Multi-agent Confidential Abductive Reasoning

Jiefei Ma, Alessandra Russo, Krysia Broda, Emil Lupu

TL;DR

This paper introduces DAREC2, a novel distributed abductive reasoning system designed for multi-agent systems where agents must collaborate to answer queries while keeping their private knowledge confidential. It extends previous work by providing a formal framework and an efficient protocol that prevents sensitive information from being shared, enabling secure collaborative reasoning in complex distributed environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In multi-agent systems (MAS), agents often possess incomplete knowledge about the world and need to collaborate to answer queries. Traditional collaborative reasoning systems assume agents can freely share all their information. However, in many real-world scenarios, such as healthcare or security policy analysis in distributed networks, agents have private information that cannot be disclosed. This creates a fundamental conflict: the need for collaborative inference versus the requirement for knowledge confidentiality. Existing systems like DAREC, while capable of distributed abductive reasoning, do not address this confidentiality concern, forcing agents to reveal potentially sensitive data during the reasoning process. This paper tackles this challenge by developing a system that allows agents to reason together and derive consistent answers without compromising their private knowledge.

Methods

The core of the paper is the DAREC2 system, which extends the previous DAREC framework. Key methodological contributions include:

  • Confidential Abductive Framework: A formal language and framework are introduced to explicitly model private and public agent knowledge. "Askable atoms" (e.g., p(u)@ID) are used to represent knowledge that can be queried from a specific agent (ID), allowing for controlled sharing.
  • Distributed Abductive Algorithm: DAREC2 employs a coordinated state-rewriting process. This involves:
  • Local Abduction: Each agent performs goal-directed reasoning using its own knowledge. During this process, it identifies sub-goals solvable only by other agents and constraints that must be globally satisfied.
  • Confidentiality Preservation: Crucially, private information is not included in the "token state" that is passed between agents. This is achieved through safe goal selection strategies that prevent private non-abducible literals from appearing in transitional states.
  • Coordination Protocol: A token-based synchronized backtracking strategy is used for agent interaction. This protocol manages the flow of transitional states between agents, allowing for concurrent computation while ensuring that agents only process states they can contribute to without revealing private data. It also handles backtracking efficiently.
  • Constraint Handling: The system leverages external Constraint Logic Programming (CLP) solvers to handle arithmetic constraints and reasoning over unbounded domains, which is essential for complex policy analysis.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper describes a case study on security policy analysis and mentions the generation of policy rules and action effect rules for benchmarking, but does not refer to specific, pre-existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Confidentiality as a First-Class Constraint: The paper demonstrates that confidentiality in collaborative reasoning isn't just an add-on but a fundamental requirement that necessitates specific architectural and algorithmic design choices.
  • "Askable Atoms" for Controlled Sharing: The introduction of p(u)@ID syntax provides a clean mechanism to specify which agent can provide information for a particular query, enabling fine-grained control over information disclosure.
  • Token-Based Synchronized Backtracking: This coordination strategy is a clever way to balance concurrency and backtracking in a distributed setting, preventing communication overload while maintaining correctness and enabling agents to work on different parts of the problem simultaneously.
  • Separation of Private and Public Reasoning: The system's design ensures that private knowledge is processed locally, and only the results of that processing (e.g., constraints, non-private sub-goals) are shared in the transitional state, effectively abstracting away sensitive details.

Key Results

  • Confidentiality Guarantee: The DAREC2 system is designed to preserve the confidentiality of private agent knowledge during collaborative reasoning.
  • Soundness and Completeness: The paper formally proves that DAREC2 is sound and complete with respect to a three-valued semantics for abductive logic programs, meaning it will find correct answers if they exist and will not produce incorrect ones.
  • Performance Improvement: Benchmarking results for distributed policy analysis showed that DAREC2 computations were significantly faster (1.26-6.17 times) than centralized approaches, attributed to concurrent computation during collaborative reasoning. The average ping time between agents was very low (0.015ms).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The current system assumes that private predicates of different agents do not have name clashes, which are assumed to have been resolved beforehand.
  • The system's soundness and completeness are based on a three-valued semantics, which is chosen to handle potential looping in top-down inference. While practical, stronger semantics might be desirable in some contexts.
  • Future Work:
    • More extensive benchmarking to investigate the impact of different safe goal selection strategies, agent selection strategies, and agent interaction strategies.
  • Extending the system to handle private abducible predicates, which would further enhance its expressiveness and applicability.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the context of multi-agent hypothetical reasoning, agents typically have partial knowledge about their environments, and the union of such knowledge is still incomplete to represent the whole world. Thus, given a global query they collaborate with each other to make correct inferences and hypothesis, whilst maintaining global constraints. Most collaborative reasoning systems operate on the assumption that agents can share or communicate any information they have. However, in application domains like multi-agent systems for healthcare or distributed software agents for security policies in coalition networks, confidentiality of knowledge is an additional primary concern. These agents are required to collaborately compute consistent answers for a query whilst preserving their own private information. This paper addresses this issue showing how this dichotomy between "open communication" in collaborative reasoning and protection of confidentiality can be accommodated. We present a general-purpose distributed abductive logic programming system for multi-agent hypothetical reasoning with confidentiality. Specifically, the system computes consistent conditional answers for a query over a set of distributed normal logic programs with possibly unbound domains and arithmetic constraints, preserving the private information within the logic programs. A case study on security policy analysis in distributed coalition networks is described, as an example of many applications of this system.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ma2011multi,
  author = {Jiefei Ma and Alessandra Russo and Krysia Broda and Emil Lupu},
  title = {{Multi-agent Confidential Abductive Reasoning}},
  booktitle = {Iclp (technical Communications)},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.4230/lipics.iclp.2011.175},
}
Figure