlo) to take their simulated measurements and "fit" them back to a 10-parameter phenomenological Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (pMSSM).

Datasets

The study does not use external experimental datasets; instead, it generates high-fidelity simulated data:

  • Simulated Integrated Luminosity: 4 $ab^{-1}$ at a center-of-mass energy ($\sqrt{s}$) of 500 GeV.
  • Beam Polarizations: Assumed 80% for electrons and 30% for positrons to help distinguish signal from background.
  • Benchmarks: The study uses the ILC1, ILC2, and nGMM1 benchmarks, which are standard theoretical points used to test the sensitivity of future colliders to "compressed" SUSY spectra.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Precision Telescope: The most striking idea is that measuring light Higgsinos isn't just about finding one particle; it’s about using them as a telescope. Because the light Higgsino masses are sensitive to the properties of much heavier, unobserved SUSY particles (like binos and winos), precise measurements at the ILC can predict the masses of particles that are far beyond the ILC’s direct energy reach.
  • Testing Grand Unification: By measuring the "gaugino" mass parameters ($M_1, M_2$) at the ILC and using Renormalization Group Equations (RGE) to "run" those values up to high energies, physicists can experimentally test if these forces actually unify at the Grand Unification (GUT) scale.
  • Dark Matter Identity: If the lightest Higgsino is the Lightest Supersymmetric Particle (LSP), it is a prime Dark Matter candidate. The paper notes that a Higgsino LSP would only account for ~5% of observed dark matter, implying that the dark sector might be multi-component (e.g., Higgsinos plus axions).

Key Results

  • Mass Precision: Higgsino masses can be measured with 0.2% to 1% precision, even with very small mass splittings.
  • Cross-Sections: Production cross-sections can be determined within 0.5–2%, depending on the beam polarization.
  • Predictive Power: Using the 10-parameter fit, the masses of unobserved heavy SUSY states (like the $\tilde{\chi}^0_3$ or heavy Higgs bosons) can be predicted with roughly 2% uncertainty.
  • Unification Confirmation: The study successfully demonstrated that the measured parameters $M_1$ and $M_2$ unify at approximately $2 \times 10^{16}$ GeV, providing a clear hint of the underlying GUT model.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Energy Ceiling: The ILC’s direct discovery reach is strictly limited by its center-of-mass energy (500 GeV in this study). It can "see" heavier particles through fits, but cannot produce them directly.
  • Model Dependency: The predictive power relies on the assumption that the underlying physics follows the pMSSM framework. If the true model of nature is significantly different, the fits might be less accurate.
  • Future Colliders: The results provide a strong roadmap for what a future 1-3 TeV collider (like a higher-energy ILC or CLIC) should look for, based on the predictions made from the 500 GeV data.

Summary updated

Abstract

Radiatively-driven natural supersymmetry, a theoretically and experimentally well-motivated framework, centers around the predicted existence of four light, nearly mass-degenerate Higgsinos with mass $\sim 100-200$ GeV (not too far above $m_Z$). The small mass splittings amongst the higgsinos, typically 4-20 GeV, results in very little visible energy arising from decays of the heavier higgsinos. Given that other SUSY particles are considerably heavy, this makes detection challenging at hadron colliders. On the other hand, the clean environment of an electron-positron collider with $\sqrt{s}>2m_{higgsino}$ would enable a decisive search of these required higgsinos, and thus either the discovery or exclusion of natural SUSY. We present a detailed simulation study of precision measurements of higgsino masses and production cross sections at $\sqrt{s}$ = 500 GeV of the proposed International Linear Collider currently under consideration for construction in Japan. The study is based on a Geant4 simulation of the International Large Detector concept. We examine several benchmark points just beyond the HL-LHC reach, with four light higgsinos directly accessible by the ILC, and the mass differences between the lightest SUSY particle and the heavier states ranging from about 4 to 20 GeV. It can be shown that their masses and production cross sections can be precisely measured to approximately 1\% precision or better. These precise measurements allow for extracting the underlying weak scale SUSY parameters, giving predictions for the masses of heavier SUSY states. These provide motivation for future high-energy colliders. Additionally, dark matter properties may be derived. Evolution of the measured gaugino masses to high energies should allow testing the hypothesis of gaugino mass unification.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lehtinen2017naturalness,
  author = {Suvi-Leena Lehtinen and Howard Baer and M. Berggren and Jenny List and H. Fujii and Jacqueline Yan and T. Tanabe},
  title = {{Naturalness and light Higgsinos: why ILC is the right machine for SUSY discovery}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of The European Physical Society Conference on High Energy Physics — PoS(EPS-HEP2017)},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.22323/1.314.0306},
}

Loading related content...

Figure