Monotonic Prefix Consistency in Distributed Systems

Alain Girault, Gregor Gößler, Rachid Guerraoui, Jad Hamza, Dragos-Adrian Seredinschi

TL;DR

This paper investigates the strongest possible data consistency guarantees in distributed systems that prioritize availability and tolerate network partitions. They prove that Monotonic Prefix Consistency (MPC) is the strongest achievable criterion under these conditions, meaning no system can offer stronger guarantees while remaining available and convergent. This is significant because it defines a fundamental limit on data consistency in real-world distributed systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In distributed systems, data is often replicated across multiple sites to improve availability and reduce latency. However, ensuring all replicas are perfectly synchronized (strong consistency or linearizability) is impossible in systems that must remain available during network partitions. This leads to the need for weaker consistency models. The paper tackles the question: among the many weaker consistency models, what is the strongest one that can be practically implemented in a system that is always available and eventually converges to a consistent state? They focus on data types where operations can be clearly separated into updates (modifying state) and queries (reading state).

Methods

The authors formally define a model for replicated data types and their executions. They introduce the concept of a "trace" which represents what a client can observe: an unordered set of updates and ordered sequences of queries per site. They then define Monotonic Prefix Consistency (MPC) based on these traces, requiring that queries on the same site return non-decreasing prefixes of updates, and queries on different sites return compatible prefixes. The core of their contribution is a theoretical proof demonstrating that no consistency criterion stronger than MPC can be implemented in a system that is both available and convergent. This involves constructing a toy implementation that satisfies MPC and then using a series of lemmas to show that any convergent implementation cannot achieve more than MPC.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Trade-off is Fundamental: The paper establishes a hard limit on data consistency in available distributed systems. You can't have perfect consistency (like strong consistency) and high availability simultaneously.
  • MPC as the Sweet Spot: Monotonic Prefix Consistency (MPC) emerges as the strongest achievable consistency model under these practical constraints. It offers a reasonable level of order for updates without demanding strict synchronization.
  • Observability Matters: The authors define a specific notion of client observability (traces) where writes are unordered. This is crucial because, under this limited view, MPC becomes indistinguishable from strong consistency. This implies that for certain applications, achieving MPC might be sufficient and simpler to implement than strong consistency.
  • Incomparability with Causal Consistency: The paper highlights that MPC is incomparable to causal consistency. This means neither is strictly stronger than the other; they offer different trade-offs and allow for different behaviors.

Key Results

The paper's main result is a theoretical proof (Theorem 1) stating that no convergent implementation can be strictly stronger than Monotonic Prefix Consistency (MPC). This means that for any convergent implementation I, there exists a trace of MPC that I cannot produce. They also provide a concrete implementation (Figure 2) that demonstrates MPC is indeed feasible.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Observability Model: The authors acknowledge that their definition of a trace (unordered writes) is specific and might not capture all real-world scenarios, especially those where the origin or timing of writes is critical (e.g., some blockchain protocols).
  • Probabilistic Settings: The paper focuses on deterministic guarantees. Future work could explore the strongest consistency criterion in probabilistic settings.
  • System Models: Extending the results to other system models, particularly those where the origin of updates does matter, is a suggested future direction.
  • Blockchain Connection: The paper notes that blockchain protocols often exhibit MPC-like properties, suggesting a practical relevance for their findings. Further investigation into the exact consistency achieved by these protocols is an open area.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study the issue of data consistency in distributed systems. Specifically, we consider a distributed system that replicates its data at multiple sites, which is prone to partitions, and which is assumed to be available (in the sense that queries are always eventually answered). In such a setting, strong consistency, where all replicas of the system apply synchronously every operation, is not possible to implement. However, many weaker consistency criteria that allow a greater number of behaviors than strong consistency, are implementable in available distributed systems. We focus on determining the strongest consistency criterion that can be implemented in a convergent and available distributed system that tolerates partitions. We focus on objects where the set of operations can be split into updates and queries. We show that no criterion stronger than Monotonic Prefix Consistency (MPC) can be implemented.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{girault2017monotonic,
  author = {Alain Girault and Gregor Gößler and Rachid Guerraoui and Jad Hamza and Dragos-Adrian Seredinschi},
  title = {{Monotonic Prefix Consistency in Distributed Systems}},
  booktitle = {FORTE},
  year = {2017},
}
Figure