Multiscale entropy analysis of retinal signals reveals reduced complexity in a mouse model of Alzheimer’s disease

Joaquín Araya-Arriagada, Sebastián Garay, Cristóbal Rojas, Claudia Duran‐Aniotz, Adrián G. Palacios, Máx Chacón, Leonel E. Medina

This research paper, published in Scientific Reports, explores a novel way to detect Alzheimer’s disease (AD) by looking at the "complexity" of electrical signals in the retina. By applying multiscale entropy (MSE) analysis to retinal recordings in mice, the authors demonstrate that both aging and AD lead to a measurable loss of signal complexity, particularly when the retina is challenged with naturalistic visual stimuli.

TL;DR

Researchers have found that retinal electrical signals lose "complexity" in the early stages of Alzheimer’s disease, long before traditional diagnostic markers appear. By using multiscale entropy analysis on mouse models, the study suggests that the retina could serve as a non-invasive "window" for early AD diagnosis, provided we use the right mathematical tools and visual stimuli.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Early diagnosis of Alzheimer’s disease is notoriously difficult. Currently, definitive diagnosis often requires post-mortem examination or expensive, invasive procedures like PET imaging and cerebrospinal fluid analysis.

Because the retina is an anatomical extension of the brain, it often manifests the same pathological signatures as AD, such as amyloid-β plaques. However, traditional electroretinograms (ERGs)—which measure the electrical response of the eye to light—typically focus on signal amplitude and timing. These metrics often only show significant changes during the advanced stages of the disease. The authors sought a more sensitive "biomarker" by looking at the underlying dynamics and information-processing capacity of the retinal network using the lens of "complexity-loss theory."

Methods

The team recorded microelectroretinograms (µERG) from the retinas of 5xFAD mice ( a common AD model) and healthy wild-type (WT) mice across two age groups: young (2–3 months) and adult (6–7 months).

The core innovation lies in the analysis:

  • Multiscale Entropy (MSE): Unlike standard entropy, which measures randomness at a single scale, MSE calculates entropy across multiple time scales using a "coarse-graining" procedure. This allows researchers to distinguish between mere noise and true biological complexity.
  • Refined Composite MSE (RCMSE) with Fuzzy Entropy: The authors used a sophisticated version of MSE that is more robust for shorter biological signals.
  • Visual Stimuli: They compared two types of light stimuli: a synthetic "Chirp" stimulus (varying frequency and intensity) and a "Natural Image" sequence (video of a natural habitat).

Datasets

The study utilized ex-vivo retinal recordings from four specific groups of mice:

  1. WT-young (n=13 retinas)
  2. 5xFAD-young (n=12 retinas)
  3. WT-adult (n=11 retinas)
  4. 5xFAD-adult (n=11 retinas)

The raw data included 252-channel electrode recordings, which were averaged and filtered to produce the µERG signals analyzed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Complexity-Loss Theory: The results support the idea that healthy biological systems are inherently complex and nonlinear. Aging and disease break down these interactions, leading to a more "predictable" or less adaptive signal.
  • Naturalism Matters: One of the most significant "aha" moments was that the Natural Image (NI) protocol was far more effective at revealing disease-related changes than the synthetic Chirp protocol. Naturalistic stimuli likely "stress" the retinal circuit in a way that exposes subtle functional deficits.
  • Early Detection Potential: MSE analysis detected differences in the young 5xFAD mice (2–3 months old). At this age, traditional amplitude-based ERG measures usually show no significant impairment, suggesting MSE is a much more sensitive early-warning system.

Key Results

  • Aging Effect: In healthy (WT) mice, complexity significantly decreased with age. The complexity index for the Chirp protocol dropped from 14.70 in young mice to 12.82 in adults (p = 0.0244).
  • Disease Effect: Under the Natural Image protocol, young WT retinas exhibited significantly higher complexity (22.72) compared to young 5xFAD retinas (21.26, p = 0.0207).
  • Signal Dynamics: While the power spectral density (the "strength" of different frequencies) was similar across all groups, the entropy analysis revealed that the structure of the signals was fundamentally different in diseased retinas.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several hurdles before this can reach the clinic:

  • Ex-vivo vs. In-vivo: These recordings were done on pieces of retina outside the body. Translating this to a living eye (in-vivo) is the next logical step.
  • Gender Disparities: The study had an imbalance of sexes in the young groups (more males in WT, more females in 5xFAD). Given that AD affects sexes differently, future studies need more balanced cohorts.
  • Diagnostic Classification: While the group averages were different, there is still overlap between individuals. The authors suggest that future work should use Machine Learning to classify individual patients based on these complexity indices.
  • Stimulus Optimization: Finding the "perfect" visual stimulus—perhaps white noise or more complex natural scenes—could further increase the sensitivity of the test.

Summary updated

Abstract

Alzheimer's disease (AD) is one of the most significant health challenges of our time, affecting a growing number of the elderly population. In recent years, the retina has received increased attention as a candidate for AD biomarkers since it appears to manifest the pathological signatures of the disease. Therefore, its electrical activity may hint at AD-related physiological changes. However, it is unclear how AD affects retinal electrophysiology and what tools are more appropriate to detect these possible changes. In this study, we used entropy tools to estimate the complexity of the dynamics of healthy and diseased retinas at different ages. We recorded microelectroretinogram responses to visual stimuli of different nature from retinas of young and adult, wild-type and 5xFAD-an animal model of AD-mice. To estimate the complexity of signals, we used the multiscale entropy approach, which calculates the entropy at several time scales using a coarse graining procedure. We found that young retinas had more complex responses to different visual stimuli. Further, the responses of young, wild-type retinas to natural-like stimuli exhibited significantly higher complexity than young, 5xFAD retinas. Our findings support a theory of complexity-loss with aging and disease and can have significant implications for early AD diagnosis.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{arayaarriagada2022multiscale,
  author = {Joaquín Araya-Arriagada and Sebastián Garay and Cristóbal Rojas and Claudia Duran‐Aniotz and Adrián G. Palacios and Máx Chacón and Leonel E. Medina},
  title = {{Multiscale entropy analysis of retinal signals reveals reduced complexity in a mouse model of Alzheimer’s disease}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-022-12208-2},
}
Figure