Multi-step planning with learned effects of (possibly partial) action executions

Utku Bozdogan, Emre Ugur

Abstract

Traditional robotic affordance models often treat actions as discrete units, predicting only the final state of an object after a full movement. This approach limits a robot's ability to perform high-precision tasks that require fine-grained control. This paper introduces a novel affordance model based on Conditional Neural Processes (CNPs) that learns the continuous motion trajectories of objects. By representing effects as full paths rather than single points, the system enables "partial action" execution—stopping a movement at the exact moment a sub-goal is reached. Experimental results in simulation demonstrate that this approach significantly reduces compounding errors and achieves sub-centimeter precision in multi-step planning tasks.

Introduction

In the field of robotics, the concept of "affordances" describes the relationship between an agent, an object, and the potential effects of an action. For example, a robot identifies that a ball is "pushable" or a handle is "pullable." While these models have successfully enabled robots to interact with their environments, they typically operate on a discrete level: an action is executed in its entirety, and the resulting state is observed.

However, the physical world is continuous. If a robot's model only understands the outcome of a standard 5cm push, it cannot intuitively determine how to move an object exactly 2cm to align it with a target. Furthermore, multi-step planning often relies on Recurrent Neural Networks (RNNs) or LSTMs, which are prone to "compounding errors"—where a minor prediction error in the first step of a sequence leads to a catastrophic failure by the final step. This research addresses these limitations by proposing a framework that learns continuous trajectories and allows for flexible, partial action execution.

Methodology

Conditional Neural Processes (CNPs) for Affordances

The core of the proposed framework is the use of Conditional Neural Processes. Unlike standard feed-forward networks, CNPs can be conditioned on a small set of observation points to predict an entire underlying function. In this context, the function represents the trajectory of an object over time.

The architecture consists of three primary components:

  1. Encoders: Separate modules process depth images (object geometry), the intended action, and the observed effect.
  2. Latent Representation: These inputs are fused into a single latent representation ($r$) that captures the underlying physics of the interaction.
  3. Bidirectional Prediction: The shared latent space allows the model to perform both forward prediction (predicting the effect of a given action) and inverse prediction (determining the necessary action to achieve a desired effect).

Partial Action Planning

Because the model predicts the entire trajectory of an object's movement rather than just the endpoint, the planner can treat a single action as a continuous spectrum of possibilities. The robot can choose to "cut the action short" at any time step ($t$) where the object’s predicted position matches a desired sub-goal. This effectively provides the robot with an infinite library of actions derived from a single learned primitive.

Continuous Adaptive Planning

To move beyond the constraints of traditional A* search—which typically selects from a pre-defined list of discrete angles and distances—the authors implemented a continuous planning method. This approach uses gradient descent on the latent space to optimize the direction and duration of a push, allowing for much finer adjustments during multi-step tasks.

Experimental Setup

The model was evaluated using two distinct datasets:

  • Lever-up Dataset: A benchmark involving objects with varying geometric shapes (3 to 8 edges) being levered from different contact points.
  • CoppeliaSim Simulation: A custom environment featuring a UR10 robot arm. The researchers collected 500 trajectories for pushing and 100 for grasping across various shapes, including cuboids, spheres, and cylinders. Vision was provided via depth images from a simulated Kinect sensor.

Key Insights and Results

Accuracy and Robustness

The CNP-based model demonstrated superior predictive accuracy compared to traditional sequence models. In the lever-up task, the CNP model achieved a prediction error of only 0.3–0.4 cm, while the LSTM baseline suffered from an error of 0.9–1.0 cm. By avoiding the recurrent feedback loop of LSTMs, the CNP model prevented the accumulation of errors over long planning horizons.

Precision in Multi-Step Tasks

The inclusion of partial actions and continuous planning led to a significant leap in precision. When tasked with reaching specific goal positions, the robot achieved an average error of just 0.002m (2mm). In contrast, traditional A* planning using discrete steps resulted in errors between 0.013m and 0.020m.

Generalization and Object Dynamics

The model's object-centric definition of actions—defining movements relative to the object's initial orientation—allowed it to generalize across different shapes. Notably, the system learned to distinguish between "rollable" objects (spheres) and "non-rollable" objects (cubes), adapting its pushing strategy to prevent spheres from rolling uncontrollably after the gripper stopped.

Conclusion and Future Work

By learning the continuous effects of actions, this research provides a pathway for robots to achieve human-like precision in manipulation tasks. The ability to execute partial actions transforms simple primitives into versatile tools for complex, multi-step planning.

Future work will focus on bridging the "sim-to-real" gap by validating these models on physical hardware, where unpredictable friction and sensor noise present additional challenges. Additionally, the authors suggest that incorporating attention mechanisms could improve the model's ability to focus on critical object features during more complex manipulations, such as grasping and multi-object interaction.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{bozdogan2024multi,
  author = {Utku Bozdogan and Emre Ugur},
  title = {{Multi-step planning with learned effects of (possibly partial) action executions}},
  journal = {Adv. Robotics},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1080/01691864.2024.2336251},
}
Figure