Model selection for maternal hypertensive disorders with symmetric hierarchical Dirichlet processes

Beatrice Franzolini, Antonio Lijoi, Igor Prünster

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel Bayesian nonparametric model, the symmetric hierarchical Dirichlet process (s-HDP), to analyze complex relationships between maternal hypertensive disorders and cardiac function. The model effectively identifies how different stages of these disorders impact cardiac health, revealing subtle alterations and enabling patient clustering for better understanding.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Hypertensive disorders during pregnancy, like preeclampsia, affect about 10% of expectant mothers and are a leading cause of maternal and fetal complications. While it's known that these conditions can impact maternal cardiac function, the precise nature and progression of these effects, especially across different severities of hypertension, remain poorly understood. Existing statistical methods often struggle with analyzing multiple related health indicators (cardiac function indexes) across distinct patient groups (different hypertensive disorders) simultaneously, especially when dealing with limited sample sizes. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a flexible statistical framework that can model these complex relationships, perform model selection to identify which cardiac functions are affected by which disorders, and uncover hidden patient subgroups.

Methods

The core of this work is the development of a symmetric hierarchical Dirichlet process (s-HDP). This is a Bayesian nonparametric approach, meaning it doesn't assume a fixed number of clusters or specific distributional shapes beforehand, allowing for greater flexibility.

Here's a breakdown of the key methodological contributions:

  • Hierarchical Structure: The model uses a hierarchical structure to simultaneously model disease-specific effects (how each hypertensive disorder impacts cardiac function) and individual patient variations.
  • Symmetric Dirichlet Process: A novel "symmetric" version of the Dirichlet process is introduced for the error terms. This ensures that the model can identify distinct patient clusters even after accounting for the main disease effects, and it's designed to handle the symmetry often observed in statistical distributions.
  • Model Selection: The framework is designed for "model selection," meaning it can determine which cardiac function indexes are significantly altered by different hypertensive disorders. This is achieved by using the model to identify partitions (groupings) of the disorders that share similar cardiac function profiles.
  • Penalization for Multiplicity: The Bayesian approach inherently handles the challenge of testing multiple cardiac indexes simultaneously, effectively penalizing for the increased chance of finding spurious associations.
  • Latent Clustering: The model can identify "latent clusters" of patients, suggesting the presence of unobserved factors (like pre-existing conditions or lifestyle) that influence cardiac function beyond the diagnosed hypertensive disorder.
  • Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC): Posterior inference (estimating model parameters and probabilities) is performed using MCMC algorithms, a standard computational technique in Bayesian statistics.

Datasets

The primary dataset used for evaluation is:

  • Transthoracic echocardiography results from a cohort of Indian pregnant women: This dataset includes measurements of ten different cardiac function indexes for women categorized into four groups: healthy (C), gestational hypertension (G), mild preeclampsia (M), and severe preeclampsia (S). This dataset is publicly available from Mendeley.

The paper also utilizes simulated data to test the model's performance under various scenarios, including different data-generating processes and the presence of outliers.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Simple Shifts: The model goes beyond simply detecting shifts in average cardiac function across disorders. It can identify more complex distributional changes and uncover underlying patient subgroups that might be missed by simpler models.
  • Ordered Severity Matters: The model's design naturally incorporates the ordered severity of hypertensive disorders (C < G < M < S), which is crucial for understanding the progressive impact on cardiac health.
  • Unobserved Factors Influence Cardiac Health: The latent clustering capability highlights that factors beyond the diagnosed hypertensive disorder play a significant role in maternal cardiac function. This opens avenues for personalized risk assessment.
  • Model Selection as a Feature: The ability to perform model selection directly within the Bayesian framework is a powerful tool for identifying which cardiac functions are most affected by specific disorders, rather than relying on separate hypothesis tests for each function.

Key Results

  • Identification of Altered Cardiac Functions: The model successfully identified specific cardiac function indexes that are modified in hypertensive patients compared to healthy subjects.
  • Progressive Alterations with Severity: The analysis revealed a progressive increase in cardiac alterations with the increasing severity of hypertensive disorders. For example, the cardiac index was found to be reduced in severe preeclampsia, and left ventricular mass index (LVMI) was increased.
  • Distinguishing Disorders: The model could differentiate between the effects of different hypertensive disorders on cardiac function, providing nuanced insights into their impact.
  • Effective Patient Clustering: The s-HDP model demonstrated strong performance in simulation studies, accurately identifying true partitions and clusters, even with small sample sizes, outperforming existing methods like the Nested Dirichlet Process (NDP).
  • Robustness: The model showed robustness to different prior specifications and deviations from symmetry in the data-generating process.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Cost: Bayesian nonparametric models, especially those involving MCMC, can be computationally intensive, which might limit their application to very large datasets without further optimization.
  • Prior Specification: While the model is shown to be robust to some prior choices, careful consideration of prior specifications is still important for optimal performance.
  • Generalizations: The authors suggest several promising avenues for future work:
  • Extending the model to accommodate other types of invariances for generalized linear models (e.g., count data with log links).
  • Exploring other types of stochastic processes beyond the Dirichlet process.
  • Investigating the model's applicability to other domains where clustering populations based on multivariate information is relevant.

Summary updated

Abstract

Hypertensive disorders of pregnancy occur in about 10% of pregnant women around the world. Though there is evidence that hypertension impacts maternal cardiac functions, the relation between hypertension and cardiac dysfunctions is only partially understood. The study of this relationship can be framed as a joint inferential problem on multiple populations, each corresponding to a different hypertensive disorder diagnosis, that combines multivariate information provided by a collection of cardiac function indexes. A Bayesian nonparametric approach seems particularly suited for this setup, and we demonstrate it on a dataset consisting of transthoracic echocardiography results of a cohort of Indian pregnant women. We are able to perform model selection, provide density estimates of cardiac function indexes and a latent clustering of patients: these readily interpretable inferential outputs allow to single out modified cardiac functions in hypertensive patients, compared to healthy subjects, and progressively increased alterations with the severity of the disorder. The analysis is based on a Bayesian nonparametric model that relies on a novel hierarchical structure, called symmetric hierarchical Dirichlet process. This is suitably designed so that the mean parameters are identified and used for model selection across populations, a penalization for multiplicity is enforced, and the presence of unobserved relevant factors is investigated through a latent clustering of subjects. Posterior inference relies on a suitable Markov chain Monte Carlo algorithm, and the model behaviour is also showcased on simulated data.
BibTeX
@article{franzolini2023model,
  author = {Beatrice Franzolini and Antonio Lijoi and Igor Prünster},
  title = {{Model selection for maternal hypertensive disorders with symmetric hierarchical Dirichlet processes}},
  journal = {The Annals of Applied Statistics},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1214/22-aoas1628},
}
Figure