Abstract
Directed acyclic graphs (DAGs) are a popular framework to express multivariate probability distributions. Acyclic directed mixed graphs (ADMGs) are generalizations of DAGs that can succinctly capture much richer sets of conditional independencies, and are especially useful in modeling the effects of latent variables implicitly. Unfortunately there are currently no good parameterizations of general ADMGs. In this paper, we apply recent work on cumulative distribution networks and copulas to propose one general construction for ADMG models. We consider a simple parameter estimation approach, and report some encouraging experimental results.
Introduction
Originally appearing in 2010 and updated in 2018, this research addresses a fundamental hurdle in probabilistic graphical modeling: how to efficiently represent and learn models that include both directed and bi-directed relationships. The authors introduce Mixed Cumulative Distribution Networks (MCDNs), a novel framework for parameterizing Acyclic Directed Mixed Graphs (ADMGs). By combining Cumulative Distribution Networks (CDNs) with copula theory, they provide a flexible way to model complex dependencies and latent variables that traditional Directed Acyclic Graphs (DAGs) struggle to capture.
The Challenge: Beyond Directed Acyclic Graphs
While Directed Acyclic Graphs (DAGs) are the workhorse of causal inference and probabilistic modeling, they are not "closed under marginalization." If a researcher marginalizes out (ignores) certain variables in a large DAG, the resulting dependencies among the remaining variables often cannot be represented by a new DAG without introducing significant complexity or losing structural information.
Acyclic Directed Mixed Graphs (ADMGs) solve this by adding bi-directed edges ($\leftrightarrow$), which represent the influence of unobserved "latent" common causes. However, ADMGs are notoriously difficult to parameterize. Previous attempts were either restricted to Gaussian distributions or suffered from an exponential explosion in the number of parameters. The MCDN framework aims to provide a general, computationally feasible construction for any ADMG.
The MCDN Framework: From Graphs to Distributions
The authors propose a multi-step approach to build a valid probability distribution that respects the constraints of an ADMG:
- District Factorization: The graph is decomposed into "districts"—sets of nodes connected by bi-directed edges. The joint distribution is then represented as a product of conditional distributions for each district.
- The "Barren" Reduction: A "barren" district is one where no node is a parent of another node within the same district. The authors show that any complex ADMG can be transformed into a version with only barren districts by introducing "artificial vertices." This simplifies the mathematics significantly without losing modeling power.
- Copula Integration: To model the dependencies within a district, the researchers use copulas. Copulas allow for the specification of marginal distributions (e.g., Gaussian, Bernoulli, Poisson) separately from the dependence structure.
- CDF-based Modeling: A key insight of the paper is that while defining dependencies in the space of Probability Density Functions (PDFs) is difficult for ADMGs, it becomes much more manageable in the space of Cumulative Distribution Functions (CDFs).
Experimental Evaluation
The authors evaluated the MCDN framework on several datasets, including synthetic benchmarks like the Insurance and Alarm networks, and real-world data from the UCI Repository such as Wisconsin Breast Cancer and SPECTF.
Key Results
- Improved Predictive Power: On the Insurance, Alarm, and Breast Cancer datasets, the MCDN significantly outperformed "overparameterized" DAGs. The improvement was measured in millibits of log-predictive probability per observation.
- Parsimony: The MCDN achieved these results with far fewer parameters than a DAG would require to capture the same complex marginal dependencies.
- Mixed Results on Continuous Data: On the SPECTF cardiac imaging dataset, the MCDN performed worse than a standard Gaussian DAG. The authors attribute this to a suboptimal fitting procedure and the restriction of bi-directed components to simple tree structures for computational ease.
Limitations and Future Work
While MCDNs offer a powerful new tool, some limitations remain. The current three-step estimation process, while fast, is not a true Maximum Likelihood Estimate (MLE). Developing more robust, simultaneous learning algorithms is a clear next step. Furthermore, this paper focuses on parameterizing a known graph; learning the structure of an ADMG from scratch remains a difficult open problem for future research.
Summary updated