Motor Imagery Enhances Performance Beyond the Imagined Action

Magdalena Gippert, Pei-Cheng Shih, Tobias Heed, Ian S. Howard, Mina Jamshidi Idaji, Arno Villringer, Bernhard Sehm, Vadim V. Nikulin

Abstract Motor imagery is frequently utilized to improve the performance of specific target movements in sports and rehabilitation. In this study, we show that motor imagery can facilitate learning of not only the imagined target movements but also sequentially linked overt movements. Hybrid sequences comprising imagined and physically executed segments allowed participants to learn specific movement characteristics of the executed segments when they were consistently associated with specific imagined segments. Electrophysiological recordings revealed that the degree of event-related synchronization in the alpha and beta bands during a basic motor imagery task was correlated with imagery-evoked motor learning. Thus, both behavioral and neural evidence indicate that motor imagery’s benefits extend beyond the imagined movements, improving performance in linked overt movements. This provides new evidence for the functional equivalence of imagined and overt movements and suggests new applications for imagery in sports and rehabilitation.

Introduction

Motor imagery (MI)—the mental simulation of movement—is a staple in sports training and physical rehabilitation. Traditionally, research has focused on the "specificity of imagery," or the idea that imagining a specific action improves that exact action. However, human movement is rarely isolated; it consists of complex, linked sequences. This study investigates whether an imagined movement can act as a contextual "anchor" for a subsequent physical one, facilitating motor adaptation to new environmental dynamics.

Methods and Experimental Design

The researchers investigated motor adaptation—the process by which the brain adjusts to external forces—using a Kinarm Exoskeleton to track 2D arm movements and 60-channel EEG to record neural activity.

Experimental setup showing the Kinarm exoskeleton and EEG recording during the reaching task.

Participants were divided into three experimental groups to test the "functional equivalence" of mental and physical actions:

  1. Active Group: Performed two physical reaches (Cue → Middle → Final).
  2. Motor Imagery (MI) Group: Imagined the first reach (Cue → Middle) and physically executed the second (Middle → Final).
  3. Control Group: Performed only the final physical reach.
The three experimental conditions: Control, Active, and Motor Imagery, illustrating the lead-in movements.

During the final reach, a "curl force field" (a robotic push) was applied. The direction of this push was tied to the location of the starting cue. To adapt successfully, the brain had to associate the lead-in (whether imagined or physical) with the specific force direction. Additionally, a separate baseline task (imagined fist clenching) was used to measure individual neural responses to imagery in the alpha (8–13 Hz) and beta (14–25 Hz) bands.

Key Insights

The Hybrid Sequence

The study revealed that the brain can "chunk" an imagined movement and a physical movement into a single, holistic unit. The MI group demonstrated faster "dwell times" at the transition point than the control group, suggesting they were executing a pre-planned hybrid sequence rather than two separate tasks.

Functional Equivalence and the Imagery Gap

While the MI group successfully adapted to the force fields, their performance was not as robust as the Active group. This suggests that while imagery is functionally equivalent to execution, it may recruit deeper layers of the motor cortex less effectively, leading to weaker motor learning.

Neural Proficiency as a Predictor

Event-Related Synchronization (ERS)—the "rebound" of alpha and beta waves following imagery—served as a powerful predictor of learning. Participants with stronger ERS during the simple fist-clench task were significantly better at adapting to the complex force-field task. Interestingly, subjective ratings of imagery "vividness" did not correlate with performance, highlighting the importance of objective neural markers.

Key Results

  • Adaptation Success: The MI group significantly reduced reaching error over 50 blocks ($p = 6.5e-07$), performing markedly better than the control group ($p = 1.3e-06$).
  • Internal Model Formation: When the force field was unexpectedly removed, the MI group showed clear "after-effects," proving they had learned a predictive internal model of the force.
  • Neural Correlation: A high correlation ($r = -0.891$) was found between specific alpha/beta power changes and the degree of error reduction.

Discussion and Future Directions

Despite its benefits, imagery-induced learning remains less effective than physical practice. Future research might explore "closed-loop" systems providing real-time EEG feedback to bridge this gap. Furthermore, this "hybrid sequence" approach holds significant promise for clinical rehabilitation, where patients might imagine fine motor tasks (like grasping) to rebuild neural pathways while performing gross motor movements they can still physically execute.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Motor imagery is frequently utilized to improve the performance of specific target movements in sports and rehabilitation. In this study, we show that motor imagery can facilitate learning of not only the imagined target movements but also sequentially linked overt movements. Hybrid sequences comprising imagined and physically executed segments allowed participants to learn specific movement characteristics of the executed segments when they were consistently associated with specific imagined segments. Electrophysiological recordings revealed that the degree of event-related synchronization in the alpha and beta bands during a basic motor imagery task was correlated with imagery-evoked motor learning. Thus, both behavioral and neural evidence indicate that motor imagery’s benefits extend beyond the imagined movements, improving performance in linked overt movements. This provides new evidence for the functional equivalence of imagined and overt movements and suggests new applications for imagery in sports and rehabilitation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gippert2025motor,
  author = {Magdalena Gippert and Pei-Cheng Shih and Tobias Heed and Ian S. Howard and Mina Jamshidi Idaji and Arno Villringer and Bernhard Sehm and Vadim V. Nikulin},
  title = {{Motor Imagery Enhances Performance Beyond the Imagined Action}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.2423642122},
}
Figure