TL;DR
This paper systematically compares the reach of "mono-X" (where X is a Higgs, Z, or b boson) dark matter searches at the LHC with direct searches for the mediator particle. While direct searches are often stronger, the study identifies specific scenarios, particularly those with compressed spectra in inelastic DM, two Higgs doublet, and squark models, where mono-X searches offer unique and powerful constraints.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The search for dark matter (DM) at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) has traditionally focused on specific signatures, often assuming DM candidates like WIMPs. However, the theoretical landscape of DM is vast, and many models predict different production mechanisms and mediator particles. This paper addresses the challenge of comprehensively evaluating the LHC's sensitivity to DM across a broad range of simplified models. Specifically, it aims to:
- Map the LHC reach: Determine how well various simplified models for DM production at the LHC can be constrained by "mono-X" final states (where X is a Higgs, Z, or b boson).
- Compare search strategies: Quantify the sensitivity of mono-X searches relative to direct searches for the mediator particle responsible for DM production. This comparison is crucial for optimizing future LHC search strategies.
- Identify complementary probes: Pinpoint specific regions of parameter space within simplified models where mono-X searches provide the strongest or unique constraints, complementing existing direct detection and other collider searches.
The paper highlights that while effective field theory (EFT) approaches offer a convenient way to compare different searches, they can become unreliable at the energy scales probed by the LHC. Therefore, using UV-complete simplified models is essential for accurate comparisons and for understanding the interplay between different experimental probes.
Methods
The authors employ a systematic approach to analyze various simplified models for DM production at the LHC. Their methodology includes:
- Simplified Model Framework: They utilize a set of UV-complete simplified models, which are designed to capture the essential features of DM production and mediator interactions without necessarily describing the full underlying theory. These models typically involve a DM particle and a mediator that couples to both DM and Standard Model (SM) particles.
- Mono-X Signatures: The focus is on mono-Higgs, mono-Z, and mono-b final states, where a single Higgs, Z, or b boson is produced alongside missing transverse energy (indicative of DM). These signatures are generated through tree-level processes.
- Recasting and Simulation: For many of the analyses, the authors perform "recasting," which involves reinterpreting existing experimental search results within the framework of their simplified models. In some cases, they also perform Monte Carlo event simulations using standard tools like MadGraph, Pythia, and Delphes to generate signal events and estimate background contributions.
- Comparison with Direct Searches: A core aspect of the study is comparing the exclusion limits derived from mono-X searches with those obtained from direct searches for the mediator particle (e.g., di-jet searches for resonances, searches for jets plus missing transverse energy).
- Parameter Space Exploration: The paper focuses on specific benchmark points and slices of parameter space to highlight the main qualitative features and comparisons between different search strategies, rather than performing exhaustive full parameter scans.
- Future Projections: The study also includes projections for future LHC runs at 14 TeV, providing insights into the potential reach of these searches with increased luminosity and energy.
Datasets
The paper primarily utilizes existing experimental data and results from LHC searches. The specific datasets and analyses referenced are detailed in Tables IV, V, VI, and VII, and in the bibliography. These include:
- 8 TeV LHC data: Results from various ATLAS and CMS experiments for searches such as di-jet resonance searches, mono-jet, jets + missing transverse energy (E_T), mono-b, mono-h, mono-Z, and diboson + E_T.
- 13 TeV LHC data: Some analyses from 2015 data are considered, and projections for 14 TeV are made based on future integrated luminosities (e.g., 300 fb⁻¹).
No new datasets were introduced by the authors; rather, they reinterpreted existing experimental results within their simplified model framework.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Direct Searches Often Dominate: A recurring theme is that direct searches for the mediator particle (e.g., via di-jet resonances) often provide stronger constraints than mono-X searches across a broad range of parameter space. This is because direct searches can probe larger mediator masses and couplings.
- Mono-X Searches Shine in Specific Niches: Despite the general dominance of direct searches, the study highlights crucial scenarios where mono-X searches are particularly powerful or even dominant. These include:
- Compressed Spectra: In models where the mass splitting between the mediator and the DM particle is small (compressed spectrum), the mono-X signature can become more prominent relative to other signatures, making mono-X searches more competitive.
- Inelastic DM: Models with inelastic DM, where an excited state of DM decays into DM plus a visible particle, can lead to significant mono-Z or mono-h signals.
- Two Higgs Doublet Models (2HDM): In certain parameter regions of 2HDM, mono-Higgs and mono-Z searches can provide significant constraints.
- Squark and Sbottom Mediated Production: For specific parameter choices, particularly in compressed scenarios, mono-X searches can offer valuable insights.
- Complementarity is Key: The paper emphasizes that mono-X searches are not always the most powerful probe but are essential for exploring specific regions of parameter space and complementing other search strategies. They offer a unique window into DM physics that might be missed by direct searches alone.
- Model Dependence is Crucial: The effectiveness of mono-X searches is highly dependent on the specific simplified model and its parameters. Understanding this dependence is vital for optimizing future experimental strategies.
Key Results
The paper systematically compares the reach of mono-X searches (mono-h, mono-Z, mono-b) against direct searches for mediators in various simplified models. Key findings include:
- General Dominance of Direct Searches: For most of the simplified models considered, direct searches for the mediator particle (e.g., di-jets, jets + E_T) provide stronger exclusion limits than mono-X searches. This is particularly true for models with large mediator masses or strong couplings to SM quarks.
- Mono-X Strength in Specific Scenarios:
- Inelastic DM: Mono-Z and mono-h searches can be competitive, especially for certain mass configurations and MET cuts.
- 2HDM: Mono-Z searches generally cover a larger parameter space than mono-h for the same production cross-section.
- Squarks with mono-Z: Mono-Z searches are found to be significantly weaker than di-jet and jets + E_T searches, even in compressed scenarios.
- Sbottoms with mono-b, mono-h, mono-Z: In the compressed region, mono-b searches become important, and mono-h searches can constrain specific couplings.
- Future Projections: Projections for 14 TeV LHC runs indicate improved sensitivity, but in many cases, direct searches are still expected to dominate. However, the mono-X searches remain crucial for exploring specific parameter regions.
Limitations and Future Work
- Focus on Simplified Models: The study is based on simplified models, which are by definition approximations of more complex UV-complete theories. The authors acknowledge that a full parameter scan for each model is beyond the scope of this work, and they focus on slices of parameter space to highlight key features.
- Experimental Uncertainties: While the paper uses existing experimental results and projections, it notes that future studies by experimental collaborations are likely to improve the limits and potentially refine the conclusions.
- Specific Model Assumptions: For some models, specific assumptions are made regarding couplings, branching ratios, and the nature of the DM particle (e.g., fermionic singlet). Relaxing these assumptions could lead to different conclusions.
- Future Work: The authors suggest that a full parameter scan for each model could be performed. They also leave the study of mono-photon searches and specific VBF topologies to future work. The presented analysis could also be updated with new Run II analyses as they become available.
Summary updated