Multilevel Bayesian Deep Neural Networks

Neil K. Chada, Ajay Jasra, Kody J. H. Law, Sumeetpal S. Singh

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method for Bayesian inference in deep neural networks (DNNs) by combining "trace-class neural network" (TNN) priors with a "multilevel Monte Carlo" (MLMC) sampling technique. This approach significantly reduces the computational cost of Bayesian DNNs, achieving optimal convergence rates for approximating posterior expectations, which is crucial for reliable uncertainty quantification in machine learning.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Bayesian inference with deep neural networks (DNNs) offers a powerful way to quantify uncertainty, but it's notoriously computationally expensive. Traditional DNNs can be difficult to work with in a Bayesian setting due to issues with identifiability and convergence. While "trace-class neural network" (TNN) priors offer improvements in these areas, the computational burden of Bayesian inference with them remains a significant hurdle. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a more efficient method for Bayesian inference in DNNs, specifically addressing the challenge of high computational cost while maintaining desirable theoretical properties.

Methods

The core of this paper lies in the development of Multilevel Bayesian Deep Neural Networks. This approach combines two key components:

  • Trace-Class Neural Network (TNN) Priors: These are a specific type of prior distribution for DNNs that are designed to be more robust and identifiable than traditional DNN priors. They are well-defined in the infinite-width limit and scale well with input dimensions.
  • Multilevel Monte Carlo (MLMC) Sampling: MLMC is a variance reduction technique that aims to reduce the computational cost of Monte Carlo methods. It achieves this by using a hierarchy of models (levels) with increasing complexity and computational cost, and cleverly combining samples from these levels to achieve a desired accuracy with lower overall cost. The paper specifically leverages an advanced MLMC method called Multilevel Sequential Monte Carlo (MLSMC).

The authors mathematically prove that their MLSMC approach, when applied to TNN priors, achieves the "canonical asymptotic computational complexity" of $1/\text{MSE}$, meaning the computational cost scales optimally with the desired mean squared error.

Datasets

The paper evaluates its methodology on several standard machine learning datasets:

  • Toy regression and classification models: Used for initial verification of theoretical findings.
  • MNIST dataset: A widely used dataset for handwritten digit recognition, employed for binary classification.
  • IMDb dataset: A large dataset of movie reviews used for sentiment classification.
  • 2D spiral dataset: Used for a spiral classification problem.
  • HalfCheetah: A benchmark from reinforcement learning.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the Gap: The paper successfully demonstrates that MLMC techniques, typically applied to diffusion processes, can be effectively adapted for Bayesian inference in deep neural networks, a domain where computational cost has been a major bottleneck.
  • TNN Priors + MLMC = Efficiency: The combination of TNN priors and MLMC is shown to be particularly powerful. TNNs provide desirable theoretical properties, while MLMC provides the computational efficiency needed to make Bayesian inference practical.
  • Canonical Convergence: The authors rigorously prove that their method achieves the optimal $O(\epsilon^{-2})$ rate of convergence for approximating posterior expectations, a significant theoretical achievement. This means the computational cost grows as slowly as theoretically possible for a given level of accuracy.
  • Robustness: The numerical experiments across various tasks (regression, classification, reinforcement learning) and parameter choices highlight the robustness and practical utility of the proposed methodology.

Key Results

  • Computational Cost Reduction: The MLMC methodology, when applied to TNN priors, achieves a significant reduction in computational cost for Bayesian inference compared to standard Monte Carlo (SMC) samplers. This reduction is often by an order of magnitude, as illustrated in the error-vs-cost plots.
  • Canonical Rate of Convergence: The proposed method consistently attains the canonical rate of convergence ($O(\epsilon^{-2})$) for various machine learning tasks, including regression, MNIST classification, and reinforcement learning. This is a key theoretical guarantee.
  • Sub-Canonical Rates: The paper also explores scenarios with lower regularity TNN priors, demonstrating that while sub-canonical rates are observed, there is still an improvement factor compared to single-level methods.
  • Practical Performance: The method shows strong performance on challenging datasets like IMDb for sentiment classification, achieving comparable accuracy to state-of-the-art methods while offering better uncertainty quantification.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Parameter Tuning: The authors acknowledge that tuning the MLMC sampler and the TNN parameters can be a non-trivial task, though they suggest adaptive methods can help.
  • Multi-Index Monte Carlo: For future work, they suggest extending the methodology to multi-index Monte Carlo, which could potentially offer further efficiency gains.
  • Other Applications: Exploring applications beyond the tested domains, such as clustering, is also proposed.
  • Advanced Monte Carlo Proposals: Investigating more advanced Monte Carlo proposals, like those based on gradient information, could enhance performance, especially in reinforcement learning.
  • Alternative TNN Priors: Analyzing TNN priors with a wider range of parameters and deriving a full complexity analysis for deep neural approximations of data-driven models are suggested.
  • Parallelization: The approach is amenable to parallelization, which could leverage supercomputing resources for even greater efficiency.
  • Network Architecture Modifications: Adapting the TNN architecture for modern CNNs and LLMs, and exploring optimal balances between network depth and width, are also identified as future research directions.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this article we consider Bayesian inference associated to deep neural networks (DNNs) and in particular, trace-class neural network (TNN) priors which were proposed by Sell et al. [39]. Such priors were developed as more robust alternatives to classical architectures in the context of inference problems. For this work we develop multilevel Monte Carlo (MLMC) methods for such models. MLMC is a popular variance reduction technique, with particular applications in Bayesian statistics and uncertainty quantification. We show how a particular advanced MLMC method that was introduced in [4] can be applied to Bayesian inference from DNNs and establish mathematically, that the computational cost to achieve a particular mean square error, associated to posterior expectation computation, can be reduced by several orders, versus more conventional techniques. To verify such results we provide numerous numerical experiments on model problems arising in machine learning. These include Bayesian regression, as well as Bayesian classification and reinforcement learning.
BibTeX
@misc{chada2022multilevel,
  author = {Neil K. Chada and Ajay Jasra and Kody J. H. Law and Sumeetpal S. Singh},
  title = {{Multilevel Bayesian Deep Neural Networks}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2203.12961},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2203.12961},
}
Figure