Multi-messenger Emission from Tidal Waves in Neutron Star Oceans

Andrew G. Sullivan, Lucas M. B. Alves, Georgina O. Spence, Isabella P. Leite, Doğa Veske, I. Bartos, Zsuzsa Márka, Szabolcs Márka

Abstract

Neutron stars in astrophysical binary systems represent exciting sources for multi-messenger astrophysics. A potential source of electromagnetic transients from compact binary systems is the neutron star ocean, the external fluid layer encasing a neutron star. We present a groundwork study into tidal waves in neutron star oceans and their consequences. Specifically, we investigate how oscillation modes in neutron star oceans can be tidally excited during compact binary inspirals and parabolic encounters. We find that neutron star oceans can sustain tidal waves with frequencies between $0.01-20$ Hz. Our results suggest that tidally resonant neutron star ocean waves may serve as a never-before studied source of precursor electromagnetic emission prior to neutron star-black hole and binary neutron star mergers. If accompanied by electromagnetic flares, tidally resonant neutron star ocean waves, whose energy budget can reach $10^{46}$ erg, may serve as early warning signs ($\gtrsim 1$ minute before merger) for compact binary mergers. Similarly, excited ocean tidal waves will coincide with neutron star parabolic encounters. Depending on the neutron star ocean model and a flare emission scenario, tidally resonant ocean flares may be detectable by Fermi and NuSTAR out to $\gtrsim 100$ Mpc with detection rates as high as $\sim 7$ yr$^{-1}$ for binary neutron stars and $\sim0.6$ yr$^{-1}$ for neutron star-black hole binaries. Observations of emission from neutron star ocean tidal waves along with gravitational waves will provide insight into the equation of state at the neutron star surface, the composition of neutron star oceans and crusts, and neutron star geophysics.

Introduction

In the era of multi-messenger astrophysics, identifying electromagnetic (EM) precursors to compact binary mergers is a high priority. While most research focuses on the dense core or solid crust of neutron stars, the external fluid layer—the neutron star ocean—remains a promising but under-explored source of transient emission. This study investigates how tidal waves in these oceans can be excited during binary inspirals and parabolic encounters, potentially serving as early warning signs for gravitational-wave (GW) events.

Modeling the Neutron Star Ocean

The researchers employed a Newtonian fluid dynamics framework to model the neutron star and its overlying ocean. The ocean's depth is determined by the melting point of the crust, which varies with temperature and chemical composition. Three primary compositions were analyzed: Carbon (C), Oxygen (O), and Iron (Fe). Using the Cowling approximation, the team solved for fluid displacements to identify oscillation modes.

Eigenfunctions $U/r$ (radial) and $V/r$ (horizontal) for a $0.44$ Hz tidal mode in a thin iron ocean (depth $\approx 0.8$ mm).

Tidal Resonances and Early Warning Signals

Ocean waves sustain low-frequency resonances between $0.01$ and $20$ Hz. These frequencies are significantly lower than the kHz-range core modes, allowing them to resonate with the binary orbit much earlier in the inspiral process. The specific composition of the ocean dictates the resonance frequency; for instance, Carbon oceans exhibit higher frequencies ($\sim 16$ Hz) compared to Iron oceans ($\sim 0.4$ Hz).

Horizontal displacement eigenfunction $V/r$ for a $16.66$ Hz mode in a thicker carbon ocean (depth $\approx 110$ cm).

When these ocean waves reach resonance, they can accumulate an energy budget of up to $10^{46}$ erg. This energy is sufficient to potentially fracture the neutron star crust, triggering magnetic reconnection and bright X-ray or gamma-ray flares. The timing of these resonances provides a critical "early warning" window. For a rigid crust, resonance typically occurs $1$ to $5$ minutes before merger. However, if the crust is elastic, waves can penetrate deeper, potentially shifting the resonance to hours or even years before the final collision.

Detectability and Multi-messenger Prospects

If these tidal resonances produce EM flares, they could be detectable by current observatories like Fermi and NuSTAR at distances $\gtrsim 100$ Mpc. The study estimates detection rates of up to $\sim 7$ yr$^{-1}$ for binary neutron star (BNS) mergers and $\sim 0.6$ yr$^{-1}$ for neutron star-black hole (NSBH) binaries. While the ocean waves themselves generate GWs, their strain is too weak for current detectors, making the EM flare the primary multi-messenger signal.

Conclusion

Observations of EM emission from neutron star ocean tidal waves, paired with GW detections, would provide unprecedented insights into the neutron star equation of state, surface composition, and internal geophysics. Future work incorporating General Relativity, magnetic fields, and rotation will be essential to refine these predictions and model the specific flare emission mechanisms.

Summary updated

Abstract

Neutron stars in astrophysical binary systems represent exciting sources for multi-messenger astrophysics. A potential source of electromagnetic transients from compact binary systems is the neutron star ocean, the external fluid layer encasing a neutron star. We present a groundwork study into tidal waves in neutron star oceans and their consequences. Specifically, we investigate how oscillation modes in neutron star oceans can be tidally excited during compact binary inspirals and parabolic encounters. We find that neutron star oceans can sustain tidal waves with frequencies between $0.01-20$ Hz. Our results suggest that tidally resonant neutron star ocean waves may serve as a never-before studied source of precursor electromagnetic emission prior to neutron star-black hole and binary neutron star mergers. If accompanied by electromagnetic flares, tidally resonant neutron star ocean waves, whose energy budget can reach $10^{46}$ erg, may serve as early warning signs ($\gtrsim 1$ minute before merger) for compact binary mergers. Similarly, excited ocean tidal waves will coincide with neutron star parabolic encounters. Depending on the neutron star ocean model and a flare emission scenario, tidally resonant ocean flares may be detectable by Fermi and NuSTAR out to $\gtrsim 100$ Mpc with detection rates as high as $\sim 7$ yr$^{-1}$ for binary neutron stars and $\sim0.6$ yr$^{-1}$ for neutron star-black hole binaries. Observations of emission from neutron star ocean tidal waves along with gravitational waves will provide insight into the equation of state at the neutron star surface, the composition of neutron star oceans and crusts, and neutron star geophysics.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sullivan2023multi,
  author = {Andrew G. Sullivan and Lucas M. B. Alves and Georgina O. Spence and Isabella P. Leite and Doğa Veske and I. Bartos and Zsuzsa Márka and Szabolcs Márka},
  title = {{Multi-messenger Emission from Tidal Waves in Neutron Star Oceans}},
  booktitle = {Monthly},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1093/mnras/stad389},
}

Loading related content...

Figure