Modulation of prefrontal couplings by prior belief-related responses in ventromedial prefrontal cortex

Bin Wang, Sabrina Drammis, Ali Hummos, Michael M. Halassa, Burkhard Pleger

Abstract

Humans and animals maintain constant payoffs in uncertain environments by steadily re-evaluating and flexibly adjusting strategies, a process largely dependent on interactions between the prefrontal cortex (PFC) and mediodorsal thalamus (MD). While the ventromedial PFC (vmPFC) represents uncertainty (prior belief about external states), the mechanism by which the brain recruits the PFC-MD network to re-evaluate decision strategy based on this uncertainty remains unclear. This study leverages nonlinear dynamic causal modeling (DCM) on fMRI data to test how prior belief-dependent activity in the vmPFC gates information flow in the PFC-MD network during strategy switching. Results show that vmPFC responses modulate connections from the dorsolateral PFC (dlPFC) to both the lateral orbitofrontal cortex (lOFC) and MD. Specifically, weaker prior beliefs (higher uncertainty) reduce the inhibitory influence of the vmPFC on the dlPFC-to-lOFC connection, suggesting the vmPFC acts as a gatekeeper for recruiting resources to re-evaluate decision strategies under uncertainty.

Introduction: The Challenge of Cognitive Flexibility

In dynamic environments, the ability to decide whether to persist with a current strategy or switch to a new one—known as cognitive flexibility—is crucial for survival. This process is known to involve a network comprising the prefrontal cortex (PFC) and the mediodorsal thalamus (MD). While previous research identified that the ventromedial PFC (vmPFC) tracks "prior beliefs" or the level of certainty regarding environmental states, the precise mechanism by which this signal influences the broader decision-making network has remained elusive. Does the vmPFC merely transmit information, or does it actively control the communication between other executive regions? This study investigates the "gating" mechanism that allows uncertainty to trigger shifts in behavioral strategy.

Methods and Modeling Framework

The researchers re-analyzed fMRI data from 28 healthy male participants performing a tactile associative learning task. In this task, participants predicted target patterns following tactile cues, with the predictability of targets varying over time (50% to 90% probability) to induce changes in uncertainty.

To bridge the gap between neural activity and cognitive states, two primary modeling techniques were employed:

  1. Hierarchical Gaussian Filter (HGF): A computational model used to estimate trial-by-trial "prior belief" and environmental volatility.
  2. Nonlinear Dynamic Causal Modeling (DCM): Unlike standard DCM, which examines direct excitation or inhibition between regions, nonlinear DCM allows for "gating" effects. Here, it was used to test if a third region (the vmPFC) modulates the strength of connections between other nodes in the PFC-MD network.
Overview of the experimental framework, including brain activations (A), model structures (B, D), and trial-by-trial belief tracking (C).

The study compared six competing models to determine which specific neural pathways were modulated by the vmPFC’s representation of uncertainty.

Results: The vmPFC as a Neural Gatekeeper

The analysis confirmed that activity in the vmPFC, left precuneus, and middle cingulate cortex significantly correlated with the HGF-derived "prior belief." When comparing strategy switching versus staying, significant activations were observed in the dlPFC, lOFC, and MD.

Brain regions showing significantly higher activity during strategy switching compared to staying: dlPFC, lOFC, and MD.

Key Findings

  • Winning Model: Bayesian Model Selection (BMS) identified a model where vmPFC activity modulated connections from the dlPFC to both the lOFC and the MD.
  • Significant Gating Effect: Bayesian Parameter Averaging (BPA) revealed that the modulation of the dlPFC → lOFC connection was highly significant (posterior probability = 0.94). The modulation of the dlPFC → MD connection showed a similar trend (0.81) but did not reach the strict 0.90 significance threshold.
  • Inhibitory Control: The modulation was found to be primarily inhibitory. Under high certainty (strong prior belief), the vmPFC inhibits the connection between the dlPFC and lOFC, likely conserving metabolic resources.
  • Uncertainty-Driven Recruitment: As uncertainty increases (weak prior belief), the vmPFC's inhibitory grip relaxes. This "opens the gate," allowing the dlPFC to increase its influence on the lOFC and MD, thereby recruiting the processing resources necessary to re-evaluate and adapt decision strategies.

Discussion and Future Directions

The findings suggest that the vmPFC acts as a gatekeeper, controlling the recruitment of the PFC-MD network based on environmental uncertainty. The authors propose that these nonlinear effects may be driven by short-term synaptic plasticity (STP) controlled by NMDA receptors.

However, several limitations remain. The spatial resolution of fMRI prevented the distinction between specific subnuclei of the MD thalamus. Additionally, the study's exclusively male sample limits generalizability. Future research using higher-resolution imaging and including more diverse participant groups will be essential to further refine this model of cognitive flexibility and explore the involvement of other regions like the basal ganglia and amygdala.

Summary updated

Abstract

Humans and other animals can maintain constant payoffs in an uncertain environment by steadily re-evaluating and flexibly adjusting current strategy, which largely depends on the interactions between the prefrontal cortex (PFC) and mediodorsal thalamus (MD). While the ventromedial PFC (vmPFC) represents the level of uncertainty (i.e., prior belief about external states), it remains unclear how the brain recruits the PFC-MD network to re-evaluate decision strategy based on the uncertainty. Here, we leverage non-linear dynamic causal modeling on fMRI data to test how prior belief-dependent activity in vmPFC gates the information flow in the PFC-MD network when individuals switch their decision strategy. We show that the prior belief-related responses in vmPFC had a modulatory influence on the connections from dorsolateral PFC (dlPFC) to both, lateral orbitofrontal (lOFC) and MD. Bayesian parameter averaging revealed that only the connection from the dlPFC to lOFC surpassed the significant threshold, which indicates that the weaker the prior belief, the less was the inhibitory influence of the vmPFC on the strength of effective connections from dlPFC to lOFC. These findings suggest that the vmPFC acts as a gatekeeper for the recruitment of processing resources to re-evaluate the decision strategy in situations of high uncertainty.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2023modulation,
  author = {Bin Wang and Sabrina Drammis and Ali Hummos and Michael M. Halassa and Burkhard Pleger},
  title = {{Modulation of prefrontal couplings by prior belief-related responses in ventromedial prefrontal cortex}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Neuroscience},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fnins.2023.1278096},
}
Figure