Model-independent Approach of the JUNO 8B Solar Neutrino Program
J. Y. Zhao, Baobiao Yue, Haoqi Lu, Yufeng Li, Jiajie Ling, Zeyuan Yu, Angel Abusleme, Thomas Adam, S. Ahmad, Rizwan Ahmed, S. Aiello, Muhammad Akram, Abid Aleem, Tsagkarakis Alexandros, Fengpeng An, Qi An, Giuseppe Andronico, Н. Анфимов, V. Antonelli, Tatiana Antoshkina, Burin Asavapibhop, J. P. A. M. de André, Didier Auguste, Weidong Bai, Nikita Balashov, W. Baldini, Andrea Barresi, D. Basilico, E. Baussan, Marco Bellato, Antonio Bergnoli, Thilo Birkenfeld, Sylvie Blin, David Blum, S.c. Blyth, Anastasia Bolshakova, M. Bongrand, Clément Bordereau, D. Breton, A. Brigatti, R. Brugnera, Riccardo Bruno, A. Budano, José Busto, Ilya Butorov, A. Cabrera, Barbara Caccianiga, Hao Cai, X. Cai, Yanke Cai, Zhiyan Cai, Riccardo Callegari, Antonio Cammi, Agustín Campeny, Chuanya Cao, G. F. Cao, Jun Cao, R. Caruso, C. Cerna, Chi Kuen Chan, J. F. Chang, Yun Chang, Guo-Ming Chen, Pingping Chen, Po-An Chen, Shaomin Chen, Xurong Chen, Yixue Chen, Yu Chen, Zhiyuan Chen, Zikang Chen, Jie Cheng, Yaping Cheng, Alexander Chepurnov, Alexey Chetverikov, D. Chiesa, P. Chimenti, A. Chukanov, Gérard Claverie, Catia Clementi, Barbara Clerbaux, Marta Colomer Molla, Selma Conforti Di Lorenzo, Daniele Corti, F. Dal Corso, Olivia Dalager, C. De La Taille, Zhi Deng, Wilfried Depnering, M. A. Díaz, Xuefeng Ding, Yayun Ding, Bayu Dirgantara, Sergey Dmitrievsky, Tadeáš Dohnal, Dmitry Dolzhikov, Georgy Donchenko, J. Dong, E. Doroshkevich
This paper explores how the upcoming Jiangmen Underground Neutrino Observatory (JUNO) can make a model-independent measurement of the <sup>8</sup>B solar neutrino flux and oscillation parameters. By leveraging three distinct detection channels (charged-current, neutral-current, and elastic scattering) and JUNO's large detector mass and low background, the experiment is poised to achieve unprecedented precision, offering crucial insights into both solar and neutrino physics.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
For decades, scientists have been trying to understand the "solar neutrino problem" – the discrepancy between the predicted and observed flux of neutrinos from the Sun. While the discovery of neutrino oscillations explained this by showing neutrinos change flavor, precisely measuring the fundamental parameters governing these oscillations and the solar neutrino flux remains a key goal. Specifically, this paper addresses the need for a model-independent measurement of the <sup>8</sup>B solar neutrino flux. Current measurements, while precise, rely on assumptions about solar models and neutrino oscillation parameters. A model-independent approach, using multiple detection channels, is crucial for resolving remaining ambiguities, particularly concerning the solar abundance problem and potential new physics beyond the Standard Model.
Methods
The authors propose using three distinct interaction channels within JUNO's liquid scintillator detector to detect <sup>8</sup>B solar neutrinos:
Charged-Current (CC) interaction: This channel is sensitive to electron neutrinos ($\nu_e$) interacting with <sup>13</sup>C nuclei. A unique feature is the detection of a prompt electron and a delayed positron from the decay of the daughter <sup>13</sup>N nucleus, providing a distinctive coincidence signature.
Neutral-Current (NC) interaction: This channel is sensitive to all neutrino flavors ($\nu_e, \nu_\mu, \nu_\tau$) interacting with <sup>13</sup>C. The signature is a mono-energetic gamma ray from the de-excitation of the daughter <sup>12</sup>C nucleus.
Elastic Scattering (ES) interaction: This channel is sensitive to all neutrino flavors scattering off electrons. The signature is a single recoiled electron.
The paper details sophisticated event selection strategies and background suppression techniques, including time, vertex, and muon vetoes, to achieve excellent signal-to-background ratios. They also consider the day-night asymmetry, which arises from neutrino regeneration within the Earth, as an additional observable for constraining oscillation parameters.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on simulated data and expected event rates based on established solar neutrino flux models and neutrino oscillation parameters.
Key Insights and Ideas
<sup>13</sup>C as a unique target: JUNO's large mass of <sup>13</sup>C nuclei is a key advantage, enabling the observation of <sup>8</sup>B solar neutrinos via CC and NC interactions for the first time with such a large detector. This opens up new avenues for model-independent measurements.
Synergy of multiple channels: Combining CC, NC, and ES channels is crucial for a model-independent determination of the <sup>8</sup>B solar neutrino flux and oscillation parameters. Each channel probes different aspects and has complementary sensitivities.
Low background is paramount: The success of this program hinges on JUNO's expected low background environment, which allows for the suppression of various sources like natural radioactivity and muon-induced isotopes.
Day-night asymmetry as a probe: The day-night asymmetry, though subtle, provides an independent handle on neutrino oscillation parameters, particularly sensitive to matter effects.
