Multi-Field Interference Simultaneously Imaging on Single Image for Dynamic Surface Measurement

Wei‐Qiang Han, Xiaodong Gao, Zhen Chen, Le Bai, Bo Liu, Rujin ZhaoSensors 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "Multi-Field Interference" (MFI) imaging technique that captures three distinct interference patterns simultaneously on a single image. This overcomes the limitations of traditional methods that capture only one pattern at a time, enabling more efficient and accurate dynamic surface measurements of high-frequency vibrating mirrors (VMs).

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

High-frequency vibrating mirrors (VMs) are crucial components in systems like infrared target detection, where their dynamic surface shape directly impacts imaging quality. Deformations caused by vibration can lead to wavefront aberrations, degrading the performance of optical systems. Accurately measuring these dynamic surface shapes in real-time, at optical-level precision, is essential for compensating these defects. Existing non-contact methods, particularly interferometric ones, often struggle with dynamic measurements. Traditional methods either require scanning mechanisms (too slow for dynamic surfaces) or capture only one interference pattern per image, necessitating multiple frames and potentially leading to temporal mismatches or data loss for fast-moving objects. This paper aims to address this by providing a method to capture multiple interference patterns from a single image, ideal for dynamic surface measurement.

Methods

The core innovation is the "Multi-Field Interference" (MFI) imaging setup. This system utilizes a light wedge (WL) and multiple reflections and refractions to generate three distinct interference patterns (S1, S2, and S3) from a single incident laser pulse.

Here's a breakdown of the key components and principles:

  • Light Path: A laser beam is polarized, expanded, and directed towards a light wedge (WL).
  • Interference Generation: The light interacts with both surfaces of the WL and the vibrating mirror (VM). Multiple reflections and refractions within the WL and off the VM create several beams.
  • Simultaneous Patterns: Specifically, three sets of beams (R3 and R61, R61 and R62, R62 and R63) interfere at the WL's surface B, forming three distinct interference patterns (S1, S2, S3) that are spatially separated.
  • Dynamic Measurement: By adjusting the angle of the VM (a), the separation between these three patterns can be controlled. This allows them to be captured simultaneously on a single camera frame.
  • Crosstalk Avoidance: A critical aspect for dynamic measurements is avoiding crosstalk. The paper highlights that synchronizing the laser repetition frequency (LRF) with the camera's frame rate (e.g., both at 10 Hz) completely eliminates crosstalk, ensuring accurate capture of the dynamic surface.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments utilize a single vibrating mirror for testing and comparison with a commercial interferometer.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Single-Image Multi-Pattern Capture: The most significant insight is the ability to generate and capture three interference patterns from a single laser pulse on one image. This fundamentally changes the paradigm for dynamic surface measurement, moving away from time-series acquisition of single patterns.
  • Spatial Separation for Dynamic Data: The method leverages spatial separation of interference patterns (controlled by the VM's angle) to encode temporal information within a single frame. This is a clever way to overcome the speed limitations of traditional methods.
  • Crosstalk Mitigation: The paper provides a clear solution for crosstalk in dynamic scenarios by matching the laser repetition frequency to the camera frame rate. This is crucial for reliable dynamic measurements.
  • Contrast Control: The authors demonstrate that the contrast of the interference fringes (and thus the quality of the measurement) can be adjusted by controlling parameters like the laser repetition frequency and the optical properties of the light wedge.

Key Results

  • Successful MFI Generation: The experimental setup successfully generated three distinct interference patterns (S1, S2, S3) on a single image.
  • Contrast Improvement: The contrast of the interference patterns (S1, S2, S3) was shown to be significant (often >0.7) at specific laser repetition frequencies (e.g., 100 Hz and 50 Hz). Contrast could be enhanced through post-processing.
  • Crosstalk Avoidance: When the laser repetition frequency matched the camera frame rate (10 Hz), crosstalk was completely avoided, which is vital for dynamic measurements.
  • Comparative Measurement: The MFI method achieved a measured RMS value of 20.3 nm for a tested mirror, which was comparable to a commercial interferometer's result (0.03 λ, equivalent to 18.9 nm for λ=632.8 nm). This validates the accuracy of the proposed method.
  • Dynamic Measurement Capability: The paper emphasizes that the MFI method is suitable for dynamic surface shape measurement of vibrating mirrors, a capability lacking in the compared commercial interferometer.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Contrast Variation: The contrast of the interference patterns varied with the laser repetition frequency, with lower contrast observed at very high or very low frequencies. While enhancement is possible, optimizing the LRF for maximum contrast is important.
  • Optical Component Sensitivity: The method relies on precise alignment and optical properties of components like the light wedge. The paper mentions the need for careful adjustment of the WL and VM.
  • Future Work: The paper implicitly suggests future work in optimizing the optical design for even higher contrast and potentially extending the method to measure even faster dynamic events. The ability to obtain three patterns simultaneously opens avenues for more complex surface analysis and potentially real-time feedback control for vibrating systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

To obtain the dynamic surface of high-frequency vibrating mirrors (VMs), a novel method involving multi-field interference (MFI) pattern imaging on a single image is proposed in this paper. Using multiple reflections and refractions, the proposed method generates three interference patterns at the same time, which improves the traditional time-series methods where a single interference pattern can be obtained at one time. Experimental results show that a series of MFI patterns can be obtained on a single image, with the laser repetition frequency (LRF) ranging from 200 Hz to 10 Hz, and the frame rate of the camera at 10 Hz. Particularly if the LRF (10 Hz) is equal to the frame rate of image, crosstalk is avoided completely, which is particularly desirable in dynamic surface measurement. In summary, the MFI imaging method provides an effective way for VM dynamic surface measurement.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{han2020multi,
  author = {Wei‐Qiang Han and Xiaodong Gao and Zhen Chen and Le Bai and Bo Liu and Rujin Zhao},
  title = {{Multi-Field Interference Simultaneously Imaging on Single Image for Dynamic Surface Measurement}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/s20123372},
}
Figure