Morphometric and Functional Brain Connectivity Differentiates Chess Masters From Amateur Players

Harish RaviPrakash, Syed Muhammad Anwar, Nadia Biassou, Ulaş Bağcı

Abstract

A common task in brain image analysis includes diagnosis of a certain medical condition wherein groups of healthy controls and diseased subjects are analyzed and compared. On the other hand, for two groups of healthy participants with different proficiency in a certain skill, a distinctive analysis of the brain function remains a challenging problem. In this study, we develop new computational tools to explore the functional and anatomical differences that could exist between the brain of healthy individuals identified on the basis of different levels of task experience/proficiency. Toward this end, we look at a dataset of amateur and professional chess players, where we utilize resting-state functional magnetic resonance images to generate functional connectivity (FC) information. In addition, we utilize T1-weighted magnetic resonance imaging to estimate morphometric connectivity (MC) information. We combine functional and anatomical features into a new connectivity matrix, which we term as the functional morphometric similarity connectome (FMSC). Since, both the FC and MC information is susceptible to redundancy, the size of this information is reduced using statistical feature selection. We employ off-the-shelf machine learning classifier, support vector machine, for both single- and multi-modality classifications. From our experiments, we establish that the saliency and ventral attention network of the brain is functionally and anatomically different between two groups of healthy subjects (chess players). We argue that, since chess involves many aspects of higher order cognition such as systematic thinking and spatial reasoning and the identified network is task-positive to cognition tasks requiring a response, our results are valid and supporting the feasibility of the proposed computational pipeline. Moreover, we quantitatively validate an existing neuroscience hypothesis that learning a certain skill could cause a change in the brain (functional connectivity and anatomy) and this can be tested via our novel FMSC algorithm.

Introduction

Identifying subtle neurobiological differences between healthy individuals with varying skill levels—such as chess masters versus amateurs—is a significant challenge in neuroimaging. While clinical studies often compare "binary" states (healthy vs. diseased), the impact of long-term expertise on brain structure and function is often non-linear and complex. This research introduces a novel framework to distinguish expertise by fusing anatomical structure with functional activity into a "Functional Morphometric Similarity Connectome" (FMSC).

Methods

The researchers developed a computational pipeline that integrates two primary modalities of brain data:

  1. Morphometric Similarity Network (MSN): Using T1-weighted MRI, eight anatomical features—including surface area (SA), gray matter volume (GM), and cortical thickness (CT)—were extracted across 34 brain regions. A similarity matrix was then constructed to represent the anatomical relationships between these regions.
  2. Functional Connectivity Network (FCN): Resting-state fMRI (rs-fMRI) was used to measure the correlation of blood-oxygen-level-dependent (BOLD) signals, identifying functional communication patterns between brain areas at rest.
  3. FMSC Fusion: The core innovation involves combining graph-theory metrics (node degree and strength) from functional data with anatomical features into a high-dimensional feature vector.
Overview of the Morphometric Similarity Network (MSN) construction process, extracting eight anatomical features from brain regions to form a similarity matrix.

Statistical feature selection ($t$-tests) was applied to reduce redundancy before training a Support Vector Machine (SVM) classifier using 10-fold cross-validation.

Results and Key Insights

The study utilized data from 47 participants (24 professional chess masters and 23 amateurs) from the International Neuroimaging Data-sharing Initiative (INDI).

Multimodal Superiority

The FMSC model achieved an impressive 88% classification accuracy, significantly outperforming models based solely on functional data (76%) or anatomical data (73%). This suggests that expertise is best characterized by the interplay between brain structure and function rather than either in isolation.

A representative connectivity matrix illustrating the complex relationships between brain regions identified in the study.

The Saliency Network and Attention

The Saliency and Ventral Attention (SVA) network emerged as a primary differentiator. The SVA acts as a "switch" between internal wandering thought (Default Mode Network) and task-focused thought (Central Executive Network). The results suggest that chess masters possess a more refined switching mechanism. Additionally, atypical connections were found in the Dorsal Attention Network (DAN), which is active during visuo-spatial tasks—a biological validation of the spatial demands of high-level chess.

Discussion and Limitations

The findings quantitatively validate the hypothesis that intensive skill acquisition leads to measurable changes in both brain anatomy and functional connectivity. However, the study faces limitations including a small sample size (N=47) and the need to better account for gender as a biological covariate. Future research may incorporate Diffusion Tensor Imaging (DTI) to examine white matter tracts and leverage deep learning as larger datasets become available.

Summary updated

Abstract

A common task in brain image analysis includes diagnosis of a certain medical condition wherein groups of healthy controls and diseased subjects are analyzed and compared. On the other hand, for two groups of healthy participants with different proficiency in a certain skill, a distinctive analysis of the brain function remains a challenging problem. In this study, we develop new computational tools to explore the functional and anatomical differences that could exist between the brain of healthy individuals identified on the basis of different levels of task experience/proficiency. Toward this end, we look at a dataset of amateur and professional chess players, where we utilize resting-state functional magnetic resonance images to generate functional connectivity (FC) information. In addition, we utilize T1-weighted magnetic resonance imaging to estimate morphometric connectivity (MC) information. We combine functional and anatomical features into a new connectivity matrix, which we term as the <i>functional morphometric similarity connectome (FMSC)</i>. Since, both the FC and MC information is susceptible to redundancy, the size of this information is reduced using statistical feature selection. We employ off-the-shelf machine learning classifier, support vector machine, for both single- and multi-modality classifications. From our experiments, we establish that the saliency and ventral attention network of the brain is functionally and anatomically different between two groups of healthy subjects (chess players). We argue that, since chess involves many aspects of higher order cognition such as systematic thinking and spatial reasoning and the identified network is task-positive to cognition tasks requiring a response, our results are valid and supporting the feasibility of the proposed computational pipeline. Moreover, we quantitatively validate an existing neuroscience hypothesis that learning a certain skill could cause a change in the brain (functional connectivity and anatomy) and this can be tested via our novel FMSC algorithm.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{raviprakash2021morphometric,
  author = {Harish RaviPrakash and Syed Muhammad Anwar and Nadia Biassou and Ulaş Bağcı},
  title = {{Morphometric and Functional Brain Connectivity Differentiates Chess Masters From Amateur Players}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Neuroscience},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fnins.2021.629478},
}
Figure