Modeling Complex Dialogue Mappings via Sentence Semantic Segmentation Guided Conditional Variational Auto-Encoder

Bin Sun, Shaoxiong Feng, Yiwei Li, Weichao Wang, Fei Mi, Yitong Li, Kan Li

Abstract

Open-domain dialogue systems often struggle with "Complex Dialogue Mappings" (CDM), where a single context may correspond to multiple valid responses (one-to-many) or diverse contexts may converge on a single generic response (many-to-one). This paper presents SegCVAE, a novel framework that leverages sentence semantic segmentation to guide a Conditional Variational Auto-Encoder (CVAE). By decomposing contexts into multiple "prominent semantics," SegCVAE effectively models these complex relationships, leading to more diverse and coherent dialogue generation compared to traditional sequence-to-sequence models.

Addressing Complex Dialogue Mappings

In natural human conversation, the relationship between a prompt and its response is rarely a simple one-to-one mapping. Real-world data is characterized by two types of Complex Dialogue Mappings (CDM):

  1. One-to-Many (O2M): A single context (e.g., "Good morning") can lead to various valid responses. Standard models often fail to capture this variety, resulting in incoherent outputs.
  2. Many-to-One (M2O): Multiple distinct contexts are frequently paired with generic responses (e.g., "I don't know"). This bias encourages models to produce "dull" and uninformative replies.
Conceptual diagram of One-to-Many and Many-to-One mappings and the proposed semantic segmentation approach.

While previous research often treated CDM as noise to be filtered, this work argues that these mappings contain rich semantic information. SegCVAE treats CDM as a feature by segmenting the input context into distinct semantic components, allowing the model to anchor responses to specific "prominent semantics."

The SegCVAE Framework

The core of the proposed method is Sentence Semantic Segmentation guided CVAE (SegCVAE). Instead of encoding the context into a single monolithic vector, the model identifies and extracts multiple influential semantic segments.

Key Components

  • Internal Separation (IS): Utilizes convolution layers and the Gumbel Softmax trick to identify specific, influential words within the input context.
  • External Guidance (EG): Leverages the broader vocabulary to find "instructive" words that align with the context's intent, bridging the gap between the explicit input and potential response directions.
  • Semantic Norms: Three specialized loss functions ensure the utility of the segmented semantics:
  • Semantic Alienation Norm: Encourages diversity by forcing segments to be distinct.
  • Semantic Centralization Norm: Maintains coherence by ensuring the combined segments represent the original context.
  • Semantic Distillation Norm: Uses ground-truth response relationships to guide the interaction between prominent semantics.

Experimental Setup

The model was evaluated on the CornellMovie and Opensubtitles datasets. To specifically analyze the impact of CDM, the authors curated two specialized subsets from Opensubtitles: O2M and M2O. These subsets allow for a controlled evaluation of how well models handle varying degrees of mapping complexity.

Experimental Results

SegCVAE demonstrates significant improvements over vanilla CVAE and other baseline models across both automatic and human evaluation metrics.

Performance metrics (Distinct-3, BLEU, Embedding-Average, and Coherence) across varying ratios of samples with Complex Dialogue Mappings.

Key Findings:

  • Accuracy and Coherence: On the Opensubtitles dataset, SegCVAE achieved a BLEU-3 score of 0.310, a substantial increase over the vanilla CVAE's 0.123.
  • Response Diversity: The model produces significantly longer and more varied responses. In the CornellMovie task, SegCVAE's average response length reached 17.4 words, compared to just 6.8 words for standard Seq2Seq models.
  • Human Evaluation: In "Suitability" and "Erudition" tests, human judges consistently preferred SegCVAE for its ability to handle complex mappings and provide informative responses.

Conclusion and Future Work

SegCVAE successfully transforms the challenge of complex dialogue mappings into a source of semantic richness. By explicitly modeling prominent semantics, the framework achieves state-of-the-art performance in generating diverse and contextually relevant responses.

Future work will address the current limitation of using a fixed number of semantic "triggers," moving toward an adaptive system that can adjust the number of segments based on the semantic density of the input. Additionally, the authors aim to improve the interpretability of the External Guidance module by incorporating structured knowledge graphs.

Summary updated

Abstract

Complex dialogue mappings (CDM), including one-to-many and many-to-one mappings, tend to make dialogue models generate incoherent or dull responses, and modeling these mappings remains a huge challenge for neural dialogue systems. To alleviate these problems, methods like introducing external information, reconstructing the optimization function, and manipulating data samples are proposed, while they primarily focus on avoiding training with CDM, inevitably weakening the model's ability of understanding CDM in human conversations and limiting further improvements in model performance. This paper proposes a Sentence Semantic \textbf{Seg}mentation guided \textbf{C}onditional \textbf{V}ariational \textbf{A}uto-\textbf{E}ncoder (SegCVAE) method which can model and take advantages of the CDM data. Specifically, to tackle the incoherent problem caused by one-to-many, SegCVAE uses response-related prominent semantics to constrained the latent variable. To mitigate the non-diverse problem brought by many-to-one, SegCVAE segments multiple prominent semantics to enrich the latent variables. Three novel components, Internal Separation, External Guidance, and Semantic Norms, are proposed to achieve SegCVAE. On dialogue generation tasks, both the automatic and human evaluation results show that SegCVAE achieves new state-of-the-art performance.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sun2022modeling,
  author = {Bin Sun and Shaoxiong Feng and Yiwei Li and Weichao Wang and Fei Mi and Yitong Li and Kan Li},
  title = {{Modeling Complex Dialogue Mappings via Sentence Semantic Segmentation Guided Conditional Variational Auto-Encoder}},
  booktitle = {Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing},
  year = {2022},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=fVKZ3576uGb},
}
Figure