Multivariate Statistics and Hydrochemistry Combined to Reveal the Factors Affecting Shallow Groundwater Evolution in a Typical Area of the Huaibei Plain, China

Qin Xi, Hesheng Wang, Jianshi Gong, Yonghong Ye, Kai Zhou, Naizheng Xu, Liang Li, Jie LiWater 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study combines hydrogeochemical analysis with multivariate statistics to understand the factors controlling shallow groundwater chemistry in China's Huaibei Plain. The research reveals that natural water-rock interactions, particularly carbonate weathering and cation exchange, are the primary drivers, with mineral dissolution significantly increasing total dissolved solids. The findings identify distinct zones of agricultural/urban influence, high fluoride, and nitrate contamination, offering crucial insights for sustainable groundwater management.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Groundwater is a vital resource, especially for agriculture and domestic supply. Understanding its chemical evolution is crucial for sustainable management. However, the Huaibei Plain, a significant agricultural and coal-mining region in China, has seen limited comprehensive studies on the factors influencing its shallow groundwater chemistry. This lack of detailed understanding poses challenges for effective water resource development and protection. The paper aims to fill this gap by systematically investigating the hydrogeochemical processes and identifying the key drivers behind the chemical composition of shallow groundwater in this region.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Hydrogeochemical Mapping: Traditional methods like Piper diagrams were used to classify groundwater types and visualize their spatial distribution.
  • Gibbs Diagrams and Ion Ratio Analysis: These techniques were used to differentiate between the dominant hydrogeochemical processes, such as rock weathering, precipitation, and evaporation, and to assess the relative contributions of different ion sources.
  • Multivariate Statistical Analysis:
    • Pearson Correlation Analysis: Used to identify significant linear relationships between different chemical parameters, suggesting common sources or processes.
  • Principal Component Analysis (PCA): Applied to reduce the dimensionality of the dataset and identify underlying factors or sources contributing to the observed chemical variations.
  • Hierarchical Cluster Analysis (HCA): Employed to group water samples with similar chemical characteristics, helping to delineate distinct hydrogeochemical zones within the study area.

These statistical methods were integrated with traditional hydrochemical analyses to provide a more robust understanding of the complex groundwater system.

Datasets

The study utilized 28 shallow groundwater samples collected from the Huaibei Plain during March-April 2023. The samples were collected from wells primarily located in agricultural areas and near farmers' homes. The wells varied in depth (around 10m and 20m) and were used for agricultural irrigation, domestic purposes, or a combination of both.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dominance of Natural Processes: The study strongly emphasizes that natural water-rock interactions, specifically carbonate weathering and cation exchange, are the primary forces shaping the groundwater chemistry, largely overshadowing anthropogenic influences in many areas.
  • Mineral Dissolution as a Key Driver of TDS: The research highlights that the dissolution of various minerals is the main reason for the accumulation of total dissolved solids (TDS) in the shallow groundwater, with Na+, Mg2+, Cl-, and SO42- being particularly significant contributors.
  • Spatial Zonation of Groundwater Quality: The application of HCA successfully identified distinct zones with specific hydrogeochemical characteristics, revealing areas impacted by agriculture/urbanization, zones with high fluoride and low hardness, and regions showing signs of nitrate contamination. This spatial differentiation is crucial for targeted management.
  • Cation Exchange Dynamics: The paper provides evidence for cation exchange processes, particularly the exchange between Ca2+ in groundwater and Na+ adsorbed on clay minerals, as a key mechanism influencing the overall chemical composition and explaining higher average Na+ concentrations.

Key Results

  • Hydrochemical Facies: The predominant hydrochemical type identified was HCO3-Ca·Mg (64.3%), with mixed SO4·Cl-Ca·Mg and SO4·Cl-Na types also present.
  • TDS and Hardness: A significant portion (60.7%) of the samples exceeded the permitted threshold for TDS (1000 mg/L), with values ranging from 512.8 to 4784.5 mg/L. The groundwater was classified as fresh to brackish, with hardness generally falling into the "hard" to "very hard" categories.
  • Anthropogenic vs. Natural Influences: While industrial and mining activities were found to have the most pronounced impacts, the study also indicated that agricultural and domestic sources contributed significantly, with their combined impact being comparable. However, in many areas, natural processes like carbonate weathering were found to be more influential than anthropogenic inputs.
  • Identification of Contaminated Zones: HCA identified three key zones: (1) agricultural/urban-influenced areas, (2) high-F-/low-hardness zones, and (3) nitrate-contaminated regions, providing a spatial framework for understanding localized issues.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Anthropogenic Impact Assessment: While the study acknowledges anthropogenic influences, the paper notes that the difference between domestic sewage and agricultural impacts was not statistically significant, suggesting a need for more refined methods to differentiate these sources.
  • Data Availability: The study mentions that the data is not publicly available as it is part of an ongoing study, which limits immediate broader access and verification by the research community.
  • Future Work Suggestions: The findings provide a scientific foundation for sustainable groundwater development, management, and protection. Future work could focus on more detailed investigations into the specific sources and pathways of contaminants within the identified zones, as well as the long-term implications of these hydrogeochemical processes on water resource sustainability. Further research could also explore the integration of more advanced modeling techniques to predict future groundwater evolution under different scenarios.

Summary updated

Abstract

Understanding the characteristics of groundwater chemistry is essential for water resource development and utilization. However, few studies have focused on the chemical evolution processes of shallow groundwater in typical areas of the Huaibei Plain. We analyzed 28 water samples from the study area using hydrogeochemical mapping, multivariate statistical analysis, and other approaches. The study found that the hydrogeochemical facies of groundwater are mainly HCO3-Ca·Mg (64.3%), mixed SO4·Cl-Ca·Mg, and SO4·Cl-Na. The hydrochemical composition is primarily controlled by natural water–rock interactions, including carbonate weathering and cation exchange processes. Correlation analysis and principal component analysis (PCA) revealed that mineral dissolution was the predominant source of Na+, Mg2+, Cl−, and SO42− in shallow groundwater, significantly contributing to total dissolved solids (TDS) accumulation. Hierarchical cluster analysis (HCA) identified three characteristic zones: (1) agricultural/urban-influenced areas, (2) high-F−/low-hardness zones, and (3) nitrate-contaminated regions. These findings provide critical insights for assessing the geochemical status of groundwater in the Huaibei Plain and formulating targeted resource management strategies.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xi2025multivariate,
  author = {Qin Xi and Hesheng Wang and Jianshi Gong and Yonghong Ye and Kai Zhou and Naizheng Xu and Liang Li and Jie Li},
  title = {{Multivariate Statistics and Hydrochemistry Combined to Reveal the Factors Affecting Shallow Groundwater Evolution in a Typical Area of the Huaibei Plain, China}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/w17070962},
}
Figure