Modèle de langue pour l'ordonnancement conjoint d'entités pertinentes dans un réseau d'informations hétérogènes .

Laure Soulier, Lamjed Ben Jabeur, Lynda Tamine, Wahiba Bahsoun

TL;DR

This paper introduces BibRank, a novel model for jointly ranking authors and documents in bibliographic networks based on their relevance to a query. BibRank leverages both the network structure and thematic relevance, outperforming existing methods by integrating these factors more effectively.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the vast landscape of academic literature, finding the most relevant documents and influential authors for a specific research query can be challenging. Traditional search methods often treat documents and authors as separate entities, failing to capture the rich interdependencies within a bibliographic network. This paper addresses the problem of co-ranking heterogeneous entities (documents and authors) within such networks, aiming to provide a more comprehensive and accurate ranking that considers both the thematic content of the information and the underlying network structure. The challenge lies in effectively combining these diverse signals to produce a unified ranking.

Methods

The core of the BibRank model is a score propagation algorithm, inspired by PageRank, that iteratively updates the relevance scores of both documents and authors. Key novelties include:

  • Integrated Approach: Unlike modular approaches that handle different factors separately, BibRank unifies the consideration of query relevance, network structure, and thematic proximity into a single process.
  • Thematic Proximity Indicators: BibRank introduces two novel indicators to estimate the topical relatedness between connected entities:
  • Document Representativeness (ProxSem(di|aj)): This measures how well a document aligns with an author's expertise, using language models to connect document topics with author profiles.
  • Author Expertise (ProxSem(aj|di)): This assesses an author's expertise in relation to a document's subject matter, again leveraging language models.
  • Marginal Citation Detection: The model aims to filter out less significant citations by comparing the ranks of connected entities based on their relevance to the query.
  • Transition Probabilities: Similar to PageRank, BibRank models user navigation within the bibliographic graph using transition probabilities between document and author sub-graphs.

Datasets

The authors evaluated their model on the CiteSeerX bibliographic collection. This dataset was chosen for its multidisciplinary nature and was downloaded via a web application in April 2011. The collection includes document titles, abstracts, author lists, and citation links. Citation links between authors were inferred by exact name matching.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergy of Structure and Content: The paper strongly suggests that effectively ranking entities in a bibliographic network requires a synergistic approach that combines thematic relevance (what the document/author is about) with network structure (how entities are connected). Neither factor alone is sufficient.
  • Author-Document Interdependence: BibRank's success highlights the importance of modeling the mutual reinforcement between authors and documents. An important document is likely cited by important authors, and vice-versa.
  • Language Models for Expertise: The use of language models to estimate author expertise and document representativeness is a powerful way to bridge the gap between textual content and network relationships.
  • Beyond Simple Citations: The model's ability to go beyond simple citation counts and consider thematic relevance and author expertise offers a more nuanced understanding of influence and importance.

Key Results

BibRank demonstrated significant improvements in ranking both documents and authors compared to three baseline models: BM25 (a probabilistic model), Language Model (LM) Hiemstra, and PRank (a heterogeneous network ranking model).

  • Document Ranking: BibRank achieved a higher NDCG@20 score (0.686) than BM25 (0.429), LM (0.322), and PRank (0.641). The percentage increase over these models was substantial, ranging from 7.03% to 113.13%.
  • Author Ranking: BibRank also outperformed the baselines in author ranking, with an NDCG@20 score of 0.520 compared to BM25 (0.376), LM (0.428), and PRank (0.455). The percentage increases ranged from 14.29% to 38.26%.
  • Qualitative Findings: The paper notes that BibRank is particularly effective in placing the most relevant documents within the top 5 results. The authors also observed that author ranking generally yielded lower NDCG scores than document ranking, which they attribute to the fact that author relevance judgments were derived from document judgments rather than direct human evaluation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The authors acknowledge that author relevance judgments are derived from document judgments, which might introduce a bias.
  • The study focuses on a specific type of heterogeneous network (bibliographic).
  • Future Work:
    • Extension to More Entity Types: The authors plan to extend BibRank to include more entity types in bibliographic networks, such as conferences and scientific institutions, and more relation types like co-authorship or affiliation.
  • Application to Social Networks: A medium-term goal is to apply the model to social networks, incorporating temporal and social factors to define entity importance beyond citation links, potentially considering average authority since publication or social distance.

Summary updated

Abstract

National audience
BibTeX
@inproceedings{soulier2012modele,
  author = {Laure Soulier and Lamjed Ben Jabeur and Lynda Tamine and Wahiba Bahsoun},
  title = {{Modèle de langue pour l'ordonnancement conjoint d'entités pertinentes dans un réseau d'informations hétérogènes .}},
  booktitle = {INFORSID},
  year = {2012},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=7U63GaY2Ko},
}

Loading related content...

Figure