Molecular characterization of breast cancer CTCs associated with brain metastasis

Debasish Boral, Monika Vishnoi, Haowen N. Liu, Wei Yin, Marc L. Sprouse, Antonio Scamardo, David S. Hong, Tuan Zea Tan, Jean Paul Thiery, Jenny C. Chang, Dario MarchettiNature Communications 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study identifies a unique molecular signature in circulating tumor cells (CTCs) from breast cancer patients with brain metastasis (BCBM). This signature, distinct from primary tumors, reveals specific signaling pathways that may drive BCBM, offering potential for early detection and personalized treatment strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Breast cancer brain metastasis (BCBM) is a significant clinical challenge, often diagnosed late and associated with poor prognosis. Current methods for detecting and characterizing circulating tumor cells (CTCs) have limitations, particularly in identifying the specific CTCs that contribute to brain metastasis. The authors aim to bridge this gap by developing a novel workflow to isolate and molecularly characterize CTCs from patients with BCBM, seeking to understand the unique biological mechanisms driving this aggressive form of metastasis. This understanding is crucial for developing early diagnostic tools and more effective therapeutic interventions.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-parametric flow cytometry approach to isolate CTCs, going beyond the standard EpCAM-positive markers to also capture "stem-like" CTCs (CD44+/CD24-). Their workflow involved:

  1. Doublet discrimination and dead cell exclusion: Standard flow cytometry techniques to ensure single, live cells.
  2. Lineage depletion: Removal of non-tumor cells using lineage-specific antibodies.
  3. Positive selection: Isolation of epithelial (PanCK+) and stem-like (CD44+/CD24-) CTCs.

To characterize these isolated CTCs, they utilized:

  • Immuno-cytochemistry: To visualize biomarker expression on CTCs.
  • DEPArray™: A microfluidic device for isolating and validating single CTCs.
  • TP53 mutation analysis (Sanger sequencing): To confirm the tumor origin of isolated CTCs and differentiate them from normal cells.
  • Whole-genome mRNA microarray: To compare gene expression profiles of CTCs with primary breast cancer tissues.
  • Quantitative PCR (qPCR): To validate specific gene expression changes and assess mitochondrial-to-nuclear DNA (MTN) index for proliferative status.
  • Ingenuity Pathway Analysis (IPA): To identify activated canonical pathways and cellular functions.

A key innovation is the development of a single-step flow cytometric method for enumerating Ki67+ and uPAR+/int-β1+ CTCs, and the use of the MTN index as a surrogate for proliferative potency.

Datasets

The study utilized the following datasets:

  • Patient-derived CTCs: Isolated from a cohort of 10 breast cancer patients and 3 healthy female donors.
  • Primary breast cancer (pBC) samples: Gene expression data curated from 31 pBC samples (GSE65505, GSE67982, GSE76250) representing different molecular subtypes.
  • T-cell transcriptomes: Data from CD4+ and CD8+ T-cells (GSE73079, GSE73081) for comparative analysis.
  • Breast cancer cell lines: Used for comparison with CTC transcriptomes.

The study also generated and analyzed whole-genome sequencing data from isolated CTC subsets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • BCBM CTCs are a distinct subpopulation: The study strongly suggests that CTCs associated with brain metastasis are not just a random subset of circulating tumor cells but possess unique molecular characteristics.
  • Beyond EpCAM: The inclusion of stem-like CTCs (CD44+/CD24-) in the analysis is crucial, as these cells may play a significant role in metastasis and are often missed by standard EpCAM-based methods.
  • Proliferative vs. Dormant CTCs: The research highlights a dichotomy in CTCs, with some exhibiting high proliferation (Ki67High) and others showing signs of growth arrest. This balance is critical for survival in circulation and subsequent metastasis.
  • Notch signaling is key in BCBM: The study identifies the Notch signaling pathway as significantly upregulated in BCBM-associated CTCs, suggesting its role in driving brain metastasis.
  • Immune evasion mechanisms: Novel inflammatory and immunomodulatory networks are implicated in BCBM CTCs, pointing towards strategies for immune evasion.

Key Results

  • Increased CTC capture: The novel workflow captured significantly more CTCs (PanCK+ and CD44+/CD24-) compared to the standard CellSearch® platform.
  • Unique CTC gene signature: CTC transcriptomes clustered independently of primary breast cancer subtypes, revealing a unique gene signature across all CTCs.
  • BCBM-specific signature: A distinct 126-gene signature was identified in CTCs from patients with BCBM compared to those without.
  • Proliferative differences: BCBM patients showed a higher ratio of Ki67High CTCs compared to non-BCBM patients.
  • Notch1 activation: Approximately 72% of BCBM CTCs were positive for Notch1 staining, compared to 24% in non-BCBM patients.
  • Genomic instability: CTC subsets from BCBM patients exhibited a significantly higher incidence of genomic mutations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Small patient cohort: The study analyzed a relatively small number of patients (10 for transcriptomics, 16 for Ki67/uPAR analysis), which limits the generalizability of findings.
  • Unmatched patient cohort for transcriptomics: The initial transcriptomic analysis used an unmatched cohort of patients with advanced breast cancer, making it challenging to definitively link gene signatures to specific metastatic sites without further segregation.
  • Future Work: The authors propose that their findings can be translated into clinical applications:
  • Screening tool: Using CTC enumeration and specific biomarkers (e.g., Ki67+/uPAR+/int-β1+, Notch1+) as a screening method for early detection of brain micro-metastasis.
  • Therapeutic monitoring: Serial estimation of these CTCs to evaluate treatment response in BCBM patients.
  • Further validation: Future studies are needed to validate these biomarkers and pathways in larger, prospective cohorts.

Summary updated

Abstract

The enumeration of EpCAM-positive circulating tumor cells (CTCs) has allowed estimation of overall metastatic burden in breast cancer patients. However, a thorough understanding of CTCs associated with breast cancer brain metastasis (BCBM) is necessary for early identification and evaluation of treatment response to BCBM. Here we report that BCBM CTCs is enriched in a distinct sub-population of cells identifiable by their biomarker expression and mutational content. Deriving from a comprehensive analysis of CTC transcriptomes, we discovered a unique "circulating tumor cell gene signature" that is distinct from primary breast cancer tissues. Further dissection of the circulating tumor cell gene signature identified signaling pathways associated with BCBM CTCs that may have roles in potentiating BCBM. This study proposes CTC biomarkers and signaling pathways implicated in BCBM that may be used either as a screening tool for brain micro-metastasis detection or for making rational treatment decisions and monitoring therapeutic response in patients with BCBM.Characterization of CTCs derived from breast cancer patients with brain metastasis (BCBM) may allow for early diagnosis of brain metastasis and/or help for treatment choice and its efficacy. In this study, the authors identify a unique signature, based on patient-derived CTCs transcriptomes, for BCBM- CTCs that is different from primary tumors.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{boral2017molecular,
  author = {Debasish Boral and Monika Vishnoi and Haowen N. Liu and Wei Yin and Marc L. Sprouse and Antonio Scamardo and David S. Hong and Tuan Zea Tan and Jean Paul Thiery and Jenny C. Chang and Dario Marchetti},
  title = {{Molecular characterization of breast cancer CTCs associated with brain metastasis}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-017-00196-1},
}
Figure