Multiframe denoising of high-speed optical coherence tomography data using interframe and intraframe priors

Liheng Bian, Jinli Suo, Feng Chen, Qionghai Dai

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel multi-frame denoising method for high-speed Optical Coherence Tomography (OCT) data. By leveraging both the low-rank property of temporally aligned OCT frames and the sparsity of image gradients within each frame, their approach effectively suppresses speckle noise while preserving crucial details, outperforming existing methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Optical Coherence Tomography (OCT) is a powerful, non-invasive imaging technique that provides cross-sectional views of biological tissues. However, high-speed OCT systems, crucial for capturing dynamic biological processes, suffer from significant speckle noise. This noise degrades image quality, making it difficult to discern fine structures and potentially hindering accurate diagnosis. Existing denoising methods often struggle to balance effective noise reduction with the preservation of important anatomical details.

Methods

The core of this work lies in a multi-frame optimization framework that exploits two key priors:

  • Inter-frame Prior (Low-Rank): Temporally registered OCT frames from a volume are assumed to exhibit redundancy. The authors model the latent sharp OCT volume as a low-rank matrix. This is achieved by minimizing the nuclear norm of the registered OCT data, effectively capturing the shared information across frames.
  • Intra-frame Prior (Gradient Sparsity): Within each individual OCT frame, the authors assume that the image gradients are sparse, similar to natural images. This is enforced by minimizing the L1 norm of the image gradients.

These priors are incorporated into an optimization model that also accounts for the logarithmic image formation and a non-uniform noise variance. To solve this potentially non-convex model, the authors employ a convex optimization algorithm based on the Augmented Lagrangian Method (ALM). This involves several convexification steps, including replacing the L0 norm with the L1 norm for gradient sparsity and introducing auxiliary variables to simplify the optimization.

Datasets

The authors evaluated their method on two datasets:

  • Pigeye OCT dataset: This dataset was acquired using a Spectralis HRA & OCT system in high-speed mode. It consists of 455 registered frames, with 13 frames per set from 35 different positions.
  • Human retinal OCT images: This dataset was acquired using a Bioptigen Inc. SDOCT imaging system, featuring ~4.5µm axial resolution and 500 A-scans per B-scan.

The benchmark image for comparison was generated by averaging all registered frames for the pigeye dataset, as a truly noise-free ground truth was not available due to the high acquisition speed.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Leveraging Multi-frame Redundancy: The paper highlights that the inherent redundancy across multiple frames in high-speed OCT is a valuable resource for denoising, going beyond single-frame approaches.
  • Combined Priors for Robustness: The synergistic use of both inter-frame (low-rank) and intra-frame (gradient sparsity) priors is crucial. The low-rank prior captures temporal consistency, while gradient sparsity preserves fine structural details within each frame.
  • Convex Optimization for Tractability: Transforming a potentially non-convex problem into a convex one using techniques like L1 norm regularization and then solving it with ALM is a key algorithmic contribution, ensuring convergence and efficiency.
  • Non-uniform Noise Modeling: Explicitly modeling non-uniform noise variance is important because speckle noise in OCT is not constant across the image, and this leads to more accurate denoising.

Key Results

  • Significant Noise Reduction: The proposed method effectively reduces speckle noise, as evidenced by substantial improvements in PSNR and SSIM. For the pigeye data, PSNR increased from 17.19dB to 31.74dB, and SSIM improved from 0.12 to 0.91.
  • Crucial Detail Preservation: Unlike some methods that blur details, this approach preserves important anatomical features, such as layer boundaries in retinal OCT images, which is vital for diagnosis.
  • Competitive Efficiency: The method achieves denoising in approximately 36 seconds per frame, making it comparable in efficiency to other fast approaches.
  • Superior Performance: Quantitative comparisons showed that the proposed method outperformed anisotropic diffusion, Bayesian, and NSC methods, and was competitive with, or superior to, the multi-frame wavelet method, particularly in textured regions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Registration Accuracy Dependence: The performance of the method is sensitive to the accuracy of frame registration. Misaligned frames can degrade the effectiveness of the low-rank prior. The authors acknowledge this as a challenge for multi-frame methods in general and suggest exploring noise-robust matching techniques.
  • Frame Rate Trade-off: A larger number of frames generally leads to better denoising due to enhanced low-rank prior exploitation. However, this comes at the cost of increased acquisition time and potential motion artifacts. Future work might involve finding an optimal balance for practical applications.
  • Anisotropic Intra-frame Prior: The current intra-frame prior (anisotropic total variation) penalizes diagonal gradients more than horizontal/vertical ones. This might introduce artifacts. Future extensions could explore an isotropic intra-frame prior.

Summary updated

Abstract

Optical coherence tomography (OCT) is an important interferometric diagnostic technique, which provides cross-sectional views of biological tissues' subsurface microstructures. However, the imaging quality of high-speed OCT is limited by the large speckle noise. To address this problem, we propose a multiframe algorithmic method to denoise OCT volume. Mathematically, we build an optimization model which forces the temporally registered frames to be low-rank and the gradient in each frame to be sparse, under the constraints from logarithmic image formation and nonuniform noise variance. In addition, a convex optimization algorithm based on the augmented Lagrangian method is derived to solve the above model. The results reveal that our approach outperforms the other methods in terms of both speckle noise suppression and crucial detail preservation.
BibTeX
@article{bian2015multiframe,
  author = {Liheng Bian and Jinli Suo and Feng Chen and Qionghai Dai},
  title = {{Multiframe denoising of high-speed optical coherence tomography data using interframe and intraframe priors}},
  journal = {Journal of Biomedical Optics},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1117/1.jbo.20.3.036006},
}
Figure