Music-selective neural populations arise without musical training

Dana Boebinger, Sam Norman-Haignere, Josh H. McDermott, Nancy Kanwisher

TL;DR

This study reveals that the brain's ability to selectively process music, a hallmark of auditory cortex, emerges even without extensive musical training. This suggests that music selectivity is a fundamental property of the human brain, likely shaped by passive exposure rather than explicit instruction.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The human auditory cortex contains specialized neural populations that respond preferentially to music. However, the origin of this "music selectivity" has been a puzzle. A key question is whether this selectivity is a learned trait, requiring dedicated musical training, or if it develops through more general exposure to music. Previous studies have often included participants with varying levels of musical experience, making it difficult to isolate the effect of explicit training. This paper directly tackles this by investigating music selectivity in individuals with minimal to no formal musical training, comparing them to highly trained musicians.

Methods

The core of the study utilizes voxel decomposition, a technique that breaks down the complex fMRI response in auditory cortex into a smaller set of underlying "component" response profiles. This allows researchers to disentangle overlapping neural signals and identify populations with specific selectivities. The authors applied this method to fMRI data from participants listening to a diverse set of 192 natural sounds.

Key aspects of their approach include:

  • Voxel Selection: Voxels showing a significant response to sound and reliable patterns across scanning sessions were selected.
  • Decomposition Algorithm: An independent component analysis (ICA)-like method was used to infer a set of shared response profiles and their corresponding weights across voxels. This algorithm aims to find components with maximally non-Gaussian weight distributions, indicating specialized neural populations.
  • Music Selectivity Measurement: Selectivity was quantified using Cohen's d, measuring the separability of music and non-music sound responses within the music-selective component.
  • Anatomical Localization: Component weights were projected onto the cortical surface to visualize their distribution in specific brain regions.

This approach builds upon previous work by Norman-Haignere et al. (2015) but applies it to a group with significantly less musical training.

Datasets

The study used a dataset of 192 natural sounds. This included:

  • 165 sounds from a previously established set (Norman-Haignere et al., 2015) that broadly sampled everyday sounds.
  • 27 additional music and drumming clips from various musical cultures, including non-Western genres, to explore responses to rhythmic features and unfamiliar music.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Music Selectivity is Not Solely Training-Dependent: The most striking finding is that individuals with almost no musical training exhibit a music-selective neural component with response profiles and anatomical distributions remarkably similar to those found in individuals with moderate musical training. This strongly suggests that explicit musical training is not a prerequisite for developing this specialized auditory processing.
  • Passive Exposure is Sufficient: The results point towards passive exposure to music, a common experience in Western societies, being sufficient for the emergence of music selectivity in non-primary auditory cortex.
  • Broad Responsiveness of Music Selectivity: The music-selective component responded strongly not only to familiar Western music but also to less familiar genres (e.g., Balinese gamelan) and to drum clips that emphasize rhythm over melody. This indicates that this neural population is broadly tuned to musical features, not just those specific to a particular culture or melodic structure.
  • Rhythm Sensitivity: The strong response to drum rhythms suggests that music selectivity is not solely driven by pitch or melody, but also by rhythmic patterns, highlighting the complex interplay of acoustic features that define music for the brain.

Key Results

  • Replication of Components: The same six functional components previously identified in auditory cortex were replicated in both the non-musician and musician groups.
  • Music Component Similarity: The music-selective component in non-musicians showed a highly similar response profile and anatomical distribution (concentrated in anterior and posterior superior temporal gyrus) to that observed in musicians and in previous studies.
  • Unfamiliar Music and Rhythm: Non-musicians showed strong responses within the music component to unfamiliar musical genres and drum clips with rhythm but little melody.
  • Behavioral Validation: Musicians outperformed non-musicians on various psychoacoustic tasks (frequency discrimination, sensorimotor synchronization, melody discrimination, and "sour note" detection), validating their self-reported musical expertise.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size for Direct Comparison: While the study demonstrates the presence of music selectivity in non-musicians, direct statistical comparisons of the magnitude of music selectivity between musicians and non-musicians were limited by sample size. The authors suggest that a small difference might exist but their study was underpowered to detect it.
  • fMRI Resolution: The study acknowledges that fMRI's spatial and temporal resolution may limit the detection of finer-grained neural activity. Future work could employ methods like M/EEG or ECoG to investigate these aspects.
  • Future Directions: The authors propose several avenues for future research:
  • Investigating the role of implicit knowledge vs. innate predisposition by studying populations with very different musical experiences (e.g., non-Western cultures, musical anhedonia, children).
  • Testing music selectivity in infants and young children to explore its developmental trajectory.
  • Further exploring the specific acoustic and musical features that drive music selectivity, such as the interplay of melody and rhythm.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recent work has shown that human auditory cortex contains neural populations anterior and posterior to primary auditory cortex that respond selectively to music. However, it is unknown how this selectivity for music arises. To test whether musical training is necessary, we measured fMRI responses to 192 natural sounds in 10 people with almost no musical training. When voxel responses were decomposed into underlying components, this group exhibited a music-selective component that was very similar in response profile and anatomical distribution to that previously seen in individuals with moderate musical training. We also found that musical genres that were less familiar to our participants (e.g., Balinese <i>gamelan</i>) produced strong responses within the music component, as did drum clips with rhythm but little melody, suggesting that these neural populations are broadly responsive to music as a whole. Our findings demonstrate that the signature properties of neural music selectivity do not require musical training to develop, showing that the music-selective neural populations are a fundamental and widespread property of the human brain.<b>NEW & NOTEWORTHY</b> We show that music-selective neural populations are clearly present in people without musical training, demonstrating that they are a fundamental and widespread property of the human brain. Additionally, we show music-selective neural populations respond strongly to music from unfamiliar genres as well as music with rhythm but little pitch information, suggesting that they are broadly responsive to music as a whole.
BibTeX
@article{boebinger2021music,
  author = {Dana Boebinger and Sam Norman-Haignere and Josh H. McDermott and Nancy Kanwisher},
  title = {{Music-selective neural populations arise without musical training}},
  journal = {Journal of Neurophysiology},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1152/jn.00588.2020},
}
Figure