Multi-Segment Reconstruction Using Invariant Features

Mona Zehni, N. Minh, Zhizhen Zhao

Abstract

The Multi-Segment Reconstruction (MSR) problem involves recovering a signal from noisy segments with unknown observation window positions. This challenge, common in DNA sequence assembly and cryo-electron microscopy, is typically approached through computationally intensive pairwise matching. We propose a novel method using shift-invariant features to simultaneously estimate the underlying signal and the distribution of segment positions. By formulating the problem as a constrained nonlinear least-squares task, we bypass explicit alignment. Empirical results show that for sufficiently long segments, random initialization leads to exact recovery. Our approach demonstrates superior noise robustness and computational efficiency compared to standard Expectation Maximization (EM) techniques.

The Multi-Segment Reconstruction Problem

The core challenge of MSR is the lack of alignment information. In many scientific domains, such as genomics or molecular imaging, data arrives as short, noisy snippets of a larger structure. Unlike Multi-Reference Alignment (MRA), where the entire shifted signal is observed, MSR provides only partial windows.

Illustration of the MSR problem: a signal and three noisy, randomly positioned segments.

Traditional solutions rely on finding overlaps between these snippets. However, as noise levels increase, these pairwise matches become unreliable, and the combinatorial complexity of aligning thousands of reads becomes prohibitive.

Methodology: Reconstruction via Invariant Features

To avoid the alignment bottleneck, we utilize statistical features that are invariant to shifts.

Higher-Order Correlations

We focus on the first, second, and third-order correlations of the observed segments. These features—analogous to the mean, power spectrum, and bispectrum—remain constant regardless of where a segment starts within the signal. The third-order correlations are particularly critical, as they capture phase information lost in the power spectrum, allowing for more accurate signal reconstruction from shorter fragments.

Optimization Framework

Reconstruction is formulated as a constrained nonlinear least-squares problem. We seek a signal $x$ and a probability distribution $p$ (representing the likelihood of segment starting positions) that minimize the discrepancy between the observed features and those predicted by the model. Given the non-convex nature of this landscape, we employ second-order optimization methods, specifically Trust-Region and Sequential Quadratic Programming (SQP) solvers.

Experimental Evaluation

We tested our method using simulated datasets consisting of randomly generated signals and position distributions. Observations were contaminated with Additive White Gaussian Noise (AWGN) at various Signal-to-Noise Ratios (SNR). Typically, $10^5$ noisy observations were used to estimate the invariant features.

Results and Discussion

Phase Transitions in Signal Recovery

A key finding is the existence of a "phase transition" in recovery performance. For a signal of length $d$, there is a minimum segment length $m$ required for unique recovery. Below this threshold, the problem is underdetermined.

Empirical probability of exact recovery as a function of signal length d and segment length m.

As shown in the figure above, once the segment length $m$ exceeds a certain boundary relative to $d$, the probability of exact recovery from random initialization dramatically increases to 100%. This suggests that for sufficiently long segments, the optimization landscape becomes more favorable, reducing sensitivity to initialization.

Efficiency and Robustness

Our method scales linearly with the number of samples, making it significantly faster than Expectation Maximization (EM). Furthermore, while EM's performance degrades sharply under high noise, the invariant feature approach remains stable. This robustness makes it an ideal candidate for providing a "warm start" to more computationally intensive refinement algorithms.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While the invariant feature approach offers a powerful alternative to alignment-based methods, challenges remain. The non-convexity of the optimization problem means that global convergence is not theoretically guaranteed for all starting points, although empirical results are promising. Future work will focus on scaling these higher-order correlations to the massive sequences found in real-world DNA assembly and extending the framework to handle variable-length segments.

Summary updated

Abstract

Multi-segment reconstruction (MSR) problem consists of recovering a signal from noisy segments with unknown positions of the observation windows. One example arises in DNA sequence assembly, which is typically solved by matching short reads to form longer sequences. Instead of trying to locate the segment within the sequence through pair-wise matching, we propose a new approach that uses shift-invariant features to estimate both the underlying signal and the distribution of the positions of the segments. Using the invariant features, we formulate the problem as a constrained nonlinear least-squares. The non-convexity of the problem leads to its sensitivity to the initialization. However, with clean data, we show empirically that for longer segment lengths, random initialization achieves exact recovery. Furthermore, we compare the performance of our approach to the results of expectation maximization and demonstrate that the new approach is robust to noise and computationally more efficient.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zehni2018multi,
  author = {Mona Zehni and N. Minh and Zhizhen Zhao},
  title = {{Multi-Segment Reconstruction Using Invariant Features}},
  booktitle = {IEEE International Conference on Acoustics, Speech and Signal Processing},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1109/icassp.2018.8461796},
}
Figure