Modulation of Instagram Number of Followings by Avoidance in Close Relationships in Young Adults under a Gene x Environment Perspective

Andrea Bonassi, Alessandro Carollo, Ilaria Cataldo, Giulio Gabrieli, Moses Tandiono, Jia Nee Foo, Bruno Lepri, Gianluca Esposito

TL;DR

This study investigates how individual differences in attachment styles and genetics influence Instagram behavior, specifically the number of "followings." It found that individuals with higher avoidance in close relationships tend to follow fewer people on Instagram, suggesting that real-world relationship patterns extend to online social networking.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rise of social networking sites (SNS) like Instagram has fundamentally altered human social interaction. While we understand much about in-person social behavior, the mechanisms driving online socialization are still being uncovered. This paper aims to bridge this gap by exploring how both environmental factors (adult attachment quality) and genetic predispositions (Serotonin Transporter Gene, 5-HTTLPR) might influence Instagram usage patterns. Specifically, it questions whether the way individuals form and maintain close relationships in real life translates to their online social networking behavior.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to gather data from 57 young adult Instagram users.

  • Attachment Assessment: Participants completed the "Experiences in Close Relationships-Revised" (ECR-R) questionnaire to measure their levels of anxiety and avoidance in romantic relationships.
  • Genetic Analysis: DNA was extracted from participants' buccal mucosa to determine their genotype for the 5-HTTLPR/rs25531 region, a gene known to influence serotonin transporter levels and social behavior.
  • Instagram Behavior Metrics: A custom Python scraper was used to extract data from participants' Instagram profiles, focusing on:
  • Number of posts
    • Number of followed users ("followings")
    • Number of followers
    • Social Desirability Index (SDI), calculated as the ratio of followers to followings.
  • Statistical Analysis: Standard statistical methods, including ANCOVA and Welch's t-test, were used to analyze the data. A Bayesian approach was also employed to compare models and assess the evidence for the observed relationships.

Datasets

The study utilized data from two primary sources:

  • Participant Self-Reports: Data from the "Experiences in Close Relationships-Revised" (ECR-R) questionnaire.
  • Instagram Profile Data: Publicly available data scraped from the Instagram profiles of the 57 participants, including number of posts, followings, and followers.

No new datasets or benchmarks were introduced in this paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Real-world avoidance predicts online following behavior: The most significant finding is the direct link between higher avoidance in close relationships and a lower number of Instagram "followings." This suggests that individuals who tend to distance themselves emotionally or avoid intimacy in their romantic partnerships also exhibit a similar tendency to limit their engagement with others online.
  • Gene-environment interaction was hypothesized but not found: The researchers initially hypothesized that a specific genetic variant (5-HTTLPR/rs25531) would interact with attachment styles to influence Instagram behavior. However, this interaction was not statistically significant.
  • Avoidance is the key environmental factor: While the genetic component didn't show an interaction effect, the environmental factor of avoidance in close relationships emerged as a strong predictor of Instagram followings. This highlights the significant role of relational experiences in shaping online social behavior.
  • Instagram behavior reflects broader social tendencies: The study reinforces the idea that online social networking is not a separate domain but rather an extension of an individual's offline social tendencies and personality traits.

Key Results

  • Avoidance significantly predicts Instagram followings: Users reporting higher levels of avoidance in close relationships followed significantly fewer Instagram accounts. This effect was statistically significant (p = 0.015) and supported by Bayesian analysis.
  • No significant gene-environment interaction: The study did not find evidence of an interaction between the 5-HTTLPR/rs25531 genotype and attachment dimensions (anxiety or avoidance) on Instagram number of posts, followings, or SDI.
  • No gender differences: Preliminary analyses indicated no significant differences in Instagram metrics between male and female participants.
  • Exploratory findings on followers: An exploratory analysis on the number of Instagram followers did not reveal any significant main effects or interaction effects.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Small and biased sample: The study involved a limited sample of 57 participants, predominantly female, from a university setting. This limits the generalizability of the findings.
  • Self-report measures: Attachment styles were assessed via self-report, which can be subject to biases.
  • Limited genetic analysis: The study focused on a specific region of the serotonin transporter gene (5-HTTLPR/rs25531) and did not consider other genetic variations or the short/long allelic variation.
  • Nature of "followings": The study did not differentiate the types of accounts followed (e.g., private individuals, brands, influencers), which could influence the interpretation of "followings."
  • Uncontrolled factors: Personality traits and other potential influences on attachment and Instagram activity were not assessed.

Future research directions suggested include:

  • Larger and more diverse samples: Future studies should aim for larger sample sizes with better representation across genders, ages, ethnicities, and attachment styles.
  • Investigating other genetic factors: Exploring other SNPs related to serotonin and their interactions with environmental factors could provide a more comprehensive understanding.
  • Cross-cultural studies: Examining gene-by-environment interactions on social media behavior across different cultures could reveal universal or culturally specific patterns.
  • Broader SNS analysis: Extending this research to other social networking platforms like Facebook, TikTok, or LinkedIn could offer a more holistic view of online socialization.
  • Longitudinal studies: Tracking individuals over time could provide deeper insights into the developmental trajectories of gene-environment influences on online behavior.

Summary updated

Abstract

Social networking sites have determined radical changes in human life, demanding investigations on online socialization mechanisms. The knowledge acquired on in-person sociability could guide researchers to consider both environmental and genetic features as candidates of online socialization. Here, we explored the impact of the quality of adult attachment and the genetic properties of the Serotonin Transporter Gene (<i>5-HTTLPR</i>) on Instagram social behavior. <i>Experiences in Close Relationships-Revised</i> questionnaire was adopted to assess 57 Instagram users' attachment pattern in close relationships with partners. Genotypes from the <i>5-HTTLPR</i>/rs25531 region were extracted from the users' buccal mucosa and analyzed. Users' Instagram social behavior was examined from four indexes: number of posts, number of followed users ("followings") and number of followers, and the Social Desirability Index calculated from the followers to followings ratio. Although no interaction between rs25531 and ECR-R dimensions was found, an association between avoidance in close relationships and Instagram number of followings emerged. Post hoc analyses revealed adult avoidance from the partner predicts the Instagram number of followings with good evidence. Moreover, users reporting high avoidance levels displayed fewer followings than users who reported low levels of avoidance. This research provides a window into the psychobiological understanding of online socialization on Instagram.
BibTeX
@article{bonassi2021modulation,
  author = {Andrea Bonassi and Alessandro Carollo and Ilaria Cataldo and Giulio Gabrieli and Moses Tandiono and Jia Nee Foo and Bruno Lepri and Gianluca Esposito},
  title = {{Modulation of Instagram Number of Followings by Avoidance in Close Relationships in Young Adults under a Gene x Environment Perspective}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph18147547},
}
Figure