Multi-color detection of gravitational arcs: method and new candidates

M. Maturi, Sebastian Mizera, G. Seidel

Abstract

Strong gravitational lensing provides fundamental insights into the distribution of dark matter in massive galaxies and clusters, as well as background cosmology. However, the number of discovered gravitational arcs remains small, creating a need for more complete samples and unbiased selection methods. Existing automatic detection methods often suffer from high false-positive rates, requiring extensive manual inspection. This paper presents a novel method that combines automated shape detection with statistical color properties of gravitational arcs. By targeting the color space associated with source galaxies at redshift $z \approx 1$, where lensing cross-sections peak, the researchers reduced sample contamination by a factor of 6–7. Testing this method on 37 deg² of the CARS survey led to the discovery of 73 new gravitational arc candidates.

Introduction: The Challenge of Finding Cosmic Magnifiers

Gravitational arcs—distorted, elongated images of distant galaxies formed by the gravitational pull of massive foreground objects—act as natural "cosmic magnifying glasses." They are essential for mapping dark matter and studying the early universe. Despite their value, identifying them in large-scale surveys is a significant bottleneck.

Current automated "arcfinder" programs frequently misidentify edge-on galaxies, spiral arms, or imaging artifacts as arcs. This results in researchers having to manually "eye-ball" thousands of candidates per square degree. As upcoming wide-field surveys like Euclid and KiDS prepare to map thousands of square degrees, this manual approach is becoming unsustainable. This study addresses the need for a high-purity automated pipeline to streamline the discovery process.

Methodology: A Two-Stage Detection Pipeline

The researchers developed a robust pipeline that filters candidates based on both morphology and physical color properties.

1. Image Segmentation

The first stage employs an "arcfinder" algorithm that analyzes the second brightness moments of pixels. It identifies coherent, elongated structures by looking for local brightness patterns that match the expected geometry of a lensed arc.

Example of gravitational arcs in a galaxy cluster (left) and the corresponding segmentation mask (right) produced by the automated arcfinder algorithm.

2. Color-Based Filtering

The core innovation of this work is the application of a color filter. The probability of a galaxy being strongly lensed (the lensing cross-section) is highest when the source is located at a redshift of approximately $z \approx 1$. At this distance, the source population is dominated by star-forming galaxies with distinct, predictable colors.

By plotting candidates on a $(g-r)$ vs $(r-i)$ color-color diagram, the authors identified a specific region where true gravitational arcs are most likely to be found. Since gravitational lensing is achromatic—meaning it does not alter the color of the light—the observed color of the arc is a direct fingerprint of the distant source galaxy. This allows the pipeline to filter out foreground and background "noise" that may look like arcs but lack the correct physical properties.

Data and Performance

The method was tested using the CFHTLS-Archive-Research Survey (CARS), covering 37 square degrees with observations in the $u, g, r, i,$ and $z$ bands. The arcfinder was calibrated using known arcs within the survey area to ensure reliability.

The color selection procedure proved highly effective, reducing the number of candidates from approximately 970 per square degree to just 150—an 85% reduction in the workload for human classifiers. From an initial pool of 7 million objects, the pipeline identified 90 high-quality arc candidates, 73 of which were previously unknown to the astronomical community.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

By leveraging the "redshift sweet spot" and the achromatic nature of lensing, this method provides a scalable solution for the Big Data era of astronomy. While ground-based resolution and light pollution from foreground galaxies remain challenges, the transition to space-based instruments like Euclid will further enhance the purity of these samples. Future developments may involve training machine learning models on these filtered datasets to achieve full automation, eliminating the need for manual validation entirely.

Summary updated

Abstract

Strong gravitational lensing provides fundamental insights in the understanding of the dark matter distribution in massive galaxies, galaxy clusters and the background cosmology. Despite their importance, the number of gravitational arcs discovered so far is small. The urge for more complete, large samples and unbiased methods of selecting candidates is rising. A number of methods for the automatic detection of arcs have been proposed in the literature, but large amounts of spurious detections retrieved by these methods forces observers to visually inspect thousands of candidates per square degree in order to clean the samples. This approach is largely subjective and requires a huge amount of eye-ball checking, especially considering the actual and upcoming wide field surveys, which will cover thousands of square degrees. In this paper we study the statistical properties of colors of gravitational arcs. We found that most of them lie in a relatively small region of the color-color diagram (g 0 r 0 ; r 0 i 0 ). We support this observational evidence by studying lensing cross section, which peaks for sources at redshift z 1, where the source-galaxy population is dominated by galaxies with large star forming regions and hence well defined colors. The use of this distinctive feature, in combination with an automatic arcfinder, reduces sample contamination by a factor of 6 7. We tested the performance of the method against 37 deg 2 of the CARS survey, detecting 73 new arc candidates.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{maturi2014multi,
  author = {M. Maturi and Sebastian Mizera and G. Seidel},
  title = {{Multi-color detection of gravitational arcs: method and new candidates}},
  booktitle = {Astronomy},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1051/0004-6361/201321634},
}
Figure