TL;DR
This bibliometric analysis reveals a significant increase in research on Blood Stasis Syndrome (BSS) from 1989-2015, particularly in China, with growing quality and diversity of studies. However, the field faces challenges with inconsistent diagnostic criteria, limited academic influence, and a need for more standardized research methodologies.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Blood Stasis Syndrome (BSS) is a fundamental concept in Traditional East Asian Medicine (TEAM), representing a state of impaired blood circulation often associated with pain and other symptoms. Despite its long history and clinical relevance, modern research on BSS has been fragmented. The authors identified a lack of comprehensive understanding of the publication landscape, quality, and academic impact of BSS research. Specifically, they aimed to address the inconsistency in diagnostic criteria, which hinders comparability and generalization of findings, and to assess the overall academic influence and productivity of BSS research over a 27-year period.
Methods
The researchers conducted a bibliometric analysis of BSS-related articles published in PubMed between January 1, 1989, and December 31, 2015. They searched using the term "blood stasis syndrome" and applied inclusion criteria focusing on articles within the TEAM framework, written in English, and within the specified date range. Data extracted included publication information (journal, year, article type, country), study content (diseases, subjects, diagnostic criteria, interventions), and bibliometric indicators (citations from Web of Science, Scopus, Google Scholar; h-index; journal impact factor). Data analysis involved descriptive statistics (counts, percentages, frequencies) using SPSS and Microsoft Excel.
Datasets
The primary dataset for this study was the collection of BSS-related articles retrieved from the PubMed database. No new datasets or benchmarks were introduced.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Dominance of Chinese Research: The vast majority of BSS research originates from China, highlighting a strong national focus but also suggesting a potential for broader international collaboration.
- Growing but Fragmented Field: While the quantity and quality of BSS research have increased, the field is hampered by a lack of standardized diagnostic criteria, making it difficult to compare studies and draw definitive conclusions.
- Coronary Heart Disease (CHD) Focus: Cardiovascular diseases, particularly CHD, are the most frequently studied conditions in relation to BSS, reflecting its perceived importance in these ailments.
- Shift in Intervention Research: There's a notable trend towards patent medicines in intervention studies, while research on herbal formulas, though still significant, appears to be shrinking proportionally.
- Limited Academic Influence: Despite the growing volume of publications, the academic influence (measured by citations and h-index) remains relatively low, suggesting a need to target higher-impact journals and improve research rigor.
Key Results
- Publication Trends: A total of 155 BSS-related articles were included. Publications showed a significant increase from 2009, peaking between 2012 and 2014.
- Article Types: Original articles constituted the largest proportion (81.94%), followed by reviews (14.19%).
- Geographic Distribution: 92.9% of articles were authored by researchers in China.
- Disease Categories: Coronary heart disease (CHD) was the most studied condition (29.68%), followed by cancer/tumor (8.39%) and stroke (5.16%). A significant portion (72.26%) did not specify a particular disease.
- Interventions: Patent medicines and herbal formulas were the most common interventions studied.
- Academic Influence: The average citations per article were 4.65 (WOS), 5.29 (Scopus), and 8.66 (Google Scholar). The average h-index was 1.39, with only 27.74% of articles having an h-index of 2 or higher.
- Diagnostic Criteria: A significant number of articles (38%) did not specify diagnostic criteria. Among those that did, there were 27 different criteria for human studies and 11 for animal/cell models, highlighting considerable inconsistency.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Date Range: The study focused on articles published between 1989 and 2015, as it aimed to capture modern research under validated diagnostic criteria.
- Language Bias: Only English-language articles were included, potentially overlooking a large body of research published in Chinese (e.g., from CNKI).
- Inconsistent Criteria: The inherent inconsistency in diagnostic criteria across studies, even within the defined period, weakens the findings.
Future work should focus on:
- International Collaboration: Increasing cooperation between countries and disciplines to broaden the scope and impact of BSS research.
- Standardized Criteria: Developing and validating uniform, internationally accepted diagnostic criteria for BSS.
- Biomarker Identification: Identifying objective biomarkers to support BSS diagnosis and subtype classification.
- Methodological Rigor: Employing more objective, scientific, and advanced technologies in clinical and experimental studies.
- Clinical Relevance: Evaluating the efficacy and safety of existing treatments and developing new ones for BSS.
- Broader Publication Strategy: Encouraging researchers to publish in higher-impact, mainstream journals to increase visibility and academic influence.
- Comparative Analysis: Conducting a future study comparing English-language publications with those from Chinese databases like CNKI.
Summary updated