Naturalness and light higgsinos: A powerful reason to build the ILC

Howard Baer, M. Berggren, H. Fujii, Suvi-Leena Lehtinen, Jenny List, T. Tanabe, Jacqueline Yan

Abstract

A core prediction of natural Supersymmetry is the existence of four light higgsinos not too far above the mass of the $Z$ boson. The small mass splittings amongst the higgsinos -- typically 5-20 GeV -- imply very little visible energy release from decays of heavier higgsinos. In particular, if other SUSY particles are quite heavy, as can be the case in SUSY with radiatively-driven naturalness, the higgsinos are extremely hard to detect at hadron colliders. The clean environment of electron-positron colliders with $\sqrt{s} > 2m_{\mathrm{higgsino}}$, however, would allow for a decisive search for the required light higgsinos. Thus, $e^+e^-$ colliders should either discover or exclude natural SUSY. We present a detailed study of higgsino pair production at the proposed International Linear $e^+e^-$ Collider which is under consideration for construction in Japan. A variety of precision measurements should allow for extraction of underlying parameters and provide a window onto physics at the grand unified scale.

Introduction: The Naturalness Problem

The Standard Model of particle physics, while remarkably successful, faces a significant theoretical hurdle known as the "naturalness" problem. The observed mass of the Higgs boson is extremely sensitive to quantum corrections from high-energy scales. Without extreme fine-tuning—where unrelated parameters cancel each other out to a precision of 1 part in 10,000—the Higgs mass should theoretically be much higher than what is observed. Supersymmetry (SUSY) offers a solution by introducing superpartners that cancel these corrections. However, the continued absence of these partners at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) has led to questions regarding the "naturalness" of SUSY itself.

The Challenge of Light Higgsinos

This research argues that natural SUSY specifically requires a small value for the higgsino mass term, $\mu$. This implies the existence of four light higgsinos ($\tilde{\chi}^\pm_1$ and $\tilde{\chi}^0_{1,2}$) with masses in the 100–300 GeV range. Crucially, these particles are expected to have very small mass gaps (5–20 GeV) between them. Because these gaps are so narrow, their decays release very little visible energy, making them nearly invisible against the high-background environment of a proton-proton collider like the LHC. This "blind spot" suggests that natural SUSY could be hiding in plain sight.

The ILC as a Higgsino Factory

The proposed International Linear Collider (ILC) provides a solution to this detection challenge. As an electron-positron collider, the ILC offers a much cleaner experimental environment. Because the initial state energy is precisely known, researchers can use conservation laws to detect the missing energy characteristic of higgsino production. Furthermore, the ILC's ability to polarize its beams is a critical tool for distinguishing between different types of superpartners.

Figure 1: Left: Production cross-sections for higgsino pairs as a function of electron beam polarization. Right: Expected precision for Higgs boson branching ratio deviations from the Standard Model at the ILC.

Methodology and Precision Measurements

The study utilized a high-fidelity simulation based on the "ILC1" benchmark point, a model that satisfies current LHC constraints while maintaining naturalness. Events were generated using WHIZARD 1.95 and passed through a full GEANT4-based simulation of the International Large Detector (ILD).

By focusing on leptonic decays (producing electron or muon pairs), the researchers demonstrated that higgsino masses could be extracted with approximately 1% precision. The invariant mass and energy distributions of the decay products provide the kinematic handles necessary to reconstruct the parent particle masses even with low visible energy release.

Figure 2: Invariant mass distribution ($M_{ee}$) for the process $e^+ e^- \to \tilde{\chi}_1^0 \tilde{\chi}_2^0 \to \tilde{\chi}_1^0 \tilde{\chi}_1^0 e^+ e^-$, showing the clear distinction between the signal and the Standard Model/SUSY backgrounds.

Implications for Grand Unification

The precision achievable at the ILC extends beyond simple discovery. By measuring low-energy parameters like $M_1, M_2, M_3$, and $\tan \beta$ with high accuracy, physicists can use Renormalization Group Equations (RGEs) to "run" these values up to the Grand Unified Theory (GUT) scale ($10^{16}$ GeV). This allows for a direct experimental test of whether the fundamental forces of nature unify, providing a window into the physics of the early universe.

Conclusion

The ILC represents a decisive tool for the future of particle physics. If natural SUSY is the solution to the Higgs mass problem, the ILC's ability to act as a "higgsino factory" will allow it to discover these stealthy particles where the LHC cannot. Beyond discovery, the ILC's precision measurements will offer unprecedented insights into the underlying structure of physical laws at the highest energy scales.

Summary updated

Abstract

A core prediction of natural Supersymmetry is the existence of four light higgsinos not too far above the mass of the $Z$ boson. The small mass splittings amongst the higgsinos -- typically 5-20\,GeV -- imply very little visible energy release from decays of heavier higgsinos. In particular, if other SUSY particles are quite heavy, as can be the case in SUSY with radiatively-driven naturalness, the higgsinos are extremely hard to detect at hadron colliders. The clean environment of electron-positron colliders with $\sqrt{s} > 2m_{\mathrm{higgsino}}$, however, would allow for a decisive search for the required light higgsinos. Thus, $e^+e^-$ colliders should either discover or exclude natural SUSY. We present a detailed study of higgsino pair production at the proposed International Linear $e^+e^-$ Collider which is under consideration for construction in Japan. A variety of precision measurements should allow for extraction of underlying parameters and provide a window onto physics at the grand unified scale.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{baer2017naturalness,
  author = {Howard Baer and M. Berggren and H. Fujii and Suvi-Leena Lehtinen and Jenny List and T. Tanabe and Jacqueline Yan},
  title = {{Naturalness and light higgsinos: A powerful reason to build the ILC}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of 38th International Conference on High Energy Physics — PoS(ICHEP2016)},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.22323/1.282.0156},
}
Figure