Modeling and Simulating Biological Processes with Stochastic Multiset Rewriting

Matteo Cavaliere, Sean Sedwards

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel computational model and a corresponding stochastic simulator for biological processes, specifically focusing on cellular functions involving membranes and proteins. The model extends existing membrane systems by incorporating objects attached to membrane surfaces, allowing for more realistic modeling of transport and reactions influenced by these proteins.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Biological cells are complex systems where various processes occur within distinct compartments (like organelles) enclosed by membranes. The movement of molecules across these membranes and their subsequent reactions are crucial for cellular function. Existing computational models, like basic membrane systems, often struggle to accurately represent how proteins embedded in or attached to membranes regulate these transport and reaction events. Specifically, many biological processes, such as receptor-mediated endocytosis or exocytosis, rely on the precise positioning and interaction of proteins on membrane surfaces to control molecular traffic. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a computational framework that explicitly models these membrane-associated proteins and their influence on cellular dynamics.

Methods

The authors extend the concept of membrane systems, which are computational models inspired by cellular structure. Their novel model introduces:

  • Compartments: Regions enclosed by membranes.
  • Floating Objects: Molecules within compartments.
  • Membrane-Attached Objects: Proteins or other molecules bound to the inner or outer surfaces of membranes.
  • Evolution Rules: Multiset rewriting rules that describe biochemical reactions within compartments.
  • Transport Rules: Rules for moving objects across membranes, crucially influenced by the presence of specific membrane-attached objects (proteins).
  • Attachment/Detachment Rules: Rules governing how objects can bind to or unbind from membrane surfaces.

A key innovation is the ability to distinguish between the inner and outer surfaces of a membrane and to associate specific rules with these surfaces. They then present a stochastic simulator of this model. This simulator uses the Gillespie algorithm to model discrete molecular interactions and stochastically determine which rule to apply and its associated time delay. This approach is particularly useful for modeling systems with small numbers of reactants, where deterministic models might be less accurate. The simulator's syntax is inspired by chemical reaction notation.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on a simulation model and its application to a biological process using experimental rates from a cited source.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Modeling Protein-Mediated Transport: The core insight is that membrane-attached proteins are not just passive bystanders but active regulators of molecular transport. The model explicitly captures this by making transport rules dependent on the presence and type of proteins on membrane surfaces.
  • Bridging Membrane Systems and Brane Calculus: The work positions itself as a bridge between membrane systems and brane calculus, incorporating features of both to create a more biologically relevant model.
  • Stochasticity for Biological Realism: The adoption of a stochastic simulation approach (Gillespie algorithm) is crucial for accurately modeling biological systems where molecular counts can be low and random fluctuations are significant.
  • Hierarchical and Surface-Specific Interactions: The model allows for hierarchical compartment structures and, importantly, differentiates interactions occurring on the inner versus outer membrane surfaces, reflecting biological reality.

Key Results

The paper presents a simulator that can model biological processes involving compartments, surface and integral membrane proteins, and the transport/processing of chemical substances. As a demonstration, they simulate the G-protein mating response in yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) using experimental rates from [14]. Figure 3 shows the simulation results (continuous curves) compared to experimental data (points with error bars), indicating the model's ability to capture the dynamics of this complex biological pathway.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their current simulator implements a sequential version of the model, whereas the underlying theoretical model allows for maximal parallel semantics. They suggest several future research directions:

  • Maximal Parallel Semantics: Developing simulators that support parallel rule application, similar to standard P systems. This might lead to challenges in decidability for certain properties.
  • Subclasses for Decidability: Investigating subclasses of rules or system configurations that retain decidable properties, even with parallel semantics.
  • Bio-Inspired Operations: Incorporating additional biological operations like fission and fusion of membrane regions.
  • Application to Other Processes: Applying the simulator to other interesting biological processes where surface proteins and transport are critical, such as drug resistance mechanisms.
  • Further Model Development: Exploring extensions to the model, potentially incorporating more complex protein interactions or membrane dynamics.

Summary updated

Abstract

Membrane systems were originally introduced as models of computation inspired by the structure and the functioning of living cells. More recently, membrane systems have been shown to be suitable also to model cellular processes. Inspired by brane calculi, a new model of membrane system with peripheral proteins has been recently introduced. Such model has compartments (enclosed by membranes), floating objects, and objects attached to the internal and external surfaces of the membranes. The objects can be processed/transported inside/across the compartments and the transport is regulated by opportune objects attached to the membranes surfaces. We present a stochastic simulator of this model, with a style of syntax based on chemical reactions. We show that the simulator can be particularly useful in modelling biological processes that involve compartments, surface and integral membrane proteins, transport and processing of chemical substances. As examples we present the simulation of circadian clock and the G-protein cycle in yeast.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cavaliere2006modeling,
  author = {Matteo Cavaliere and Sean Sedwards},
  title = {{Modeling and Simulating Biological Processes with Stochastic Multiset Rewriting}},
  booktitle = {Simulation and Verification of Dynamic Systems},
  year = {2006},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=14tCRiKSifAV},
}
Figure