Mutual Information Analysis in Multimodal Learning Systems

Hadi Hadizadeh, S. Faegheh Yeganli, Bahador Rashidi, Ivan V. Bajic

Abstract

In recent years, there has been a significant increase in applications of multimodal signal processing and analysis, largely driven by the increased availability of multimodal datasets and the rapid progress in multimodal learning systems. Well-known examples include autonomous vehicles, audiovisual generative systems, vision-language systems, and so on. Such systems integrate multiple signal modalities: text, speech, images, video, LiDAR, etc., to perform various tasks. A key issue for understanding such systems is the relationship between various modalities and how it impacts task performance. In this paper, we employ the concept of mutual information (MI) to gain insight into this issue. Taking advantage of the recent progress in entropy modeling and estimation, we develop a system called InfoMeter to estimate MI between modalities in a multimodal learning system. We then apply InfoMeter to analyze a multimodal 3D object detection system over a large-scale dataset for autonomous driving. Our experiments on this system suggest that a lower MI between modalities is beneficial for detection accuracy. This new insight may facilitate improvements in the development of future multimodal learning systems.

Introduction

In the development of autonomous driving systems, vehicles rely on a multimodal approach, integrating data from cameras, LiDAR, and radar. A prevailing assumption in the research community is that these modalities should reinforce one another through high redundancy. However, information theory suggests a potential trade-off: if sensors provide nearly identical information (high Mutual Information), one may be redundant. Conversely, if they provide distinct information (low Mutual Information), they may be more complementary. This paper investigates whether high MI between modalities actually improves performance or if "modality diversification" is the true driver of accuracy.

Methodology

InfoMeter: Estimating Mutual Information

Estimating MI in high-dimensional neural network features is notoriously difficult due to the "curse of dimensionality." To address this, the authors developed InfoMeter. This tool leverages state-of-the-art learning-based compression techniques (specifically the iWave++ model) to act as an entropy estimator. By treating feature maps as images, InfoMeter calculates MI using the classic Shannon formula: $I(X; Y) = H(X) + H(Y) - H(X, Y)$.

InfoMeter architecture for Mutual Information estimation.

Multimodal 3D Detection Framework

The primary model analyzed is FUTR3D, a transformer-based sensor fusion framework. The system samples features from both camera and LiDAR backbones, passing them through a modality-agnostic fusion layer to predict 3D bounding boxes.

Multimodal 3D object detection framework (FUTR3D).

Controlled MI Manipulation

To observe how MI affects performance, the researchers manipulated the relationship between camera and LiDAR data using four experimental schemes:

  1. Scene Clutter: Sorting data by object density (clutter increases occlusions and typically lowers MI).
  2. Generative Inpainting: Using Stable Diffusion to alter images while leaving LiDAR data untouched.
  3. Classic Inpainting: Masking objects using traditional algorithms.
  4. Synthetic Rain: Adding noise and blurring effects to simulate foul weather.

Experimental Results

The study utilized the nuScenes dataset, containing approximately 40,000 samples. Across all experimental schemes, a consistent trend emerged: Lower MI correlates with higher Mean Average Precision (mAP).

  • Clutter Analysis: The "High Clutter" dataset had a lower MI (4.9 bits) and achieved a significantly higher 55.0% mAP, compared to the "Low Clutter" dataset (MI: 5.7 bits, mAP: 41.9%).
  • Inpainting: The original dataset (lower MI: 5.2 bits) outperformed the distorted version (higher MI: 5.4 bits) by nearly 9% mAP.
  • Weather Effects: Even when noise was introduced, the "Low Noise" version (lower MI: 5.4 bits) maintained a higher mAP (33.6%) than the "High Noise" version (higher MI: 5.5 bits, mAP: 22.8%).

Discussion and Conclusion

The core finding of this research is that multimodal models thrive when sensors provide complementary rather than redundant information. High MI may lead to "information overfitting," where the model fails to learn the unique, nuanced features provided by each sensor individually. This suggests that "modality diversification" is a critical factor for multimodal system performance, much like data augmentation is for unimodal systems. Future work will investigate if this principle holds across different fusion architectures and broader tasks like vision-language modeling.

Summary updated

Abstract

In recent years, there has been a significant increase in applications of multimodal signal processing and analysis, largely driven by the increased availability of multimodal datasets and the rapid progress in multimodal learning systems. Well-known examples include autonomous vehicles, audiovisual generative systems, vision-language systems, and so on. Such systems integrate multiple signal modalities: text, speech, images, video, LiDAR, etc., to perform various tasks. A key issue for understanding such systems is the relationship between various modalities and how it impacts task performance. In this paper, we employ the concept of mutual information (MI) to gain insight into this issue. Taking advantage of the recent progress in entropy modeling and estimation, we develop a system called InfoMeter to estimate MI between modalities in a multimodal learning system. We then apply InfoMeter to analyze a multimodal 3D object detection system over a large-scale dataset for autonomous driving. Our experiments on this system suggest that a lower MI between modalities is beneficial for detection accuracy. This new insight may facilitate improvements in the development of future multimodal learning systems.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hadizadeh2024mutual,
  author = {Hadi Hadizadeh and S. Faegheh Yeganli and Bahador Rashidi and Ivan V. Bajic},
  title = {{Mutual Information Analysis in Multimodal Learning Systems}},
  booktitle = {MIPR},
  year = {2024},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=up4bn3AsDD},
}
Figure