Model-Free Robust $\phi$-Divergence Reinforcement Learning Using Both Offline and Online Data

Kishan Panaganti, Adam Wierman, Eric Mazumdar

Introduction

Reinforcement learning (RL) has demonstrated remarkable success in simulated environments, yet the transition from simulation to real-world deployment remains a significant challenge. This "sim-to-real gap" arises because simulators are inherently imperfect representations of reality, often failing to account for unmodeled physics, sensor degradation, or environmental shifts. To address this, researchers have turned to Robust Markov Decision Processes (RMDPs), which seek policies that perform well across a set of possible models rather than a single nominal one.

In this work, accepted for ICML 2024, researchers Kishan Panaganti, Adam Wierman, and Eric Mazumdar present a novel theoretical framework for robust RL. Their approach introduces two model-free algorithms, RPQ and HyTQ, which utilize φ-divergence regularization to achieve robustness without the computational burden of explicitly modeling environment dynamics.

The Challenge of Robustness in RL

Standard RL assumes that the training environment (the simulator) and the deployment environment are identical. When this assumption fails, agent performance typically collapses. Robust RL aims to mitigate this by optimizing for the worst-case scenario within a defined uncertainty set. However, traditional robust methods face two primary obstacles:

  1. The Model-Free Requirement: Most robust RL methods are model-based, requiring the estimation of transition dynamics. In high-dimensional state spaces, this estimation is often computationally prohibitive.
  2. The Coverage Problem: Offline RL relies on historical datasets. If these datasets do not sufficiently cover the state-action space required by a robust policy (the "out-of-distribution" problem), the resulting agent will be unreliable.

Methodology: φ-Divergence Regularization

The authors propose using φ-divergence regularization to define the uncertainty set. Instead of a hard-coded set of environments, they apply a penalty based on the statistical distance (divergence) between the nominal simulator and potential real-world variations.

A key contribution of this paper is a dual reformulation of the robust objective. By transforming a complex min-max optimization problem—where an adversary selects the worst environment while the agent selects the best action—into a simpler minimization problem, the authors enable the development of model-free updates that depend only on the nominal simulator.

Proposed Algorithms

  • RPQ (Robust φ-regularized fitted Q-iteration): An offline algorithm designed for fixed datasets. It employs a two-step update process: first, it solves for a dual-variable function to account for model uncertainty, and second, it performs least-squares regression to update the Q-values.
  • HyTQ (Hybrid robust Total-variation-regularized Q-iteration): A hybrid algorithm that augments offline data with limited online interaction. This allows the agent to actively explore and "fill in the gaps" where the offline data is insufficient, significantly relaxing the data coverage requirements.

Theoretical Insights and Results

The paper focuses on providing rigorous mathematical guarantees for these algorithms in high-dimensional systems using general function approximation (e.g., neural networks).

  • Suboptimality Bounds: The authors prove that the performance gap between the learned policy and the optimal robust policy vanishes at a rate of $1/\sqrt{N}$, where $N$ is the number of samples.
  • Sample Efficiency in Hybrid Learning: A major finding is that hybrid learning (HyTQ) drastically reduces the required data quality. While pure offline RL requires global data coverage, the hybrid framework only requires coverage over the path taken by the optimal robust policy.
  • Unified Analysis: The framework is not limited to a single type of uncertainty. The authors provide a unified analysis that applies to a broad class of φ-divergences, including KL divergence, Total Variation, and Chi-square.

Limitations and Future Directions

While the paper advances the state of robust RL, several areas for future work remain. The hybrid analysis (HyTQ) is currently specialized for Total Variation (TV) distance; extending these guarantees to other divergences like KL is a non-trivial theoretical challenge. Additionally, the two-step optimization process required to find the dual function and the Q-function adds computational complexity that may require specialized stabilization techniques when implemented in deep neural network architectures. Finally, the authors note that while their statistical rates are strong, they may not yet reach the absolute minimax optimal limits, suggesting room for further refinement of the bounds.

Summary updated

Abstract

The robust $\phi$-regularized Markov Decision Process (RRMDP) framework focuses on designing control policies that are robust against parameter uncertainties due to mismatches between the simulator (nominal) model and real-world settings. This work makes *two* important contributions. First, we propose a *model-free* algorithm called *Robust $\phi$-regularized fitted Q-iteration* for learning an $\epsilon$-optimal robust policy that uses only the historical data collected by rolling out a behavior policy (with *robust exploratory* requirement) on the nominal model. To the best of our knowledge, we provide the *first* unified analysis for a class of $\phi$-divergences achieving robust optimal policies in high-dimensional systems of arbitrary large state space with general function approximation. Second, we introduce the *hybrid robust $\phi$-regularized reinforcement learning* framework to learn an optimal robust policy using both historical data and online sampling. Towards this framework, we propose a model-free algorithm called *Hybrid robust Total-variation-regularized Q-iteration*. To the best of our knowledge, we provide the *first* improved out-of-data-distribution assumption in large-scale problems of arbitrary large state space with general function approximation under the hybrid robust $\phi$-regularized reinforcement learning framework.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{panaganti2024model,
  author = {Kishan Panaganti and Adam Wierman and Eric Mazumdar},
  title = {{Model-Free Robust $\textbackslash\{\}phi$-Divergence Reinforcement Learning Using Both Offline and Online Data}},
  booktitle = {International Conference on Machine Learning},
  year = {2024},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=Yug1IEkvcb},
}
Figure