Key Results
The study predicts that JUNO, with 10 years of data, can achieve the following precisions at 1σ:
<sup>8</sup>B neutrino flux: 5%
sin<sup>2</sup>θ<sub>12</sub>: 8%
Δm<sup>2</sup><sub>21</sub>: 20%
When combined with existing data from the Sudbury Neutrino Observatory (SNO), the precision on the <sup>8</sup>B neutrino flux is expected to improve to a world-leading 3%. The NC measurement alone is expected to yield a 10.6% uncertainty on the <sup>8</sup>B flux, comparable to SNO's NC measurement.
Limitations and Future Work
Systematic uncertainties: The precision of the results is sensitive to uncertainties in detection efficiency, cross-sections, and background estimations. The paper acknowledges these and incorporates them into the analysis. Future work could focus on further reducing these uncertainties.
<sup>8</sup>B spectral shape: While the paper uses the Bahcall spectrum, any deviation from this predicted spectral shape could impact the results.
Hep neutrinos: The hep neutrino signal is too small to be detected with the proposed methods, limiting the scope of the measurement to <sup>8</sup>B neutrinos.
Future directions: The authors suggest that these measurements will be crucial for testing CPT symmetry and resolving potential discrepancies between neutrino and antineutrino oscillation parameters. The combination of JUNO data with SNO data is highlighted as a path to achieving the best possible precision.
Summary updated
Abstract
Abstract The physics potential of detecting 8 B solar neutrinos will be exploited at the Jiangmen Underground Neutrino Observatory (JUNO), in a model-independent manner by using three distinct channels of the charged current (CC), neutral current (NC), and elastic scattering (ES) interactions. Due to the largest-ever mass of 13 C nuclei in the liquid scintillator detectors and the expected low background level, 8 B solar neutrinos are observable in the CC and NC interactions on 13 C for the first time. By virtue of optimized event selections and muon veto strategies, backgrounds from the accidental coincidence, muon-induced isotopes, and external backgrounds can be greatly suppressed. Excellent signal-to-background ratios can be achieved in the CC, NC, and ES channels to guarantee the observation of the 8 B solar neutrinos. From the sensitivity studies performed in this work, we show that JUNO, with 10 yr of data, can reach the 1 σ precision levels of 5%, 8%, and 20% for the 8 B neutrino flux, <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" overflow="scroll"> <mml:msup> <mml:mrow> <mml:mi>sin</mml:mi> </mml:mrow> <mml:mrow> <mml:mn>2</mml:mn> </mml:mrow> </mml:msup> <mml:msub> <mml:mrow> <mml:mi>θ</mml:mi> </mml:mrow> <mml:mrow> <mml:mn>12</mml:mn> </mml:mrow> </mml:msub> </mml:math> , and <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" overflow="scroll"> <mml:mi mathvariant="normal">Δ</mml:mi> <mml:msubsup> <mml:mrow> <mml:mi>m</mml:mi> </mml:mrow> <mml:mrow> <mml:mn>21</mml:mn> </mml:mrow> <mml:mrow> <mml:mn>2</mml:mn> </mml:mrow> </mml:msubsup> </mml:math> , respectively. Probing the details of both solar physics and neutrino physics would be unique and helpful. In addition, when combined with the Sudbury Neutrino Observatory measurement, the world's best precision of 3% is expected for the measurement of the 8 B neutrino flux.
BibTeX
@article{zhao2024model,
author = {J. Y. Zhao and Baobiao Yue and Haoqi Lu and Yufeng Li and Jiajie Ling and Zeyuan Yu and Angel Abusleme and Thomas Adam and S. Ahmad and Rizwan Ahmed and S. Aiello and Muhammad Akram and Abid Aleem and Tsagkarakis Alexandros and Fengpeng An and Qi An and Giuseppe Andronico and Н. Анфимов and V. Antonelli and Tatiana Antoshkina and Burin Asavapibhop and J. P. A. M. de André and Didier Auguste and Weidong Bai and Nikita Balashov and W. Baldini and Andrea Barresi and D. Basilico and E. Baussan and Marco Bellato and Antonio Bergnoli and Thilo Birkenfeld and Sylvie Blin and David Blum and S.C. Blyth and Anastasia Bolshakova and M. Bongrand and Clément Bordereau and D. Breton and A. Brigatti and R. Brugnera and Riccardo Bruno and A. Budano and José Busto and Ilya Butorov and A. Cabrera and Barbara Caccianiga and Hao Cai and X. Cai and Yanke Cai and Zhiyan Cai and Riccardo Callegari and Antonio Cammi and Agustín Campeny and Chuanya Cao and G. F. Cao and Jun Cao and R. Caruso and C. Cerna and Chi Kuen Chan and J. F. Chang and Yun Chang and Guo-Ming Chen and Pingping Chen and Po-An Chen and Shaomin Chen and Xurong Chen and Yixue Chen and Yu Chen and Zhiyuan Chen and Zikang Chen and Jie Cheng and Yaping Cheng and Alexander Chepurnov and Alexey Chetverikov and D. Chiesa and P. Chimenti and A. Chukanov and Gérard Claverie and Catia Clementi and Barbara Clerbaux and Marta Colomer Molla and Selma Conforti Di Lorenzo and Daniele Corti and F. Dal Corso and Olivia Dalager and C. De La Taille and Zhi Deng and Z. Y. Deng and Wilfried Depnering and M. A. Díaz and Xuefeng Ding and Yayun Ding and Bayu Dirgantara and Sergey Dmitrievsky and Tadeáš Dohnal and Dmitry Dolzhikov and Georgy Donchenko and J. Dong and E. Doroshkevich},
title = {{Model-independent Approach of the JUNO <sup>8</sup>B Solar Neutrino Program}},
journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
year = {2024},
doi = {10.3847/1538-4357/ad2bfd},
}