Musical mirror-symmetrical movement tasks: comparison of rhythm versus melody-playing

Serhat Tokgöz, Demet Aydoğdu, Barkın İlhan, Yusuf Levent Şahin, Nurtuğ Barişeri̇, Batu Ozturkler, Tolga ÇukurNeuroreport 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses fMRI to compare the brain activity associated with two bimanual mirror-symmetrical movement (MSM) tasks: playing a musical rhythm versus playing a melody. They found that the more complex melody-playing task engages more cortical areas, particularly in the left hemisphere, and suggests a dominant left-to-right hemispheric influence. In contrast, the simpler rhythm task primarily activates subcortical areas.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Bimanual mirror-symmetrical movement (MSM), where both hands perform the same movement simultaneously, is a fundamental motor skill found across many species. While generally considered "easy" to control, the specific neural mechanisms underlying different types of MSM tasks are not fully understood. This is particularly true for musical MSMs, which involve complex coordination and timing. The authors aim to differentiate the brain's functional anatomy and interhemispheric interactions between two distinct musical MSM tasks: playing a simple rhythm versus a melody. Understanding these differences could have implications for neurophysiology and motor rehabilitation, especially for conditions affecting motor control.

Methods

The researchers recruited 15 right-handed pianists, chosen for their refined motor control. Participants performed two tasks while undergoing functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI):

  • Bimanual Rhythm Task: Participants tapped out a rhythm using their fingers simultaneously on two keyboards. The left keyboard was set up with reversed keys to allow for homologous finger movements with the right hand.
  • Bimanual Melody-Playing Task: Participants played a simple melody on the same reversed keyboard setup. This task required sequential finger movements.

fMRI data was collected using a 1.5 Tesla MRI scanner. Statistical analysis involved:

  • General Linear Models (GLMs): To identify brain regions activated during each task compared to rest, and to compare activations between the two tasks.
  • Laterality Indices: To quantify hemispheric dominance for specific brain regions.
  • Dynamic Causal Modeling (DCM): To investigate the causal connectivity and directional influences between the left and right hemispheres during the tasks.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized fMRI data collected from 15 human participants.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Complexity Matters: The melody-playing task, requiring sequential and memory-based movements, elicited significantly more cortical activation, particularly in the posterior parietal cortex (PPC), compared to the simpler, repetitive rhythm task. This suggests the PPC is involved in processing sequential movements and task complexity.
  • Hemispheric Dominance in Melody: The melody-playing task showed a clear left-hemisphere dominance, with evidence of causal influences flowing from the left to the right cerebral cortex, as indicated by DCM. This suggests a more integrated, top-down control for this complex task.
  • Subcortical Role in Rhythm: The rhythm task, while also activating some cortical areas, showed a stronger engagement of subcortical regions. This hints that simpler, more automatic motor patterns might rely more heavily on these deeper brain structures, potentially with less direct cortical involvement.
  • Shared Core Networks: Both tasks activated common brain regions, including the primary sensorimotor cortex, supplementary motor area (SMA), cerebellum (anterior lobe), left thalamus, and left putamen. This highlights a shared neural substrate for bimanual motor control.

Key Results

  • Melody vs. Rhythm: Significant activations were detected in the posterior parietal cortex (PPC) when comparing melody-playing to rhythm (Fig. 3a). No significant differences were found when comparing rhythm to melody (Fig. 3b).
  • Hemispheric Influence: DCM analysis indicated that melody-playing acted as a modulatory input from the left to the right hemisphere, with a strong probability (1.0) of this directional influence. No such modulatory effect was observed from right to left.
  • Laterality Indices: While most brain regions showed weak lateralization, the frontal lobe and basal ganglia showed slight left-hemisphere lateralization for melody-playing. Frontal laterality indices were significantly more symmetric (less lateralized) during rhythm playing compared to melody-playing.
  • Cerebellar Involvement: Both tasks showed significant cerebellar activations, particularly in the anterior lobe, vermis, and paravermian areas, underscoring its role in bimanual motor control.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Participant Pool: The study focused on pianists, who have specialized motor skills. Future research could explore these tasks in non-musicians to understand the general population's neural responses.
  • Task Specificity: While the study compared two distinct musical MSMs, further investigation into other types of MSM tasks (e.g., non-musical, more complex melodies) could provide a broader understanding.
  • Rehabilitation Potential: The authors suggest that the melody-playing task, with its significant cortical engagement and left-hemisphere dominance, might be more relevant for rehabilitation of deficits related to the primary motor cortex (e.g., after stroke). The subcortical involvement in rhythm playing could also be beneficial. Future studies are needed to evaluate the utility of these tasks in patient populations.
  • Interhemispheric Interaction Nuances: While DCM suggested left-to-right influence in melody-playing, the exact nature of interhemispheric communication (inhibitory vs. excitatory) warrants further exploration.

Summary updated

Abstract

Bimanual mirror-symmetrical movement (MSM) is relatively easy to control movement. Different MSM tasks may have different activations and interhemispheric interactions. The purpose of this study is to compare anatomo-physiological features such as hemispheric activations and dominance of two different MSMs, namely melody-playing and rhythm. We examined functional MRI (fMRI) recordings in a group of fifteen right-handed pianists performing two separate tasks: bimanual rhythm and bimanual melody-playing on two different keyboards with standard key order for right hand and reversed for left hand, which allows homolog fingers' movements. Activations and laterality indices on fMRI were examined. The results show that significant cerebellar activations (especially in anterior cerebellum) in both groups. Significant primary sensorimotor cortical activations are observed in the melody-playing group. While there are also bilaterally symmetric activations, and laterality indices suggest overall lateralization towards the left hemisphere in both groups. Activations in the left fronto-parietal cortex, left putamen and left thalamus in conjunction with right cerebellar activations suggest that the left cortico-thalamo-cerebellar loop may be a dominant loop. Dynamic causal modeling (DCM) indicates the presence of causal influences from the left to the right cerebral cortex. In conclusion, melody-playing with bimanual MSM is a complex in-phase task and may help activate the bilateral cortical areas, and left hemisphere is dominant according to laterality indices and DCM results. On the other hand, bimanual rhythm is a simpler in-phase task and may help activate subcortical areas, which might be independent of the voluntary cortical task.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tokgoz2020musical,
  author = {Serhat Tokgöz and Demet Aydoğdu and Barkın İlhan and Yusuf Levent Şahin and Nurtuğ Barişeri̇ and Batu Ozturkler and Tolga Çukur},
  title = {{Musical mirror-symmetrical movement tasks: comparison of rhythm versus melody-playing}},
  booktitle = {Neuroreport},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1097/wnr.0000000000001433},
}
Figure