Multiscale analysis of shear failure of thick-walled hollow cylinder in dry sand

Ning Guo, Jidong Zhao, WaiChing SunGéotechnique 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel multiscale modeling approach combining Finite Element Method (FEM) and Discrete Element Method (DEM) to simulate shear failure in thick-walled hollow cylinders filled with dry sand. This method successfully replicates complex curvilinear shear bands observed in experiments, offering a deeper understanding of how particle-level behavior influences macroscopic soil failure.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the mechanical behavior of soils under complex loading conditions, such as cavity expansion, is crucial in geotechnical engineering. Thick-walled hollow cylinder (TWHC) tests are a standard method for studying this, often revealing intricate shear failure patterns. Traditional numerical models (like FEM) rely on phenomenological constitutive laws that require numerous internal variables to capture the inherent anisotropy and evolving fabric of granular materials. This can be cumbersome and may not fully represent the underlying physics. The challenge is to develop a numerical framework that can accurately predict these complex failure patterns without resorting to overly complex macroscopic models, by directly linking micro-scale particle interactions to macro-scale soil behavior.

Methods

The authors employ a hierarchical multiscale modeling approach, combining the strengths of FEM and DEM.

  • FEM (Macroscopic Scale): The overall boundary value problem of the TWHC test is solved using FEM. This method is efficient for handling large-scale deformations and boundary conditions.
  • DEM (Microscopic Scale): Instead of a traditional constitutive law, the FEM uses DEM simulations at specific points (Gauss quadrature points) within the FEM mesh. These points represent "representative volume elements" (RVEs) of the granular material.
  • Coupling: At each loading step, the macroscopic deformation from the FEM is applied to the RVEs. The DEM simulations within these RVEs then compute the resulting stresses and stiffness tensors. These homogenized values are fed back to the FEM to update the macroscopic solution.

This FEM/DEM coupling allows the model to capture the path-dependent behavior and microstructural evolution (like particle rotations and force chains) that lead to macroscopic failure, bypassing the need for predefined phenomenological models.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on numerical simulations and compares its results to existing experimental data from the literature (e.g., Alsiny et al., 1992).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging Scales: The multiscale FEM/DEM approach provides a powerful tool for connecting grain-scale mechanics to macroscopic soil behavior, offering insights not easily obtainable with single-scale models.
  • Emergent Anisotropy: The model demonstrates how particle rearrangements and rotations at the micro-scale naturally lead to the anisotropic behavior observed macroscopically, particularly within shear bands.
  • Shear Band Genesis: The simulations successfully reproduce the formation of curvilinear shear bands, a key failure mechanism in TWHC tests, by capturing the localized particle rotations and fabric evolution within these zones.
  • Cavity Pressure Prediction: The model qualitatively replicates the evolution of cavity pressure during expansion, including the post-peak softening, aligning well with experimental observations where analytical models struggle due to the complexity of strain localization.

Key Results

  • The multiscale FEM/DEM model successfully simulated the TWHC tests in dry sand, reproducing the characteristic curvilinear shear bands observed in experiments.
  • The model captured the evolution of cavity pressure during expansion, showing qualitative agreement with laboratory tests, including post-peak softening.
  • The simulations revealed a strong correlation between significant particle rotations within dilative shear bands and the highly anisotropic microstructural attributes of the RVEs at those locations.
  • The peak cavity pressure predicted by the multiscale model was found to be lower than analytical solutions based on simple elasto-perfect-plastic models, which the authors attribute to the complex strain localization and softening behavior captured by their approach.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Particle Shape: The authors acknowledge that using circular particles in the DEM model is a limitation. For more quantitative modeling of sand behavior, they suggest that considering realistic particle shapes is a necessary future pursuit.
  • Experimental Data: While the study compares its results to existing experimental data, it does not present new experimental datasets.
  • Future Work: The authors indicate that incorporating realistic particle shapes into the DEM model is a key area for future research to improve the quantitative accuracy of the simulations.

Summary updated

Abstract

A novel hierarchical multiscale model has been applied to simulate the thick-walled hollow cylinder tests in dry sand and to investigate the corresponding shear failures. The combined finite-element method and discrete-element method (FEM/DEM) model employs the FEM as a vehicle to advance the solution for a macroscopic non-linear boundary value problem incrementally. It is, meanwhile, free of conventional macroscopic phenomenological constitutive law, which is replaced by discrete-element simulations conducted with representative volume elements (RVEs) associated with the Gauss quadrature points of the FEM mesh. Numerical simulations proposed by the authors indicate that this multiscale approach is capable of replicating the evolution of cavity pressure during cavity expansion – before and after the onset of strain localisation – in qualitative agreement with laboratory tests. In particular, the curvilinear shear bands observed from experiments have been reproduced numerically. The information provided by the mesoscale DEM and the macroscale FEM reveals a close linkage between significant particle rotations taking place inside the dilative shear bands and the highly anisotropic microstructural attributes of the associated RVEs.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{guo2016multiscale,
  author = {Ning Guo and Jidong Zhao and WaiChing Sun},
  title = {{Multiscale analysis of shear failure of thick-walled hollow cylinder in dry sand}},
  booktitle = {Géotechnique},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1680/jgele.15.00149},
}
Figure