Motivation for family vacations with young children: anecdotes from the Internet

Mimi Li, Dan Wang, Wenqing Xu, Zhenxing MaoJournal of Travel & Tourism Marketing 2017 · DOI

Abstract

Family travel receives growing attention from both the travel industry and academia, but they ignore a vital segment of the family holiday: nuclear families that travel with young children. This study investigated the motivations that drive this market segment to take vacations as a starting point to understand the travel behavior of family tourists, especially those with young and dependent children. By employing netnography, this study collected and analyzed 97 travel diaries from five travel blogs and one travel forum in 2015. Five motivation themes emerged, namely they are spending quality time with children, creating pleasant memories, learning and development, compensation for children, and self-compensation. Both theoretical and practical implications are discussed and future research is suggested.

Introduction

While the travel industry frequently targets "families," it often overlooks the specific psychological drivers of parents traveling with toddlers and infants. Most tourism research focuses on "logical" children—those old enough to express opinions and influence destination choices. However, there is a significant gap in understanding the "nuclear family with young children" (ages 0–4). At this developmental stage, which Piaget classifies as the sensory-motor and preoperational phases, children cannot manipulate information logically. Yet, their presence fundamentally alters travel patterns, shifting activities from high-adrenaline adventures to child-centric leisure. This study seeks to understand the underlying motivations that drive parents to undertake the often-exhausting task of traveling with very young children, especially when faced with social criticism that the child "won't even remember the trip."

Methodology

The researchers employed netnography, a qualitative research method designed to study the behavior of individuals in online communities. The study used a "covert" approach, acting as passive observers of existing online content without interacting with the creators. Data analysis followed an inductive coding method (Glaser & Strauss), involving open coding to identify categories, axial coding to group concepts, and selective coding to finalize abstract thematic patterns. Analysis was facilitated by NVivo 10 software to ensure systematic data management.

Data Sources

The study analyzed a total of 97 travel diaries contributed by 46 authors (41 mothers and 5 fathers) collected between November 2014 and February 2015. Data was sourced from Mafengwo, a major Chinese travel user-generated content (UGC) site (50 posts), and five international travel blogs (47 posts). The children involved ranged from 2 months to 4 years old.

Profiles of international travel bloggers (Part 1)

As shown in the tables above, the international bloggers represented a diverse range of backgrounds, including authors from Canada, the United States, Ireland, and the United Arab Emirates, with professional backgrounds ranging from freelance writers to solicitors.

Key Findings and Motivations

The analysis distilled parental motivation into five core dimensions:

  1. Spending Quality Time: Vacations serve as a "bonding" mechanism to escape the pressures of daily work and focus entirely on the family unit.
  2. Creating Pleasant Memories: Parents acknowledge the child might forget the trip, but they value their own ability to recall these moments through photos and shared experiences.
  3. Learning and Development: Travel is viewed as a "foundation" for environmental awareness and cultural respect, with parents reporting "proud-parent moments" when children adapt to new environments.
  4. Self-compensation: Parents often use travel to fulfill childhood dreams they never realized with their own parents, healing "regretful childhood memories."
  5. Compensation for Children: Organizing trips to alleviate "parental guilt" caused by work-related absences or previous trips taken without the child.

Cultural Nuances and the "Naysayer" Narrative

A recurring theme was parents traveling in defiance of social pressure. Relatives often criticized these trips as "useless," but parents viewed the struggle as a necessary evolution in parenting. Additionally, a distinct cultural difference emerged: Chinese families were significantly more likely to travel with extended family (specifically grandmothers) to assist with childcare, allowing parents some personal "adventure time."

Conclusion and Future Directions

Despite the "sacrifice" of personal leisure, parents perceived a high "return on investment" in the form of family cohesion and child adaptability. However, the study acknowledges limitations, such as the potentially performative nature of public blog posts and selection bias toward highly motivated, tech-savvy parents. Future research could benefit from mixed methods, combining netnography with face-to-face interviews to further explore the daily care aspects of holidays with young children.

Summary updated

Abstract

Family travel receives growing attention from both the travel industry and academia, but they ignore a vital segment of the family holiday: nuclear families that travel with young children. This study investigated the motivations that drive this market segment to take vacations as a starting point to understand the travel behavior of family tourists, especially those with young and dependent children. By employing netnography, this study collected and analyzed 97 travel diaries from five travel blogs and one travel forum in 2015. Five motivation themes emerged, namely they are spending quality time with children, creating pleasant memories, learning and development, compensation for children, and self-compensation. Both theoretical and practical implications are discussed and future research is suggested.
BibTeX
@article{li2017motivation,
  author = {Mimi Li and Dan Wang and Wenqing Xu and Zhenxing Mao},
  title = {{Motivation for family vacations with young children: anecdotes from the Internet}},
  journal = {Journal of Travel \& Tourism Marketing},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1080/10548408.2016.1276007},
}
Figure