Morphological growth performance and genetic parameters on Korean pine in Northeastern China

David Kombi Kaviriri, Ling Yang, Chunli Zhao, Xiaona Pei, Zuoyi Fan, Jingyuan Wang, Liang Xu, Mulualem Tigabu, Xiangling You, Yuhua Li, Huanzhen Liu, Xiyang ZhaoSilvae 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Korean pine (Pinus koraiensis) is an economically valuable species owing to its excellent timber quality and nuts useful for various purposes. But few studies have been made on growth performance, and aspects combining the genetic gain and classification method on phenotypic similarity in the selection process of superior families. Thus, the present study aimed at analyzing the genetic variation and highlight suitable morphological traits for family selection; establishing trait correlations and families’ ordination based on similarities in phenotypic characters, and selecting elite families and suitable parent trees. Full-sib families from 28 crosses established in randomized complete block design from Naozhi orchard in Northeast China were used, and 11 morphological traits were investigated. Significant differences were observed among families for all traits. The traits coefficients of variation ranged from 6.07 to 56.25 % and from 0.029 to 15.213 % in phenotype and genotypic variation, respectively. A moderate level of inherited genetic control was observed (broad sense heritability $H^2$, varied from 0.155 to 0.438). Traits related to stem growth were highly positively correlated to each other whereas crown traits showed a weak correlation with stem traits (Pearson correlation r, ranged from -0.161 to 0.956). Based on multi-trait comprehensive analysis, we selected six elite families and six parents, which resulted in a genetic gain of 5.6 %, 16.9 %, and 36.4 % in tree height, diameter at breast height, and volume, respectively. These results make a theoretical basis for selecting excellent families and establish orchards of Korean pine from improved seeds.

Introduction

The Korean pine (Pinus koraiensis) is a cornerstone of the timber and nut industries in Northeast China. However, breeding programs for this species often face challenges due to the slow growth cycles characteristic of conifers. While previous research has examined individual growth traits, there has been a significant gap in studies that integrate genetic parameters—such as heritability and combining ability—with phenotypic similarity classification to select superior families.

This study addresses this gap by identifying reliable morphological indicators of superior growth and analyzing trait correlations. The ultimate goal is to establish a robust framework for selecting the best parent trees and offspring to enhance the productivity of future plantations.

Methods and Materials

The research was conducted at a 33-year-old experimental plantation located at the Naozhi Forestry farm. The dataset comprised 834 individual trees from 28 full-sib families, derived from controlled crosses between 11 male and 12 female parent trees.

Researchers evaluated 11 morphological traits, including tree height (Ht), diameter at breast height (DBH), stem straightness (SSD), and wood volume (V). The analysis employed several advanced statistical techniques:

  • Quantitative Genetic Analysis: Phenotypic and genotypic coefficients of variation were calculated, and broad-sense heritability ($H^2$) was estimated to distinguish genetic influence from environmental factors.
  • Combining Ability: General Combining Ability (GCA) and Specific Combining Ability (SCA) were assessed to identify superior parents and optimal breeding pairs.
  • Multivariate Statistics: Principal Component Analysis (PCA) was used to reduce the 11 traits into primary factors, while hierarchical clustering and heatmaps visualized family groupings based on phenotypic resemblance.
  • Selection Index: A comprehensive evaluation value ($Q_i$) was used to rank families based on weighted trait impacts.

Key Insights: Trait Correlations and Genetic Control

A critical finding of the study is the relationship between different growth characteristics. Stem growth traits—such as height, diameter, and volume—exhibited strong positive correlations. In contrast, crown traits (width and height) showed much weaker correlations with stem development. This suggests that breeders can select for high timber volume without necessarily increasing canopy size, which is advantageous for high-density planting strategies.

Correlation matrix of morphological traits

The analysis also revealed that diameter and volume traits account for approximately 57.95% of the population's variation. Consequently, diameter at breast height (DBH) serves as an efficient and easily measurable proxy for overall wood yield. Furthermore, the observed moderate heritability (0.155 to 0.438) underscores that while genetics are a primary driver, site-specific silvicultural practices remain essential for maximizing growth.

Results: Elite Family Selection and Genetic Gains

By integrating genetic parameters with phenotypic clustering, the researchers identified six elite families (PK710, PK24, PK713, PK1014, PK79, and PK310) and six superior parents (Females F9, F10, F13 and Males M11, M12, M14). The clustering analysis effectively grouped these families based on their shared morphological profiles, as shown in the heatmap below.

Heatmap and hierarchical clustering of Korean pine families

The selection of these elite groups promises substantial genetic improvements for the next generation:

  • 5.6% gain in tree height.
  • 16.9% gain in diameter at breast height (DBH).
  • 36.4% gain in total wood volume.

The high coefficient of variation for wood volume (56.25%) highlights the significant potential for improvement through targeted selection.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This study provides a theoretical and practical basis for establishing improved Korean pine seed orchards. However, the researchers note that because the data is site-specific to the Naozhi orchard, these findings should be validated across different geographic regions to account for genotype-by-environment interactions.

Future work should expand the selection criteria to include wood density and nut quality. Additionally, integrating genomic selection using DNA markers could significantly accelerate the breeding process, allowing for the identification of superior genotypes long before they reach physical maturity.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Korean pine ( Pinus koraiensis ) is an economically valuable species owing to its excellent timber quality and nuts useful for various purposes. But few studies have been made on growth performance, and aspects combining the genetic gain and classification method on phenotypic similarity in the selection process of superior families. Thus, the present study aimed at analyzing the genetic variation and highlight suitable morphological traits for family selection; establishing trait correlations and families’ ordination based on similarities in phenotypic characters, and selecting elite families and suitable parent trees. Full-sib families from 28 crosses established in randomized complete block design from Naozhi orchard in Northeast China were used, and 11 morphological traits were investigated. Significant differences were observed among families for all traits. The traits coefficients of variation ranged from 6.07 to 56.25 % and from 0.029 to 15.213 % in phenotype and genotypic variation, respectively. A moderate level of inherited genetic control was observed (broad sense heritability H 2 , varied from 0.155 to 0.438). Traits related to stem growth were highly positively correlated to each other whereas crown traits showed a weak correlation with stem traits (Pearson correlation r, ranged from -0.161 to 0.956). Based on multi-trait comprehensive analysis, we selected six elite families and six parents, which resulted in a genetic gain of 5.6 %, 16.9 %, and 36.4 % in tree height, diameter at breast height, and volume, respectively. These results make a theoretical basis for selecting excellent families and establish orchards of Korean pine from improved seeds.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kaviriri2023morphological,
  author = {David Kombi Kaviriri and Ling Yang and Chunli Zhao and Xiaona Pei and Zuoyi Fan and Jingyuan Wang and Liang Xu and Mulualem Tigabu and Xiangling You and Yuhua Li and Huanzhen Liu and Xiyang Zhao},
  title = {{Morphological growth performance and genetic parameters on Korean pine in Northeastern China}},
  booktitle = {Silvae},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.2478/sg-2023-0004},
}
Figure