Monovalent lanthanide(I) in borozene complexes

Wan‐Lu Li, Teng‐Teng Chen, Weijia Chen, Jun Li, Lai‐Sheng Wang

TL;DR

This paper reports the discovery and characterization of monovalent lanthanide(I) complexes stabilized by a novel "borozene" ligand (B<sub>8</sub><sup>2-</sup>). Using photoelectron spectroscopy and theoretical calculations, the researchers demonstrate a fascinating structural and oxidation state transition from early to late lanthanides, opening new avenues for designing lanthanide compounds with tunable properties.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Lanthanide elements are typically known for their +II and +III oxidation states, with rare examples of +IV and +V. However, monovalent lanthanide (+I) complexes are exceptionally scarce, limiting our understanding and exploration of their chemistry. This scarcity stems from the challenge of stabilizing such low oxidation states. The paper addresses this by investigating the possibility of stabilizing monovalent lanthanides using novel aromatic boron clusters, termed "borozenes," which are analogous to well-known aromatic hydrocarbons like benzene. Specifically, the study focuses on LnB<sub>8</sub><sup>-</sup> clusters, aiming to understand their structures, bonding, and the oxidation states of the lanthanide ions.

Methods

The researchers employed a dual approach combining experimental photoelectron spectroscopy (PES) with theoretical quantum chemistry calculations.

  • Photoelectron Spectroscopy (PES): A home-built magnetic-bottle apparatus was used to generate and probe LnB<sub>8</sub><sup>-</sup> anions. Laser ablation of Ln/<sup>11</sup>B targets created the clusters, which were then mass-selected and subjected to photodetachment using 193 nm and 355 nm lasers. The resulting electron kinetic energies were measured to determine the binding energies of the electronic states.
  • Theoretical Calculations: Density Functional Theory (DFT) methods (PBE, PBE0) were used for global minimum structure searches and to calculate relative energies of different isomers. High-level coupled-cluster calculations (CCSD(T)) were performed for more accurate energy comparisons. To understand the bonding, Adaptive Natural Density Partitioning (AdNDP) and Energy Decomposition Analysis (EDA) were utilized. Photoelectron spectra were simulated using time-dependent DFT (TDDFT) and generalized Koopman's theorem (GKT) to compare with experimental results.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on de novo synthesis and characterization of specific molecular species.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Monovalent Lanthanide(I) Stabilization: The study successfully demonstrates the stabilization of monovalent lanthanide ions (Ln(I)) within borozene complexes. This is a significant achievement, as Ln(I) species are exceptionally rare.
  • Structural and Oxidation State Transition: A remarkable shift in both structure and oxidation state was observed across the lanthanide series. Early lanthanides (La, Pr) form low-symmetry Cs structures with Ln(III), while a low-lying C<sub>7v</sub> isomer with Ln(I) is also present. For late lanthanides (Tb, Tm, Yb), the C<sub>7v</sub> structure with Ln(I) becomes the global minimum.
  • "Borozene" Ligand: The B<sub>8</sub><sup>2-</sup> ligand in the C<sub>7v</sub> complexes is identified as a doubly aromatic species, analogous to benzene and other aromatic hydrocarbons. This "borozene" ligand is crucial for stabilizing the monovalent lanthanide.
  • Tunable Properties: The ability to form lanthanide complexes with variable oxidation states and distinct structural motifs suggests a pathway to engineer compounds with tailored magnetic and chemical properties.
  • Aromaticity in Boron Clusters: The work further solidifies the concept of "borozenes" – aromatic boron clusters analogous to hydrocarbons – and highlights their potential as versatile ligands in inorganic and organometallic chemistry.

Key Results

  • Early Lanthanides (La, Pr): Complicated photoelectron spectra indicated the presence of multiple isomers. Theoretical calculations revealed a dominant low-symmetry Cs structure with Ln(III) and a co-existing, lower-energy C<sub>7v</sub> half-sandwich structure with Ln(I).
  • Late Lanthanides (Tb, Tm, Yb): Simpler photoelectron spectra were observed, consistent with a single dominant, highly symmetric C<sub>7v</sub> half-sandwich structure. Theoretical calculations confirmed this C<sub>7v</sub> structure as the global minimum, featuring a monovalent Ln(I) ion coordinated by the B<sub>8</sub><sup>2-</sup> ligand.
  • Bonding Analysis: AdNDP analysis revealed the B<sub>8</sub><sup>2-</sup> ligand to possess delocalized σ and π bonding, contributing to its aromaticity and ability to stabilize the Ln(I) center. The bonding between Ln(I) and B<sub>8</sub><sup>2-</sup> was characterized as strong and largely ionic for late lanthanides.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Isomer Coexistence: For early lanthanides, the Cs (Ln(III)) and C<sub>7v</sub> (Ln(I)) isomers were found to be close in energy, suggesting that both might be present in experimental samples, complicating spectral interpretation.
  • Magnetic Properties: While the paper hints at interesting magnetic properties due to the electronic configurations of the Ln(I) ions, a detailed investigation of these properties is not presented.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that borozenes with different charge states could serve as ligands to modulate oxidation states in lanthanide complexes. This opens up avenues for designing new lanthanide boride complexes with tunable oxidation states and magnetic properties. Further exploration of other borozene ligands (B<sub>7</sub><sup>3-</sup>, B<sub>9</sub><sup>-</sup>) with lanthanides is also implied. The potential for these complexes in applications like single-molecule magnets is also mentioned.

Summary updated

Abstract

Lanthanide (Ln) elements are generally found in the oxidation state +II or +III, and a few examples of +IV and +V compounds have also been reported. In contrast, monovalent Ln(+I) complexes remain scarce. Here we combine photoelectron spectroscopy and theoretical calculations to study Ln-doped octa-boron clusters (LnB<sub>8</sub><sup>-</sup>, Ln = La, Pr, Tb, Tm, Yb) with the rare +I oxidation state. The global minimum of the LnB<sub>8</sub><sup>-</sup> species changes from C<sub>s</sub> to C<sub>7v</sub> symmetry accompanied by an oxidation-state change from +III to +I from the early to late lanthanides. All the C<sub>7v</sub>-LnB<sub>8</sub><sup>-</sup> clusters can be viewed as a monovalent Ln(I) coordinated by a η<sup>8</sup>-B<sub>8</sub><sup>2-</sup> doubly aromatic ligand. The B<sub>7</sub><sup>3-</sup>, B<sub>8</sub><sup>2-</sup>, and B<sub>9</sub><sup>-</sup> series of aromatic boron clusters are analogous to the classical aromatic hydrocarbon molecules, C<sub>5</sub>H<sub>5</sub><sup>-</sup>, C<sub>6</sub>H<sub>6</sub>, and C<sub>7</sub>H<sub>7</sub><sup>+</sup>, respectively, with similar trends of size and charge state and they are named collectively as "borozenes". Lanthanides with variable oxidation states and magnetic properties may be formed with different borozenes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2021monovalent,
  author = {Wan‐Lu Li and Teng‐Teng Chen and Weijia Chen and Jun Li and Lai‐Sheng Wang},
  title = {{Monovalent lanthanide(I) in borozene complexes}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-021-26785-9},
}
Figure