Modeling and Control of an Omnidirectional Micro Aerial Vehicle Equipped with a Soft Robotic Arm

Róbert Szász, Mike Allenspach, Minghao Han, Marco Tognon, Robert K. Katzschmann

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel unified modeling and control framework for a flying manipulator composed of an omnidirectional micro aerial vehicle (OMAV) and a soft robotic arm. By combining the maneuverability of the OMAV with the inherent compliance and safety of a soft arm, this system aims to overcome the limitations of traditional rigid aerial manipulators, opening up new possibilities for human-robot interaction and complex aerial tasks.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Aerial manipulators, essentially drones with robotic arms, are a rapidly advancing area of robotics, promising to extend robotic capabilities into 3D space for tasks like construction, delivery, and maintenance. However, existing systems often use rigid robotic arms, which lack the compliance and inherent safety needed for close human collaboration or interaction with delicate environments. Furthermore, traditional aerial platforms like quadcopters are often underactuated, complicating control when an arm is attached. This paper addresses the challenge of integrating a soft robotic arm with a highly maneuverable omnidirectional aerial vehicle (OMAV) to create a more versatile, compliant, and safer flying manipulator. The core problem is developing a unified model and a control strategy that can effectively manage the complex dynamics of this combined system.

Methods

The authors propose a unified modeling approach that combines three key principles:

  • Piecewise Constant Curvature (PCC) and Augmented Rigid Body Model (ARBM): These hypotheses are used to model the soft continuum robotic arm. PCC approximates the arm's segments as having constant bending curvature, while ARBM augments a rigid-body model to better capture the dynamics of these compliant segments, including the off-center mass.
  • Floating-Base Approach: This standard technique from rigid-body robotics is adapted to model the OMAV as a dynamic base for the soft arm.
  • Hierarchical Task-Prioritizing Controller: A model-based feedback controller is designed to manage the coupled system. It prioritizes tasks, starting with end-effector orientation, then end-effector position, and finally OMAV orientation. Crucially, it leverages nullspace projection to allow lower-priority tasks (like OMAV orientation changes) to be executed without interfering with higher-priority tasks (like maintaining end-effector position and orientation). This ensures that the system can perform complex maneuvers while maintaining precise control over the end-effector.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The evaluation is performed entirely in simulation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergy of Softness and Omnidirectionality: The paper highlights how combining a soft arm with an OMAV creates a system that is both dynamically capable (due to the OMAV) and inherently safe and compliant (due to the soft arm). This is a significant step towards robots that can safely operate alongside humans.
  • Unified Modeling for Hybrid Systems: The successful integration of PCC/ARBM for the soft arm with a floating-base model for the OMAV demonstrates a viable path for modeling complex hybrid robotic systems.
  • Hierarchical Control with Nullspace Exploitation: The proposed controller effectively manages multiple, potentially conflicting, objectives by prioritizing tasks and using nullspace projection. This allows for sophisticated behaviors, such as the OMAV actively reorienting itself while the end-effector remains precisely controlled.
  • Bridging Rigid and Soft Robotics Paradigms: The approach of using ARBM to represent soft arm dynamics allows for the application of established rigid-body control techniques, simplifying the development of controllers for soft robotic systems.

Key Results

The paper presents simulation results demonstrating the effectiveness of the proposed model and controller:

  • Nullspace Motion Exploitation: The system successfully maintained a stable end-effector position and orientation while the OMAV continuously changed its own orientation, showcasing the controller's ability to utilize the system's redundant degrees of freedom.
  • Disturbance Recovery: The coupled system demonstrated fast and accurate recovery from external force disturbances applied to both the OMAV and the end-effector, with minimal overshoot.
  • Dynamic Trajectory Tracking: The end-effector was able to follow a circular trajectory with a specified orientation. While a small position tracking error (mean L2 norm of 0.043m) was observed, the system maintained stability and compliance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simulation-Based Evaluation: The authors acknowledge that all experiments were conducted in simulation. The next crucial step is to validate the proposed model and controller on a real-world physical system.
  • Potential for Micro Oscillations: High gains in the controller can lead to micro oscillation effects, which the authors plan to address in future work.
  • Future Applications: The authors envision future work including experiments with an additional gripper for basic transport tasks and further investigation into micro oscillation effects. They also suggest exploring curvature space or hybrid control for more advanced scenarios.
  • Model Complexity: The paper notes that increasing the fidelity of the soft arm model (e.g., by using more PCC elements per actuated segment) leads to higher computational demands, a common trade-off in soft robotics.

Summary updated

Abstract

Flying manipulators are aerial drones with attached rigid-bodied robotic arms and belong to the latest and most actively developed research areas in robotics. The rigid nature of these arms often lack compliance, flexibility, and smoothness in movement. This work proposes to use a soft-bodied robotic arm attached to an omnidirectional micro aerial vehicle (OMAV) to leverage the compliant and flexible behavior of the arm, while remaining maneuverable and dynamic thanks to the omnidirectional drone as the floating base. The unification of the arm with the drone poses challenges in the modeling and control of such a combined platform; these challenges are addressed with this work. We propose a unified model for the flying manipulator based on three modeling principles: the Piecewise Constant Curvature (PCC) and Augmented Rigid Body Model (ARBM) hypotheses for modeling soft continuum robots and a floating-base approach borrowed from the traditional rigid-body robotics literature. To demonstrate the validity and usefulness of this parametrisation, a hierarchical model-based feedback controller is implemented. The controller is verified and evaluated in simulation on various dynamical tasks, where the nullspace motions, disturbance recovery, and trajectory tracking capabilities of the platform are examined and validated. The soft flying manipulator platform could open new application fields in aerial construction, goods delivery, human assistance, maintenance, and warehouse automation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{szasz2022modeling,
  author = {Róbert Szász and Mike Allenspach and Minghao Han and Marco Tognon and Robert K. Katzschmann},
  title = {{Modeling and Control of an Omnidirectional Micro Aerial Vehicle Equipped with a Soft Robotic Arm}},
  booktitle = {RoboSoft},
  year = {2022},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=Nb9MzjenVF},
}
Figure