Analysis of Data Harvesting by Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Chang-Sik Choi, François Baccelli, Gustavo de Veciana

Abstract: This paper explores an emerging wireless Internet-of-things (IoT) architecture based on unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs). We consider a network where a fleet of UAVs at a fixed altitude flies on planned trajectories and IoT devices on the ground are scheduled to transmit their data to the UAVs when the latter are nearby. In such a system, the UAVs' motion triggers the uplink transmissions of the IoT devices. As a result, network performance is determined by the geometric and dynamic characteristics of the system. We propose a joint stationary model for UAVs and IoT devices and then evaluate the interference, the coverage probability, and the data rate of the typical UAV. To assess the harvesting capability of the proposed architecture, we derive a formula for the amount of data uploaded from each IoT device to a UAV. We also establish a linear relationship between the UAV coverage and the harvesting capability of the network, which provides insights into the design of the proposed harvesting scheme. In addition, we use our analytical results to numerically show that there exists a trade-off between the uploaded data and the size of the IoT scheduling window. Specifically, for a given UAV and IoT geometry, there exists an optimal scheduling window that maximizes the harvesting capability of the proposed network.

Introduction

As the Internet of Things (IoT) continues to expand, monitoring remote or rural areas—such as agricultural fields or seismic zones—presents a significant infrastructure challenge. Deploying fixed cell towers in low-density regions is often cost-prohibitive, and ground-based mobile harvesters are limited by existing road networks. Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) offer a flexible, cost-effective alternative for data harvesting. However, UAV-based networks introduce a unique "dynamic interference" problem: the movement of the drone itself triggers ground devices to transmit, creating a shifting interference environment. This paper provides a rigorous mathematical framework to model movement-triggered interference and optimize the "activation window" for maximum data collection efficiency.

System Model and Methodology

The researchers utilize Stochastic Geometry to model the random spatial patterns of the network. IoT devices are modeled as a stationary Poisson Point Process (PPP) on the ground, while UAVs are represented as a "shifted comb process"—a line of drones flying at a fixed altitude with constant spacing and velocity.

Top-down view of the UAV harvesting system showing the activation window and device triggering as the UAV moves from t=0 to t=60.

A central component of this architecture is the Activation Window. Each UAV manages a rectangular window on the ground; as the drone passes over, it uses Time-Division Multiple Access (TDMA) to schedule transmissions from the devices currently within that window. To analyze this complex moving system, the authors employ Palm Calculus and the Mass Transport Principle, allowing them to link the instantaneous data rate of a drone to the total data harvested from a single sensor over time.

Key Insights: The "Goldilocks" Window

A critical finding of the study is the existence of an optimal activation window size ($w$). The system performance is governed by a trade-off:

  • Small Windows: If the window is too small, the UAV frequently flies over empty areas, wasting harvesting opportunities.
  • Large Windows: If the window is too large, the UAV attempts to communicate with distant devices (resulting in weak signals) while simultaneously experiencing higher interference from other active windows.

Surprisingly, despite the constant motion, the statistical distribution of interference remains time-invariant due to the joint stationarity of the drone and sensor positions. This allows for the derivation of exact formulas for the Signal-to-Interference Ratio (SIR) coverage probability and mean data rate.

Results and Performance Analysis

Numerical simulations validated the analytical models, confirming that the system is primarily "interference-limited," meaning thermal noise is negligible compared to signals from neighboring active IoT windows.

Typical data rate as a function of the SIR threshold for various activation window widths (w), illustrating the performance trade-offs.

As shown in the performance analysis, there is a clear relationship between device density and the optimal window size. As the density of IoT devices increases, the optimal activation window size must decrease to mitigate rising interference. For instance, at a density of 30 devices/km², the optimal window is approximately 40% of the distance between drones. Furthermore, the study highlights that moving drones provide "universal" coverage over time; even a small activation window will eventually pass over every ground device.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While this framework provides a robust foundation for UAV data harvesting, several areas remain for future exploration. The current model assumes straight-line trajectories and basic fading models. Real-world deployments must account for complex Air-to-Ground (A2G) effects like urban shadowing, energy constraints of both UAVs and IoT devices, and more sophisticated flight paths such as hovering over high-demand zones.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper explores an emerging wireless Internet-of-things (IoT) architecture based on unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs). We consider a network where a fleet of UAVs at a fixed altitude flies on planned trajectories and IoT devices on the ground are scheduled to transmit their data to the UAVs when the latter are nearby. In such a system, the UAVs' motion triggers the uplink transmissions of the IoT devices. As a result, network performance is determined by the geometric and dynamic characteristics of the system. We propose a joint stationary model for UAVs and IoT devices and then evaluate the interference, the coverage probability, and the data rate of the typical UAV. To assess the harvesting capability of the proposed architecture, we derive a formula for the amount of data uploaded from each IoT device to a UAV. We also establish a linear relationship between the UAV coverage and the harvesting capability of the network, which provides insights into the design of the proposed harvesting scheme. In addition, we use our analytical results to numerically show that there exists a trade-off between the uploaded data and the size of the IoT scheduling window. Specifically, for a given UAV and IoT geometry, there exists an optimal scheduling window that maximizes the harvesting capability of the proposed network.
BibTeX
@article{choi2019analysis,
  author = {Chang-Sik Choi and François Baccelli and Gustavo de Veciana},
  title = {{Analysis of Data Harvesting by Unmanned Aerial Vehicles}},
  journal = {IEEE Transactions on Wireless Communications},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1109/twc.2019.2958807},
}
Figure