Monitoring and Diagnosability of Perception Systems

Pasquale Antonante, David I. Spivak, Luca Carlone

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel mathematical framework for monitoring and diagnosing faults in the perception systems of autonomous vehicles. By extending existing fault diagnosis techniques to handle the complexities of perception pipelines (heterogeneous modules and temporal interactions), the authors provide a formal way to guarantee and monitor safe operation, crucial for building public trust and enabling wider adoption of self-driving technology.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Autonomous vehicles (AVs) rely heavily on perception systems to understand their surroundings – think object detection, lane finding, and localization. Failures in these systems can have catastrophic consequences, as tragically demonstrated by past accidents. While safety is paramount, current methods for ensuring the reliability of AV perception systems are often ad-hoc or lack formal guarantees. Existing safety standards like ISO 26262 are not fully equipped to handle the complexities of fully autonomous systems, especially their perception components. The core challenge is to develop a rigorous, mathematical approach to monitor these systems in real-time, detect when something goes wrong, and pinpoint the source of the fault, even when multiple components might be misbehaving. This is essential for both regulatory certification and building public confidence in AVs.

Methods

The paper's main contribution is a mathematical model for runtime monitoring and fault detection in perception systems. They achieve this by:

  • Generalizing Multiprocessor Diagnosability: They draw inspiration from established techniques for diagnosing faults in multiprocessor systems. However, perception systems are different: modules have diverse outputs and operate at different rates, and their outputs are temporally dependent. The authors adapt these techniques to handle this heterogeneity and temporal aspect.
  • Graph-Theoretic Approach: They model the perception system as a directed graph, where nodes represent modules and edges represent data flows or consistency checks. This "diagnostic graph" allows them to formalize how modules test each other.
  • Temporal Diagnostic Graphs: To capture the time-varying nature of perception data and module interactions, they introduce "temporal diagnostic graphs." These graphs extend the static diagnostic graph to encompass time intervals and temporal consistency checks between module outputs over time. This allows for a more comprehensive understanding of system behavior and fault propagation.
  • Topos Theory: For a more elegant and powerful formulation, they show how their temporal diagnostic graphs can be described using the language of topos theory. This provides a formal framework for reasoning about diagnosability and fault detection over arbitrary time intervals.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on a theoretical framework and uses an example perception pipeline for illustration.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Temporal Consistency is Key: The paper highlights that simply checking module outputs at a single point in time is insufficient. The temporal evolution of data and module interactions provides crucial information for detecting and diagnosing faults that might otherwise be masked.
  • Heterogeneity is a Major Hurdle: Traditional fault diagnosis often assumes identical components. Perception systems are inherently heterogeneous, with different sensors, algorithms, and output types. The proposed framework explicitly addresses this, making it applicable to real-world AV perception stacks.
  • Topos Theory as a Unifying Language: The use of topos theory offers a sophisticated and concise way to express complex temporal relationships and diagnosability properties, potentially simplifying the development of formal verification tools for AV systems.
  • Diagnosability as a Measurable Guarantee: The framework provides a quantitative measure of how many faults can be detected and identified, offering a formal guarantee of system robustness.

Key Results

The paper presents a theoretical framework and a methodology for monitoring and fault diagnosis. While specific quantitative results are not detailed in the provided text (as it focuses on the methodology and theoretical underpinnings), the key outcome is the development of:

  • A mathematical model for runtime monitoring and fault detection in perception systems.
  • A graph-theoretic approach to represent perception systems and their diagnostic capabilities.
  • The concept of temporal diagnostic graphs to capture time-varying behaviors and inter-module dependencies.
  • A demonstration that this temporal approach can enhance diagnosability compared to static methods.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Complexity: While the paper mentions that fault identification can be practical, the underlying algorithms for determining diagnosability and identifying faults can be computationally intensive. The paper notes that naive implementations can be impractical, and while improved algorithms exist, their real-time performance in complex AV systems would need thorough evaluation.
  • Real-world Validation: The paper uses an example perception pipeline for illustration and discusses the theoretical framework. The abstract mentions "realistic simulations using the LGSVL self-driving simulator and the Apollo Auto autonomy software stack" and "minimal computation overhead (< 5 ms on a single-core CPU)," but these specific results are not detailed in the provided text.
  • Modeling Complex Scenarios: The paper acknowledges the need for more examples of perception systems that can be modeled and benefit from their approach.
  • Full AV Architecture: A future direction is to extend this work to model an entire AV software architecture, not just the perception component, using temporal type theory.

Summary updated

Abstract

Perception is a critical component of high-integrity applications of robotics and autonomous systems, such as self-driving vehicles. In these applications, failure of perception systems may put human life at risk, and a broad adoption of these technologies requires the development of methodologies to guarantee and monitor safe operation. Despite the paramount importance of perception systems, currently there is no formal approach for system-level monitoring. In this work, we propose a mathematical model for runtime monitoring and fault detection and identification in perception systems. Towards this goal, we draw connections with the literature on diagnosability in multiprocessor systems, and generalize it to account for modules with heterogeneous outputs that interact over time. The resulting temporal diagnostic graphs (i) provide a framework to reason over the consistency of perception outputs –across modules and over time– thus enabling fault detection, (ii) allow us to establish formal guarantees on the maximum number of faults that can be uniquely identified in a given perception system, and (iii) enable the design of efficient algorithms for fault identification. We demonstrate our monitoring system, dubbed PerSyS, in realistic simulations using the LGSVL self-driving simulator and the Apollo Auto autonomy software stack, and show that PerSyS is able to detect failures in challenging scenarios (including scenarios that have caused self-driving car accidents in recent years), and is able to correctly identify faults while entailing a minimal computation overhead (< 5 ms on a single-core CPU).
BibTeX
@inproceedings{antonante2021monitoring,
  author = {Pasquale Antonante and David I. Spivak and Luca Carlone},
  title = {{Monitoring and Diagnosability of Perception Systems}},
  booktitle = {IEEE/RSJ International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=qoUI0Eea8r},
}
Figure